🎧 Case Brief Lecture

PINES CITY EDUCATIONAL CENTER AND EUGENIO BALTAO, PETITIONERS, VS. THE NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION (THIRD DIVISION) AND DANGWA BENTREZ, ROLAND PICART, APOLLO RIBAYA, SR.…

G.R. No. 96779. November 10, 1993 November 10, 1993

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Pines City Educational Center versus National Labor Relations Commission

The Case

This is a petition for certiorari brought by Pines City Educational Center, through its President Eugenio Baltao, against the National Labor Relations Commission and ten of its former teachers. The school asks the Supreme Court to reverse the Commission's resolution affirming the Labor Arbiter's award of reinstatement and full backwages to the teachers. The case matters because it draws the line between two kinds of fixed-term teaching contracts: those knowingly and voluntarily agreed upon, which may lawfully expire, and those that are merely devices to circumvent security of tenure, which cannot. It is also the case that restored the rule deducting income earned elsewhere from an illegally dismissed employee's backwages.

Procedural History

The ten teachers filed a complaint for illegal dismissal before the Labor Arbiter. The Labor Arbiter ruled for them, ordering their immediate reinstatement and the payment of full backwages and other benefits, and denying their other money claims for lack of merit. The school appealed to the National Labor Relations Commission, which affirmed the Labor Arbiter in full, adding that a stipulation fixing a definite period of employment is void because it offends the safeguards of Article 280 of the Labor Code. The school then came to the Supreme Court on a petition for certiorari, and the Court issued a temporary restraining order enjoining enforcement of the Commission's resolution.

Facts

The ten private respondents were employed as teachers on probationary basis by Pines City Educational Center. All but one were hired as college instructors; Jane Bentrez was hired as a grade school teacher. All of them, except Roland Picart and Lucia Chan, signed contracts of employment for a fixed duration. Dangwa Bentrez had a one-year contract running from June 1988 to March 1989; the others had one-semester contracts running from November 1988 to March 1989. Except for Leila Dominguez, who served one semester, the teachers had been employed for one to two years.

On March 31, 1989, the school notified them that their contracts would no longer be renewed, citing the expiration of the stipulated periods and their poor performance as teachers. The teachers were never informed in writing of the standards or criteria of evaluation that would qualify them for regular appointment.

On April 10, 1989, the teachers filed a complaint for illegal dismissal, alleging that their dismissal was without cause and in violation of due process. The school insisted that the fixed periods in the contracts governed the relationship and that it could not be compelled to enter into new contracts. The Labor Arbiter found the contracts vague, found no written evidence that the Academic Committee had actually evaluated the teachers, and found that they were hastily dismissed without any chance to refute the allegations against them.

Issues

  • Whether or not the National Labor Relations Commission committed grave abuse of discretion in holding that a stipulation fixing a definite period of employment is void under Article 280 of the Labor Code.
  • Whether or not the teachers who knowingly and voluntarily agreed to fixed periods of employment were lawfully terminated upon the expiration of those periods.
  • Whether or not the teachers who signed no fixed-period contract, namely Roland Picart and Lucia Chan, were illegally dismissed.
  • Whether or not the backwages awarded to illegally dismissed employees must be reduced by the income they earned elsewhere during the period of dismissal.

Applicable Provisions

Article 280 of the Labor Code, as quoted in the Commission's resolution, provides:

Article 280. Regular and Casual Employment. The provisions of written agreement to the contrary notwithstanding and regardless of the oral agreement of the parties, an employment shall be deemed to be regular where the employee has been engaged to perform activities which are usually necessary or desirable in the usual business or trade of the employer, except where the employment has been fixed for a specific project or undertaking the completion or termination of which has been determined at the time of the engagement of the employee or where the work or services to be performed is seasonal in nature and the employment is for the duration of the season.

This is the provision the Commission read as outlawing every fixed-period stipulation, and the provision the Court reads more narrowly.

Article 279 of the Labor Code, as amended by Section 34 of Republic Act Number 6715, provides:

Article 279. Security of Tenure. In cases of regular employment, the employer shall not terminate the services of an employee except for a just cause or when authorized by this Title. An employee who is unjustly dismissed from work shall be entitled to reinstatement without loss of seniority rights and other privileges and to his full backwages, inclusive of allowances, and to his other benefits or their monetary equivalent computed from the time his compensation was withheld from him up to the time of his actual reinstatement.

This is the source of the relief granted to the two illegally dismissed teachers, and the provision whose phrase "full backwages" the Court construes against double compensation.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the Commission gravely abused its discretion. The Court had already spoken in the Brent case, and it restated that ruling:

Accordingly, and since the entire purpose behind the development of legislation culminating in the present Article 280 of the Labor Code clearly appears to have been, as already observed, to prevent circumvention of the employees right to be secure in his tenure, the clause in said article indiscriminately and completely ruling out all written or oral agreements conflicting with the concept of regular employment as defined therein should be construed to refer to the substantive evil that the Code itself has singled out: agreements entered into precisely to circumvent security of tenure. It should have no application to instances where a fixed period of employment was agreed upon knowingly and voluntarily by the parties without any force, duress or improper pressure being brought to bear upon the employee and absent any other circumstances vitiating his consent, or where it satisfactorily appears that the employer and employee dealt with each other on more or less equal terms with no moral dominance whatever being exercised by the former over the latter.

The Commission knew of the Brent ruling, the school having invoked it on appeal, yet disregarded it without reason. The Court invoked the maxim stare decisis et non quieta movere, meaning that once a case is decided one way, another case involving exactly the same point should be decided the same way, and warned that to defy its decisions is to court contempt.

On the second issue, applying Brent, the Court held that the eight teachers who knowingly and voluntarily agreed to fixed periods were lawfully terminated by the expiration of their contracts. As to them, the Commission gravely abused its discretion in affirming their reinstatement and backwages.

On the third issue, Roland Picart and Lucia Chan signed no contract fixing a period of employment and never knowingly and voluntarily agreed to one. The burden therefore fell on the school to prove that their termination was legal. As probationary employees they are protected by the constitutional guarantee of security of tenure and cannot be removed except for cause. The school relied on the Academic Committee's evaluation, but the Labor Arbiter found no written proof of it and nothing in the record showing that the two were given even a chance to refute the allegations. The Court concurred in these factual findings, there being no showing that they were resolved arbitrarily, and held the order of reinstatement and full backwages proper under Article 279 as amended.

On the fourth issue, the Court held that in computing the backwages of the two, the total amount they earned elsewhere from dismissal to reinstatement, if any, must be deducted. The reason is that employees should not enrich themselves at the expense of their employer, and the law abhors double compensation. To this extent the Court modified its earlier ruling in the Ferrer case.

Doctrine

First, a stipulation fixing a definite period of employment is not automatically void. Article 280's prohibition against agreements conflicting with regular employment refers only to agreements entered into precisely to circumvent security of tenure. Where the fixed period was agreed upon knowingly and voluntarily, without force, duress, or improper pressure, and absent any circumstance vitiating consent, or where employer and employee dealt on more or less equal terms with no moral dominance by the employer, the contract is valid and employment may lawfully end upon its expiration.

Second, probationary employees enjoy security of tenure and may be removed only for cause. Where no fixed period was agreed upon, the employer bears the burden of proving that the termination was legal, and a bare claim of poor performance, unsupported by written evidence and unaccompanied by any opportunity to refute it, does not discharge that burden.

Third, an illegally dismissed employee is entitled under Article 279, as amended, to reinstatement without loss of seniority rights and to full backwages inclusive of allowances, computed from the time compensation was withheld up to actual reinstatement, but the income he earned elsewhere during the dismissal must be deducted, lest he be unjustly enriched and doubly compensated.

Disposition

The petition was granted in part: the Commission's resolution was modified, Roland Picart and Lucia Chan were ordered reinstated without loss of seniority rights and paid full backwages subject to deduction of income earned elsewhere, the rest of the Labor Arbiter's decision was set aside, and the temporary restraining order was made permanent.

Remember This

Memorize the line that a fixed-term contract is void only when it is a device to circumvent security of tenure, not when it is knowingly and voluntarily agreed upon. Examiners use this case to test the Brent doctrine on fixed-period employment, the burden of proof against probationary employees, and the deduction of income earned elsewhere from backwages.