PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. REY CRUZA Y BAUIO, JOEMARIE PALMAREZ Y PAGDATU, JIMMY PALMAREZ Y PAGDATU AND GARRY PADRE-E Y PALLORE, ACCUSED-APPELLANTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
People versus Cruza
The Case
This is a criminal appeal in which the People of the Philippines prosecuted Rey Cruza, Joemarie Palmarez, Jimmy Palmarez, and Garry Padre-e as co-conspirators in the killing of Canuto Natividad. The accused admitted being present on the night of the killing but insisted they were mere spectators who had only been asked to help push a stalled truck. The case matters because it gathers in one decision the rules a reviewee must command: conspiracy inferred from concerted action, the criminal law rule that an offender answers for all the consequences of his unlawful act, treachery as a qualifying circumstance, the deference owed to the trial court's factual findings, and the court's control over the prosecution once an information is filed.
Procedural History
An information was filed against the companions of Arnold Fuentes. Before arraignment, the prosecution moved for reinvestigation, and the Regional Trial Court of Valenzuela, presided over by Judge Teresita Capulong, granted the motion. After reinvestigation, the prosecutor recommended dropping the charges against Joemarie and Jimmy Palmarez for lack of evidence, and the city prosecutor moved to dismiss the charge against all the accused on the ground that no conspiracy was shown. The trial court denied the motion and proceeded to trial. After trial, the trial court convicted all the accused, imposed reclusion perpetua and the accessory penalties on each, and held them solidarily liable for civil indemnity of 50,000 pesos plus costs. Joemarie Palmarez, Jimmy Palmarez, and Garry Padre-e appealed in due time. Rey Cruza did not appeal on time; he later filed a motion to admit a brief, which the Supreme Court denied. The appeal of the other three reached the Supreme Court, which affirmed the trial court in full.
Facts
At about eleven o'clock in the evening of July 10, 1991, in Barangay Mapulang Lupa, Valenzuela, Metro Manila, Arnold Fuentes drove his truck into and damaged the gate of the lot owned by Canuto Natividad. The two exchanged words. Fuentes left in a rage but returned minutes later with Rey Cruza, Roy Cruza, Joemarie Palmarez, Jimmy Palmarez, and Garry Padre-e.
The five approached Canuto from behind and started mauling him. Fuentes struck at him twice with a bladed weapon but missed. The companions then held Canuto's arms to render him defenseless, and Fuentes succeeded in stabbing him in the abdomen. Rey Cruza was heard to say, "Pare, saksakin mo na!" and later Roy Cruza exclaimed, "Pare, takbo na, napuruhan mo na!" The five ran away. Fuentes was overtaken by townspeople who had witnessed the incident and was hacked to death; Canuto also died that same night. Four of the assailants were later found hiding under a bulldozer in the trucking compound where they were employed. Roy Cruza disappeared and remains at large.
Three prosecution witnesses, Canuto's son and two neighbors, placed the accused at the scene and identified them as the persons who assisted Fuentes. They had no difficulty recognizing the accused because the place was well lighted. For the defense, three of the accused testified that Fuentes had asked them to help push his stalled truck; that from about ten meters away they saw him arguing with Canuto and then stabbing him; and that, frightened of being implicated, they ran and hid.
Issues
- Whether or not the accused actively participated in the killing as conspirators, rather than being mere spectators ten meters away.
- Whether or not conspiracy may be inferred from their concerted acts of holding the victim's arms, urging the stabbing, and fleeing together.
- Whether or not the accused are liable for the death of Canuto even if their intention was only to maul him.
- Whether or not the crime is murder qualified by treachery.
- Whether or not the trial court erred in denying the motions to dismiss the charges after reinvestigation.
Applicable Provisions
Article 4 of the Revised Penal Code provides:
Criminal liability shall be incurred by any person committing a felony although the wrongful act done be different from that which he intended.
This is the basis for holding the accused liable for the death of Canuto even if their original intent was only to maul him.
Article 248 of the Revised Penal Code, as discussed in the decision, defines and penalizes murder, and the Court quotes its concept of treachery:
Treachery exists when the offender commits any of the crimes against persons, employing means, methods or forms in the execution thereof which tend directly and specially to insure its execution without risk to himself arising from the defense which the offended party might make.
This qualifies the killing to murder, because Canuto was attacked from behind and never had the opportunity to defend himself.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that factual questions resolved by the trial court are not subject to review, and that the trial court is in the superior position to assess the witnesses' deportment on the stand. The three prosecution witnesses testified to seeing the accused gang up on the victim and restrain his arms to enable Fuentes to strike the fatal blow. The Court found no plausible reason for them to lie against persons they hardly knew, and found the claim that the accused stood ten meters away hard to believe, especially since the defense could not explain why, if they were that far, they would feel threatened and hide under a bulldozer. The Court stressed that unexplained flight is evidence of guilt.
On the second issue, the Court held that conspiracy was established. The accused restrained Canuto's arms as Fuentes dealt the fatal blow, after one of them urged him to do so, and afterwards they all fled together. They were acting in concert from the start of the attack until they fled and hid. The Court rejected the arguments that the single wound and the absence of weapons negated conspiracy, calling the first a non sequitur and holding that the accused were unarmed because their purpose was to assist the armed Fuentes.
On the third issue, the Court applied Article 4 of the Revised Penal Code and held that even if the real intention was only to maul, the accused remain responsible for Canuto's death as the graver consequence of their unlawful acts.
On the fourth issue, the Court held that treachery qualified the crime to murder, since Canuto was attacked from behind by the five men while assessing the damage to his gate and, due to the suddenness of the attack, never had the opportunity to defend himself.
On the fifth issue, the Court held that once the information is filed, the trial court acquires jurisdiction, and any subsequent act of the public prosecutors relating to its disposition must be subject to the court's approval. A reinvestigation requires the court's permission, and any motion to withdraw the information or dismiss the case is addressed to the court's sound discretion. The trial court therefore did not err in denying the motions, because there really was a conspiracy among all of them.
Doctrine
- Conspiracy may be inferred from the concerted acts of the accused before, during, and after the crime; acting in concert to restrain the victim while another deals the fatal blow, urging the stabbing, and fleeing together establish it.
- Under Article 4 of the Revised Penal Code, a person is responsible for all the consequences of his unlawful act although such consequences were not the ones originally intended.
- Treachery qualifies a killing to murder when the offender employs means that insure its execution without risk to himself arising from the defense the offended party might make.
- Unexplained flight is evidence of guilt.
- Factual findings of the trial court, based on its observation of the witnesses' deportment, are not disturbed on appeal absent a showing of an accepted exception.
- Once the information is filed, the trial court acquires jurisdiction, and the prosecution's acts relating to the disposition of the case, including reinvestigation and dismissal, require the court's approval and are addressed to its sound discretion.
Disposition
The Supreme Court affirmed the trial court's decision in full and dismissed the appeal, with costs against the appellants.
Remember This
The line worth memorizing is that a person is responsible for all the consequences of his unlawful act although such consequences were not the ones originally intended. Examiners like to use this case on conspiracy inferred from concerted action, on treachery as a qualifying circumstance, and on the court's control over the prosecution after the information is filed.