NICANOR SOMODIO, PETITIONER, VS. COURT OF APPEALS, EBENECER PURISIMA AND FELOMINO AYCO, RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Somodio versus Court of Appeals
The Case
This is a petition for review on certiorari brought by Nicanor Somodio against the Court of Appeals, Ebenecer Purisima, and Felomino Ayco. Somodio asks the Supreme Court to reverse the appellate court's dismissal of his two ejectment complaints and to restore the rulings of the municipal and regional trial courts in his favor. The case matters because it draws a bright line between possession and ownership, and because it reminds every reviewee that in ejectment the only question is who held the property first in fact, not who can prove title.
Procedural History
Somodio filed two separate complaints before the Municipal Trial Court, Branch One, General Santos: an action for unlawful detainer with damages against Ayco, and a complaint for forcible entry against Purisima. The two cases were consolidated. On April 30, 1986, the Municipal Trial Court ruled for Somodio, ordering the private respondents to remove their houses, deliver the land to him, and pay attorney's fees and litigation expenses. On appeal, the Regional Trial Court, Branch 22, General Santos City, affirmed the Municipal Trial Court in full. The respondents then elevated the matter to the Court of Appeals on a petition for review. The Court of Appeals, in a decision dated September 29, 1987, set aside the decisions of both trial courts and ordered the dismissal of Somodio's complaints, holding that he had not clearly and conclusively established physical, prior possession over the lot. Somodio's motion for reconsideration was denied, so he filed this petition for review on certiorari under Rule 45 of the Revised Rules of Court.
Facts
On October 21, 1974, Jose Ortigas executed an instrument called a Transfer of Rights, conveying to Wilfredo Mabugat the possession of a residential lot in Rajah Muda, Bula, General Santos City. Somodio contributed one-half of the purchase price. The next day, Mabugat executed an Affidavit of Trust expressly recognizing Somodio's right over one-half undivided portion of the lot. Somodio later learned from the District Land Office that the lot was numbered 6328-X, Csd 2281-D. He and Mabugat then partitioned the property, with Somodio taking the western part. Immediately after the partition, Somodio took possession of his portion and planted ipil-ipil trees, coconut trees, and other fruit-bearing trees.
In 1976, Somodio began constructing a structure twenty-two by eighteen feet on his lot. His employment took him to Kidapawan, North Cotabato, and he left the unfinished structure in the care of his uncle, visiting the property every three months or on weekends when he had time. In October 1977, he allowed respondent Ayco to transfer his hut to the lot. About six years later, Somodio demanded that Ayco vacate, but the demand proved futile. On August 23, 1983, Somodio filed the unlawful detainer case against Ayco.
Meanwhile, on June 26, 1983, respondent Purisima entered the land and constructed a house on it. Four days later, Somodio filed the forcible entry complaint against Purisima. Purisima claimed the lot was a portion of the land covered by his application for a miscellaneous sales patent, describing it as Lot 6328-Y, and contended that his father, a geodetic engineer, had surveyed the area for the Small Farmers Fishpond Association, Inc. in 1958, with the survey plan approved by the Director of Lands in 1960. Ayco presented no evidence of his own and merely anchored his right on Purisima's evidence. The trial court found that Purisima built his house almost on the spot where Somodio's unfinished house stood, through stealth and strategy, and that the houses of both respondents stood inside Lot 6328-X, not on Lot 6328-Y.
Issues
- Whether or not the petition for review may be entertained even though it raises questions of fact already passed upon by the Court of Appeals.
- Whether or not Somodio established prior possession de facto over Lot 6328-X, entitling him to recover possession from the private respondents.
- Whether or not Somodio properly identified the lot he occupied.
- Whether or not a ruling on possession in an ejectment case amounts to a determination of ownership.
Applicable Provisions
Article 531 of the Civil Code of the Philippines provides:
Possession is acquired by the material occupation of a thing or the exercise of a right, or by the fact that it is subject to the action of our will, or by the proper acts and legal formalities established for acquiring such right.
This provision supplies the test of possession: Somodio need not have his feet on every square meter of ground, so long as the property was subjected to the action of his will.
Ruling
On the procedural issue, the Court held that although the findings of fact of the Court of Appeals are generally binding, the rule admits exceptions, one of which is when the factual findings of the Court of Appeals and the trial court are contrary to each other. Here they were contrary, so the Court scrutinized the evidence on record to arrive at the correct findings.
On prior possession, the Court ruled for Somodio. In ejectment cases, the only issue is who is entitled to the physical or material possession of the property, independent of any claim of ownership. Anyone who can prove prior possession de facto may recover such possession even from the owner himself, and this holds regardless of the character of the possession, provided the claimant has priority of time entitling him to stay until lawfully ejected through accion publiciana or accion reivindicatoria. Somodio took possession in 1974 when he planted the property, and began construction in 1976. The Court held it immaterial that the building was unfinished and that he visited only intermittently, because possession does not mean a man must have his feet on every square meter of ground; it is enough that he subjected the property to the action of his will. Even on the Court of Appeals' finding that improvements began only in 1981, Somodio still had priority, since Purisima entered only in 1983. The father's survey did not help Purisima, because the survey was made for the association, not for the father, and there was no proof that the father ever exercised possession between 1958 and 1983 or authorized Purisima to enter as his successor-in-interest. Priority in time was the pivotal cog.
On identification, the Court held the matter was settled by Purisima's own admissions in his pleadings and by two ocular inspections, which confirmed that Lots 6328-X and 6328-Y are distinct and that the respondents' houses stood on Lot 6328-X.
On ownership, the Court stressed that Somodio's prior possession is not synonymous with ownership. Forcible entry is merely a quieting process and never determines the actual title to an estate.
Doctrine
- In ejectment, the only issue is physical or material possession de facto, independent of any claim of ownership; prior possession, however acquired, prevails until the claimant is lawfully ejected by one with a better right.
- Possession is acquired by material occupation or by subjecting the thing to the action of one's will, as Article 531 of the Civil Code declares; intermittent visits and an unfinished structure do not defeat it.
- Priority in time is the pivotal cog in resolving possession where no party has produced tax declarations or public land applications.
- A judgment in forcible entry quiets possession only and never determines title.
- The factual findings of the Court of Appeals are generally binding, but not when they conflict with those of the trial court.
Disposition
The Court granted the petition, reversed and set aside the decision of the Court of Appeals, reinstated the decisions of the trial courts, and taxed costs against the private respondents.
Remember This
Memorize the line that possession in the eyes of the law does not require a man to have his feet on every square meter of ground; it is enough that the property is subject to the action of his will. Examiners use this case to test the possession-versus-ownership distinction in ejectment and the exception to the binding effect of the Court of Appeals' factual findings.