IN THE MATTER OF THE PETITION FOR HABEAS CORPUS OF LEONARDO PAQUINTO AND JESUS CABANGUNAY. CHAIRMAN SEDFREY A. ORDOÑEZ, COMM. SAMUEL M. SORIANO, COMM. HESIQUIO R. MALLILLIN, COM…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Ordoñez versus Director of Prisons
The Case
This is a petition for habeas corpus brought before the Supreme Court by the Commission on Human Rights, through its Chairman Sedfrey A. Ordoñez, on behalf of two prisoners, Leonardo Paquinto and Jesus Cabangunay, against the Director of Prisons. The two men had been convicted by military commissions during martial law, their convictions were later nullified because those commissions had no jurisdiction over civilians, and yet they remained in detention for years because the government never filed new charges against them in the civil courts. The case matters because it fixes the consequence of an unlawful detention that the State itself cannot cure: when the government can no longer prosecute, the prisoner does not keep serving the sentence — the prisoner goes free. It is also a leading statement on the nature of liberty under the Bill of Rights.
Procedural History
The case began, in effect, with the earlier ruling of the Supreme Court in the Olaguer case, which nullified the convictions of civilians tried by military commissions while the civil courts were functioning. In the later Cruz case, the Court directed the Department of Justice to file the corresponding informations against such civilians in the civil courts within one hundred eighty days from notice of the decision. No information was ever filed against Paquinto and Cabangunay. The Commission on Human Rights then filed this petition for habeas corpus directly with the Supreme Court as an original action. The Court immediately issued the writ, returnable on or before June 22, 1994, and set the case for hearing on that same date. After hearing, and after the Office of the Solicitor General submitted its memorandum, the Court decided the petition.
Facts
Leonardo Paquinto and Jesus Cabangunay were civilians tried by military commissions during martial law. Both were originally condemned to die by musketry, but their sentence was commuted to reclusion perpetua under the new Constitution. Their convictions were then nullified by the Supreme Court in the Olaguer case, which held that the military tribunals had no jurisdiction to try civilians when the courts of justice were functioning. In the Cruz case, the Court ordered the Department of Justice to file the proper informations against them in the civil courts within one hundred eighty days. No information was ever filed, yet the two remained under detention, confined since 1974.
On May 27, 1992, Ernesto Abaloc, together with Cabangunay and Paquinto, wrote to the United Nations Human Rights Committee, complaining that their continued detention violated their rights under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. In a decision dated October 14, 1993, the Committee declared the communication admissible and asked the Republic of the Philippines to explain the complaint within six months. The Department of Foreign Affairs furnished a copy to the Commission on Human Rights, whose Chairman then wrote the Secretary of Justice of its intention to sue for the release of the complainants unless criminal charges had already been filed. The Department of Justice replied that Abaloc had been released, that Paquinto and Cabangunay were still detained at the National Penitentiary, and intimated that it would not object to a petition for habeas corpus on their behalf.
The petition was filed on June 13, 1994. At the hearing, the Solicitor General argued that under the Tan case the Olaguer ruling could not be applied retroactively to persons already serving sentence, and that the prisoners' remedy was to pursue executive clemency. He submitted a letter from a lawyer, Atty. Anselmo Mabuti, saying that Paquinto chose to complete the service of his sentence. When questioned directly by the Court, however, both prisoners disowned that lawyer, said they had never met him, and denied authorizing the letter. They asked instead to be released on the strength of the Olaguer decision. The government's main excuse for not filing charges was that the records of the cases had allegedly been burned.
Issues
- Whether or not the continued detention of Paquinto and Cabangunay is lawful, given that their convictions were nullified and no informations were ever filed against them in the civil courts.
- Whether or not the loss of the records of their cases, which prevents the government from prosecuting them anew, may justify their continued imprisonment.
- Whether or not the prisoners' alleged choice to serve their sentence and seek executive clemency bars their release.
Applicable Provisions
The decision rests on the constitutional guarantee of liberty, which the Court invokes in declaring that liberty is not a grant of the State. The Court states the principle in these words:
Liberty is not a gift of the government but the right of the governed.
This principle governs the whole petition: because liberty inheres in the person, detention must rest on a valid conviction or pending charge, and here there is neither.
The Court also applies its own earlier directive in the Cruz case, which it quotes:
Those civilians who were convicted by military courts and who have been serving (but not yet completed) their sentences of imprisonment for the past many years may be given the option either to complete the service of their sentence, or be tried anew by the civil courts. Upon conviction, they should be credited in the service of their sentence for the full period of their previous imprisonment. Upon acquittal, they should be set free.
That directive required the government either to try the prisoners anew or to release them, and it is the measure against which the government's inaction is judged.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the detention is unlawful. There is absolutely no question that the prisoners' plea should be heeded. The government failed to show that their continued detention is supported by a valid conviction, by the pendency of charges, or by any legitimate cause whatsoever. Their convictions had been nullified, and no informations were filed within the period fixed in the Cruz case. In the eyes of the law, Paquinto and Cabangunay are not guilty, or do not appear to be guilty, of any crime for which they may be validly held. They are therefore entitled to be set free.
On the second issue, the Court rejected the loss of the records as an excuse. It is not the fault of the prisoners that the records cannot now be found; they were not the custodians of those records. It is illogical and even absurd to suggest that because the government cannot prosecute them, the prisoners' detention must continue. The Court put the rule plainly:
If no information can be filed against them because the records have been lost, it is not the prisoners who should be made to suffer.
On the third issue, the Court likewise rejected the claim that the prisoners had opted to serve their sentence. When questioned directly, both disowned the lawyer who wrote the letter, and Paquinto denied authorizing it. No mention was made of Cabangunay at all. The Court gave no weight to the letter and honored the prisoners' actual plea for release.
Underlying all three rulings is the Court's conception of liberty: it is not derived from the sufferance of the government, or its magnanimity, or even from the Constitution, which merely affirms but does not grant it. Liberty inheres in every person as a member of the human family, and when one person is deprived of it, all are diminished, for liberty is total and indivisible.
Doctrine
A detention is lawful only if it rests on a valid conviction, on pending criminal charges, or on some other legitimate cause. When a conviction is nullified for want of jurisdiction and the State fails to file new charges within the period fixed by the Court, the detention loses its legal basis and the prisoner must be released.
The failure or inability of the government to prosecute — including the loss of the case records — cannot be charged against the prisoner. The burden of the State's own default falls on the State, not on the person detained.
Liberty is not a gift of the government but the right of the governed; the Constitution merely affirms it and does not grant it. Every person is free unless the law validly limits that freedom because he has affronted the rights of others or offended the public welfare.
Disposition
The petition was granted, and the Court ordered Jesus Cabangunay and Leonardo Paquinto released immediately.
Remember This
Memorize the line: liberty is not a gift of the government but the right of the governed — and the State's inability to prosecute can never be the prisoner's penalty. Examiners use this case for the requisites of lawful detention and for the rule that a nullified military conviction, unaccompanied by new charges, entitles the prisoner to immediate release through habeas corpus.