EDITH JUINIO ATIENZA, PETITIONER, VS. COURT OF APPEALS, HON. SERGIO PESTANO, SALVADORA ATIENZA AND MARIA BEATRIZ ATIENZA, RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Atienza versus Court of Appeals
The Case
This is a petition for certiorari brought by Edith Juinio Atienza, the widow of the late Andres Atienza, against the Court of Appeals and against her mother-in-law Salvadora Atienza and the adopted daughter Maria Beatriz Atienza. The widow asks the Supreme Court to reverse the appellate court and to order the dismissal of a damages, accounting, and partition case filed against her in Roxas City, on the ground that a separate estate proceeding she herself later filed in Quezon City was already pending. The case matters because it is the clean teaching vehicle on litis pendentia, the rule that a case may be dismissed only when another action is pending between the same parties for the same cause, and on the companion rule that an order denying a motion to dismiss is merely interlocutory and cannot be the subject of certiorari.
Procedural History
Salvadora Atienza and Maria Beatriz Atienza filed a complaint for damages, accounting, and partition before the Regional Trial Court of Roxas City. Instead of answering, Edith Juinio Atienza filed a special proceeding for the issuance of letters of administration of the estate before the Quezon City court, and then moved to dismiss the Roxas City case on the ground of litis pendentia. The presiding judge, Sergio Pestano, denied the motion to dismiss and appointed Salvadora Atienza as guardian ad litem of Maria Beatriz Atienza. He likewise denied the widow's motion for reconsideration. The widow then filed an answer in the Roxas City case and, afterwards, went up to the Court of Appeals on a petition for certiorari and prohibition with preliminary injunction, alleging grave abuse of discretion. The Court of Appeals found no grave abuse of discretion, dismissed the petition, and affirmed the trial court's ruling that the Roxas City case could not be dismissed on the ground of litis pendentia. It denied her motion for reconsideration. The widow then elevated the matter to the Supreme Court by petition for certiorari.
Facts
Andres Atienza died intestate on June 26, 1987, leaving three heirs: his mother Salvadora Atienza, his widow Edith Juinio Atienza, and his adopted daughter Maria Beatriz Atienza. On September 21, 1987, Salvadora and Maria Beatriz filed before the Roxas City court a civil case for damages, accounting, and partition against the widow. In their complaint they alleged that the widow used a fake birth certificate of Maria Beatriz in claiming insurance, retirement, and other benefits, and that this tortious act effectively deprived Salvadora of her share in the estate. They prayed that the widow be held liable for moral and exemplary damages and that an accounting and partition be ordered.
Instead of filing an answer, the widow filed a special proceeding for the issuance of letters of administration of the estate before the Quezon City court, and then moved to dismiss the Roxas City case on the ground that a case involving the same parties and the same action was pending before the Quezon City court. The trial court denied the motion, and denied reconsideration as well.
The widow then answered the Roxas City complaint and later sought relief from the Court of Appeals. That court saw that the Quezon City special proceeding was filed by the widow long after the Roxas City case was instituted, and that her motion to dismiss came after she had been granted an extension of time to file an answer, enabling her in the meantime to institute the Quezon City proceeding she then used to seek dismissal. The appellate court also noted that the Roxas City case was already much in progress, with a complaint and an answer with counterclaim filed, fully joining the issues. On February 11, 1991, while the case was pending, Salvadora Atienza died and was survived by her sole heir and daughter, Suzette Atienza del Rosario, whose substitution the Court later granted.
Issues
- Whether or not litis pendentia obtains between the Roxas City civil case for damages, accounting, and partition and the Quezon City special proceeding for the settlement of the estate, such that the civil case should be dismissed.
- Whether or not an order denying a motion to dismiss may be the basis of a petition for certiorari.
Applicable Provisions
Section 1 of Rule 16 of the Rules of Court, on the grounds for a motion to dismiss, provides:
Section 1. Grounds. Within the time for pleading a Motion to Dismiss the action may be made on any of the following grounds: xxx xxx xxx (e) That there is another action pending between the same parties for the same cause.
This is the provision the widow invokes, and its requirement of the same parties and the same cause is the very element the Court finds missing.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that litis pendentia does not obtain, and it adopted the appellate court's statement of the requisites: identity of parties or at least such as represent the same interest in both actions; identity of rights asserted and reliefs prayed for, the relief being founded on the same facts; and such identity that a judgment in the pending case, regardless of which party succeeds, would amount to res judicata in the other. Not all these requisites are present. While the parties in both cases are the heirs of Andres Atienza, the causes of action differ. The Roxas City case is for damages, accounting, and partition, whereas the Quezon City proceeding is for the intestate estate of the deceased. In the civil case the plaintiffs seek to recover moral damages arising from alleged tortious acts, and a decision there would not be res judicata in the estate proceeding. The prayer for partition is merely an incident of a finding that the widow committed wrongful acts to acquire the decedent's properties to the prejudice of the complainants.
The Court distinguished the widow's cited cases. In Teodoro versus Mirasol, the first case was dismissed because the claim for damages was not the central cause of action but merely an incident of the main question, and was not alleged as an independent cause of action in a separate paragraph as the Rules require. Here, the civil case is principally for damages and is alleged as the first cause of action. Arcillas versus Montejo, far from helping the widow, only reaffirms the options granted by law to the heirs, either a special proceeding for the settlement of the estate or an ordinary action of partition.
The Court also stressed that the Quezon City proceeding was filed long after the Roxas City case, and that the widow filed it only as an afterthought to evade liability for her alleged tortious acts should they be proved. The Court would not sanction that behavior by ordering dismissal of the civil case.
On the second issue, the Court held that an order denying a motion to dismiss is merely interlocutory and cannot be the basis of a petition for certiorari. It quoted its own ruling:
An order that does not finally dispose of the case, and does not end the Court's task of adjudicating the parties' contentions and determining their rights and liabilities as regards each other, but obviously indicates that other things remain to be done by the Court, is interlocutory, e.g., an order denying a motion to dismiss under Rule 16 of the Rules, or granting a motion for extension of time to file a pleading, or authorizing amendment thereof, or granting or denying applications for postponement, or production or inspection of documents or things, etc. Unlike a final judgment or order, which is appealable, as above pointed out, an interlocutory order may not be questioned on appeal except only as part of an appeal that may eventually be taken from the final judgment rendered in the case.
The remedy, the Court said, is appeal in due course after the case has been decided on the merits. To allow all interlocutory orders to be reviewed by certiorari would delay the administration of justice and unduly burden the courts.
Doctrine
For a motion to dismiss under Section 1 of Rule 16 on the ground that another action is pending, the three requisites of litis pendentia must concur: identity of parties, identity of rights asserted and reliefs prayed for founded on the same facts, and such identity that a judgment in the pending case would amount to res judicata in the other. A special proceeding for the settlement of an estate and an ordinary action for damages, accounting, and partition do not share the same cause of action, so litis pendentia does not lie. An order denying a motion to dismiss is interlocutory and is not reviewable by certiorari; the remedy is an appeal in due course from the final judgment. And a party may not manufacture the ground for dismissal by filing a second case after the first, for that is an afterthought the Court will not sanction.
Disposition
The petition was denied for lack of merit and the decision of the Court of Appeals was affirmed in its entirety, with costs, and the substitution of Suzette Atienza del Rosario for the deceased Salvadora Atienza was granted.
Remember This
The one line to memorize: litis pendentia requires identity of parties, of rights and reliefs, and of such identity that judgment in one would be res judicata in the other, and an order denying a motion to dismiss is interlocutory and not a proper subject of certiorari. Examiners use this case to test the requisites of litis pendentia and the rule that the remedy from a denied motion to dismiss is appeal, not certiorari.