G.R. No. L-52324. November 23, 1981

MAR-BAY & COMPANY, INC., PETITIONER, VS. M. G. SUNTAY TRADING CO., INC. AND THE HONORABLE COURT OF APPEALS, RESPONDENTS.

Decisions / Signed Resolutions November 23, 1981 FIRST DIVISION GUERRERO, J.:
Download PDF


GUERRERO, J.:


Petitioner Mar-Bay & Company, Inc., thru its President,
Agustin Tanco, and private respondent M. G. Suntay Trading Co., Inc., also thru
its President, Manolita G. Suntay, have filed and submitted to the Court a
Compromise Agreement executed by and between them in representation of their
respective corporations on October 14, 1981 and duly acknowledged on October
27, 1981, which Compromise Agreement resolving their mutual claims and settling
the incident brought before this Court by the instant petition for review,
stipu­lates the following terms and conditions, to wit:

“1.  That both parties agree to the withdrawal and
release of the amount of P5,500,000.00 held and retained under the restraining
orders of the Supreme Court issued to the Development Bank of the Philippines
on September 12, 1980 (re P1.5 million loan proceeds) and September 19, 1980
(re P4 million loan proceeds);

 2.   That
both parties agree that from said amount of P5,500,000.00, petitioner Mar-Bay
& Co., Inc., thru its duly authorized President, Agustin Tanco, will
collect and receive from the Deve­lopment Bank of the Philippines the amount of
Four million five hundred thousand pesos (P4,500,000.00); that private
respondent M. G. Suntay Trading Co., Inc., thru its duly authorized President,
Manolita G. Suntay, will collect and receive from the Develop­ment Bank of the
Philippines the amount of One million pesos (P1,000,000.00);

 3.   That
petitioner Mar-Bay & Co., Inc. will post a surety bond in the amount of Two
million pesos (P2,000,000.00) to be secured from the
Commonwealth Insu­rance Company, Makati, Rizal or State Bonding & Insurance
Co., Inc., Escolta, Manila in favor of respondent M. G. Suntay Trading Co.,
Inc. to answer for the default, failure or non-performance of Mar-Bay &
Co., Inc. to comply with its undertaking under stipulation No. 6 of this
Compromise Agreement;

 4.   That
both parties agree to the immediate dismissal and/or withdrawal of the above
petition pending before this Honorable Court docketed as G.R. No. 52324;

 5.   That
with respect to the case between the parties entitled ‘M. G. Suntay Trading
Co., Inc. vs. Mar-Bay & Co., Inc.’ decided by Judge Lino Añover, Civil Case
No. 0-24460, CFI of Quezon City, and now pending appeal on the merits in the
Court of Appeals, both parties agree to accept and abide with whatever decision
or judgment to be rendered by the Court of Appeals; and both parties agree to
waive any further appeal to the Supreme Court on any matter, point or issue
decided by the Court of Appeals;

 6.   That
both parties agree that petitioner Mar-Bay & Co., Inc. will pay to private
respondent M. G. Suntay Trading Co., Inc. thru their respective Presidents duly
authorized the total amount in rentals for the 20-year period (1977 to 1997)
less the P1 million per par. 7
and rentals already paid by Mar-Bay and collected by M. G. Suntay Trading Co.,
which total amount in lump sum shall be paid by Mar-Bay & Co. in two (2)
equal installments:  the first
installment of 50% shall be paid upon final judgment by the Court of Appeals,
and the second installment of 50% shall be paid within six (6) months
thereafter, without interest;

 7.   That
both parties request the Honorable Supreme Court to approve this Compromise
Agreement, to order the release of P5.5 million subject to its restraining
orders and order the Development Bank of the Philippines to pay petitioner
Mar-Bay & Co., thru its duly authorized President, Agustin Tanco, the sum
of P4.5 million and to private respondent, M. G. Suntay Trading Co., thru its
duly authorized President, Manolita G. Suntay, the sum of P1,000,000.00 in
accordance with this Compromise Agreement, and to dismiss the instant petition
for review.”

Pursuant to said Compromise Agreement, the parties assisted by
their respective counsel, filed a Joint Manifestation and Motion reiterating
that the Compromise Agreement be approved; that judgment be rendered accor­ding
to the terms and conditions of said Agreement including the guarantee of a
personal bond in the amount of P500,000.00 executed by petitioner Agustin
Tanco; that the restraining orders issued pursuant to the Court Resolutions
dated September 12, 1980 and September 19, 1980 be lifted; that the Development
Bank of the Philippines be ordered to pay petitioner Mar-Bay & Co., thru
its President, Agustin Tanco, the sum of P4.5 million and to pay private
respondent M. G. Suntay Trading Co., Inc., thru its President, Manolita G.
Suntay, the sum of P1,000,000.00, both from the funds thus restrained; and to
dismiss the petition.

We find the Compromise Agreement entered into by the parties and
herein submitted to the Court to be proper and duly authorized, confirmed and
ratified by the Board of Directors of both corporations as attested by the
Corporate Secretaries.  Accordingly, We approve the same since the terms and conditions are not contrary
to law, morals, good custom, public order and public policy.

The parties are hereby enjoined to comply strictly, faithfully
and honestly in all good faith the terms, conditions and stipulations therein
contained.

WHEREFORE, IN VIEW OF THE FOREGOING, judgment is hereby
rendered:

1.  Approving the Compromise
Agreement;

2.  Lifting the restraining
orders issued by the Court pursuant to Resolutions dated September 12, 1980 and September 19, 1980;

3.  Directing the Development
Bank of the Philippines to pay petitioner Mar-Bay & Co., Inc., thru its
President, Agustin Tanco, the sum of P4.5
million and to respondent M. G. Suntay Trading Co., Inc., thru its
President, Manolita G. Suntay, the sum of P1,000,000.00, both from the P5.5
million loan proceeds heretofore restrained; and

4.  Dismissing the petition,
the same having been rendered moot and academic.

No costs.

SO ORDERED.

Teehankee, Acting C.J., Makasiar, Fernandez, and Melencio-Herrera, JJ., concur.