🎧 Case Brief Lecture

MAYOR PABLO P. MAGTAJAS & THE CITY OF CAGAYAN DE ORO, PETITIONERS, VS. PRYCE PROPERTIES CORPORATION, INC. & PHILIPPINE AMUSEMENT AND GAMING CORPORATION, RESPONDENTS.

G.R. No. 111097. July 20, 1994 July 20, 1994

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Magtajas versus Pryce Properties Corporation

The Case

This is a petition for review filed by Mayor Pablo P. Magtajas and the City of Cagayan de Oro against Pryce Properties Corporation, Incorporated and the Philippine Amusement and Gaming Corporation, or PAGCOR. The City assails the decision of the Court of Appeals striking down two ordinances that banned the operation of a casino within the city. The case matters because it draws the boundary between the police power of local government units and the national policy embodied in a special law, and because it settles, as a rule of statutory construction, that local councils may suppress illegal gambling but may not prohibit games of chance that Congress itself has authorized.

Procedural History

Pryce Properties Corporation, Incorporated challenged the two ordinances before the Court of Appeals, where PAGCOR joined as intervenor and supplemental petitioner. The challenge succeeded. The Court of Appeals declared the ordinances invalid and issued the writ prayed for to prohibit their enforcement. The City moved for reconsideration, and that motion was denied. The City and its mayor then came to the Supreme Court by petition for review under Rule 45 of the Rules of Court.

Facts

In 1992, PAGCOR, enjoying tremendous success in several cities, decided to expand its operations to Cagayan de Oro City. It leased a portion of a building belonging to Pryce Properties Corporation, Incorporated, renovated and equipped the premises, and prepared to inaugurate a casino there during the Christmas season.

The reaction of the Sangguniang Panlungsod was swift and hostile. On December 7, 1992, it enacted Ordinance No. 3353, prohibiting the issuance of a business permit, and cancelling existing business permits, to any establishment using or allowing its premises to be used for the operation of a casino. On January 4, 1993, it adopted the sterner Ordinance No. 3375-93, which flatly prohibited the operation of a gambling casino in the city and fixed penalties of fine, closure, and imprisonment for violation.

Civic organizations denounced the project, and the religious elements, the women's groups, and the youth echoed the objection. Demonstrations were led by the mayor and the city legislators, and the media described the casino as an affront to the welfare of the city.

Issues

  • Whether or not the Sangguniang Panlungsod of Cagayan de Oro City has the power and authority to prohibit the establishment and operation of a PAGCOR casino within its territorial limits.
  • Whether or not the phrase "gambling and other prohibited games of chance" in the Local Government Code refers only to illegal gambling.
  • Whether or not the ordinances are invalid because they contravene Presidential Decree No. 1869, the PAGCOR charter.
  • Whether or not the ordinances are discriminatory because they single out the casino while tolerating cockfighting.
  • Whether or not the ordinances are unreasonable and inconsistent with the policy of the State.

Applicable Provisions

Section 16 of the Local Government Code, the General Welfare Clause, provides:

Every local government unit shall exercise the powers expressly granted, those necessarily implied therefrom, as well as powers necessary, appropriate, or incidental for its efficient and effective governance, and those which are essential to the promotion of the general welfare.

This is the source of the police power invoked by the City, and the Court measures the ordinances against it.

Section 458 of the same Code provides:

The Sangguniang Panlungsod, as the legislative body of the city, shall enact ordinances, approve resolutions and appropriate funds for the general welfare of the city and its inhabitants pursuant to Section 16 of this Code and in the proper exercise of the corporate powers of the city as provided for under Section 22 of this Code.

This is the specific grant on which the City rested its power to ban the casino.

The same Section 458 further provides:

Enact ordinances intended to prevent, suppress and impose appropriate penalties for habitual drunkenness in public places, vagrancy, mendicancy, prostitution, establishment and maintenance of houses of ill repute, gambling and other prohibited games of chance, fraudulent devices and ways to obtain money or property, drug addiction, maintenance of drug dens, drug pushing, juvenile delinquency, the printing, distribution or exhibition of obscene or pornographic materials or publications, and such other activities inimical to the welfare and morals of the inhabitants of the city.

The decisive question is whether the word "gambling" here embraces casinos authorized by special law, and the Court holds that it does not.

Section 5 of the Code provides:

Any provision on a power of a local government unit shall be liberally interpreted in its favor, and in case of doubt, any question thereon shall be resolved in favor of devolution of powers and of the lower local government unit.

The City invoked this rule of liberal interpretation, but the Court does not allow it to defeat an express national policy.

Section 534 of the Code, the repealing clause, provides:

All general and special laws, acts, city charters, decrees, executive orders, proclamations and administrative regulations, or part or parts thereof which are inconsistent with any of the provisions of this Code are hereby repealed or modified accordingly.

The City relied on this general clause, but the Court notes that Presidential Decree No. 1869 is not among the laws specifically repealed.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court holds that the City may not prohibit the operation of a PAGCOR casino. The morality of gambling is not a justiciable issue, and gambling is not illegal per se. Congress may prohibit gambling altogether, allow it without limitation, or prohibit some forms and allow others, and the courts do not sit to review that wisdom. The only question the Court resolves is the validity of the ordinances by the criteria laid down by law.

On the second issue, the Court rules for the respondents. Reading the phrase "gambling and other prohibited games of chance" under the rule of noscitur a sociis, meaning that a word takes its meaning from the words associated with it, the Court concludes that "gambling" refers only to illegal gambling, which like the other prohibited games of chance must be prevented or suppressed.

On the third issue, the Court holds that the ordinances contravene Presidential Decree No. 1869 and the public policy embodied in it. The City argued that the Local Government Code had modified the decree, but the Court finds no sufficient indication of an implied repeal, since implied repeals are not lightly presumed. PAGCOR revenues are in fact tapped by later statutes, showing that its charter has not been repealed. The Court adds that courts must reconcile statutes rather than annul one in favor of the other, and so holds that local government units may and indeed must prevent and suppress all kinds of gambling within their territories except only those allowed by statutes like Presidential Decree No. 1869.

On the fourth and fifth issues, the Court finds the ordinances invalid. It stresses that municipal governments are only agents of the national government, exercising delegated legislative powers, and that the delegate cannot be superior to the principal. It is a heresy to suggest that local government units can undo the acts of Congress and negate them by mere ordinance.

Doctrine

First, the tests of a valid ordinance are that it must not contravene the Constitution or any statute, must not be unfair or oppressive, must not be partial or discriminatory, must not prohibit but may regulate trade, must be general and consistent with public policy, and must not be unreasonable.

Second, under the rule of noscitur a sociis, the phrase "gambling and other prohibited games of chance" in Section 458 of the Local Government Code means only illegal gambling, because the general word takes its color from the words associated with it.

Third, local government units may prevent and suppress all kinds of gambling within their territories except those allowed by statutes such as Presidential Decree No. 1869, and this exception must be read into the Code so that both laws remain effective and mutually complementary.

Fourth, implied repeal is not favored, and a general repealing clause does not repeal a special charter absent a clear and unmistakable showing of intent.

Disposition

The petition was denied and the decision of the Court of Appeals was affirmed, so the ordinances of Cagayan de Oro City were struck down and their enforcement prohibited.

Remember This

The one line to memorize is that a local government unit may suppress illegal gambling but cannot, by mere ordinance, prohibit a casino that Congress itself has authorized by special law. Examiners use this case to test the limits of local police power, the noscitur a sociis rule, and the strong presumption against implied repeal.