SPOUSES EPIFANIO FIGE AND MARTINA FIGE, PETITIONERS, VS. THE COURT OF APPEALS, HON. MARCELINO E. BAUTISTA, JR., IN HIS CAPACITY AS PRESIDING JUDGE, REGIONAL TRIAL COURT, PARAñAQ…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Spouses Fige versus Court of Appeals
The Case
This is a petition for review on certiorari brought by the spouses Epifanio Fige and Martina Fige against the Court of Appeals, the presiding judge of the Regional Trial Court of Parañaque, and the private respondents who are the registered co-owners of a parcel of land in Tambo, Parañaque. The action below was a simple action for unlawful detainer over a store standing on that land. The case matters because it gathers into one decision three rules every reviewee must carry into the bar: the tenant may not deny the title of his landlord, the question of ownership is generally foreign to an ejectment suit, and a certificate of title may not be attacked collaterally.
Procedural History
The private respondents filed a complaint for unlawful detainer before the Metropolitan Trial Court of Parañaque, Branch 78. After trial, that court dismissed the case for lack of cause of action. The private respondents appealed to the Regional Trial Court of Parañaque, which reversed the Metropolitan Trial Court and ordered the petitioners to vacate the premises, to pay seven hundred pesos monthly from March 15, 1989 until they vacated, to pay fifteen thousand pesos as attorney's fees, and to pay the costs of suit.
The petitioners then appealed to the Court of Appeals, which affirmed the Regional Trial Court but deleted the award of attorney's fees. The petitioners' motion for reconsideration was denied for lack of merit. Hence, the petitioners elevated the matter to the Supreme Court by petition, assigning as errors the misappreciation of their evidence, the failure to consider that the complaint states no cause of action, and the affirmance with modification of the Regional Trial Court decision.
Facts
The private respondents are the registered co-owners of a four hundred one square meter parcel of land with improvements, located at 634 Quirino Avenue, Tambo, Parañaque, Metro Manila, covered by Transfer Certificate of Title No. 36798. One of the improvements on the land is a store built in 1972. In September 1984, one of the co-owners, Antonio Camarillo, verbally leased the store to the petitioners at a monthly rental of seven hundred pesos.
On February 21, 1989, the private respondents wrote to the petitioners terminating the verbal lease by the end of that month and gave them fifteen days to vacate. The petitioners responded by sending a postal money order for one thousand four hundred pesos, representing rent for January and February 1989. On March 2, 1989, the private respondents reiterated their demand. Conciliation at the barangay level failed, and the complaint for unlawful detainer was filed.
The petitioners contested the complaint. They averred that the lot described in the private respondents' title is different from the parcel on which the store stood, and that they had bought the latter lot from a certain Elsie Periquet. To support this, they presented a location plan, field notes, survey documents, a sales application, and a survey verification report, and offered the testimony of Geodetic Engineer Cresencio Supleo.
Issues
- Whether or not the Court of Appeals erred in disregarding the petitioners' survey exhibits and the testimony of Engineer Supleo, which the Metropolitan Trial Court had credited.
- Whether or not the private respondents' complaint states no cause of action.
- Whether or not the Court of Appeals erred in affirming with modification the decision of the Regional Trial Court of Parañaque.
Applicable Provisions
Article 1456 of the Civil Code provides:
If a person having right to a thing gives it to another for a consideration, the latter cannot, in an action involving the possession of the thing, deny the title of the former.
This is the codal basis of the rule that a tenant cannot controvert the title of his landlord in an action involving possession of the leased premises.
Paragraph 5, Section 28 of Act No. 2259, the Cadastral Act, as amended by Section 1862 of Act No. 2711, is the provision the Court invokes on the survey documents. As the Court states the duty it imposes, it is the duty of private surveyors to send their original field notes, computations, reports, surveys, maps, and plots of the property to the Bureau of Lands for verification and approval. Because the petitioners' survey exhibits were never so verified and approved, they were properly denied probative value.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that while factual questions are not ordinarily raised in a petition for certiorari, it examined the evidence because the trial court and the appellate courts had ruled contradictorily. It found no reason to reverse the Court of Appeals. The survey exhibits were not verified and approved by the Bureau of Lands as the Cadastral Act requires, so their authenticity was not established and they could not be considered. The technical description offered as another exhibit was an uncertified xerox copy, unauthenticated and unattested under the seal of the Bureau of Lands, and was in fact a different document from what had been marked in the trial court, so it was inadmissible.
The Court then stressed the juridical relation between the parties: lessee and lessor. Given that relation, the petitioners could not claim they had purchased the lot from Elsie Periquet. The Court quoted its earlier ruling in Tiu versus Court of Appeals:
The fact of lease having been admitted by the private respondent as well as the expiration of the term thereof, there can be no question that the issue of ownership is foreign to the action. Indeed, it matters not that private respondent was already an occupant of the leased premises when he executed and signed the contract of lease, because the basis of the ejectment suit is the very contract of lease. Private respondent cannot now be heard to impugn what he had previously admitted, which includes that petitioner is the owner of the premises. Neither can he confuse the issue by raising the question of title to defeat the right of petitioner to the possession of the premises and to eject him therefrom.
On the second and third issues, the Court held that they must necessarily fail. The petitioners' evidence that the private respondents' title does not include the lot they occupy was far from convincing, and the charge of fraud and misrepresentation was bereft of competent evidence, for allegations of fraud must be proved by clear and convincing evidence. The Court was satisfied that the private respondents proved their cause of action.
Doctrine
First, a tenant cannot, in an action involving the possession of the leased premises, controvert the title of his landlord, and cannot set up any inconsistent right to change the relation between them without first delivering up the premises to the landlord. This flows from Article 1456 of the Civil Code.
Second, in an action for unlawful detainer, the question of possession is primordial while the issue of ownership is generally unessential. The issue of ownership should be raised by the affected party in an appropriate action, for a certificate of title cannot be the subject of a collateral attack.
Third, survey documents such as location plans, field notes, and technical descriptions carry no probative value unless verified and approved by the Bureau of Lands as the Cadastral Act requires, and an unauthenticated xerox copy of a technical description is inadmissible.
Fourth, allegations of fraud must be proved by clear and convincing evidence.
Disposition
The petition was denied, and the decision of the Court of Appeals was affirmed, with costs against the petitioners.
Remember This
Memorize the line: a tenant cannot controvert the title of his landlord in an action involving possession of the leased premises. Examiners use this case to test the rule that ownership is foreign to ejectment and that a certificate of title cannot be collaterally attacked.