PEPSI-COLA BOTTLING CO., ANTHONY SIAN AND VIRGILIO CASTILLO, PETITIONERS, VS. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION, FOURTH DIVISION, CEBU CITY; OSCAR T. ENCABO, AND HON. JESSELIT…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Pepsi-Cola Bottling versus National Labor Relations Commission
The Case
This is a petition for certiorari brought by Pepsi-Cola Bottling Company and its officers, Anthony Sian and Virgilio Castillo, against the National Labor Relations Commission, its Fourth Division in Cebu City, and the dismissed employee Oscar Encabo. The petitioners ask the Supreme Court to annul the labor tribunal's decision and resolution which affirmed the labor arbiter's award of reinstatement, backwages, and attorney's fees in favor of Encabo. The case matters because it gathers in one decision the whole law of dismissal: the two written notices that due process demands, the strict standard for loss of trust and confidence, the respect owed to the factual findings of labor agencies, and the rule that separation pay may replace reinstatement when the working relationship has been strained.
Procedural History
Encabo filed a complaint for illegal dismissal and unfair labor practice before the National Labor Relations Commission, Regional Office Number 8, in Tacloban City. Executive Labor Arbiter Jesselito Latoja rendered judgment ordering the Pepsi-Cola companies and the two officers to reinstate Encabo to his former position as Maintenance Manager and to pay backwages and attorney's fees. The petitioners appealed to the National Labor Relations Commission, which dismissed the appeal in April 1991. Their motion for reconsideration was denied in August 1991, the Commission holding that the alleged cessation of business was never raised at the arbitration level and could not be entertained on appeal. The petitioners then came to the Supreme Court on a petition for certiorari with a prayer for a writ of preliminary injunction, and the Court issued a temporary restraining order.
Facts
On the first of September 1986, Oscar Encabo, a licensed mechanical and electrical engineer, was employed as maintenance manager of the Pepsi-Cola beverage plant at Tanauan, Leyte. In January 1988 the plant's soaker machine needed rehabilitation. A contractor, Precision Machinist Corporation, submitted a quotation, and the company accepted it. The Plant General Manager, Sian, wired Castillo to prepare a list of spare parts and informed him that the maintenance manager of the Iloilo plant, a Mr. Doromal, would come over to handle the work. Encabo prepared the purchase requisitions, but Doromal revised them. The contractor's crew began work in the middle of March 1988 under Doromal's supervision, and the contractor failed to make the machine fully operational.
Castillo then asked Encabo to take over. Assisted by the men directly under him, Encabo made the soaker machine operational again within three weeks, at an efficiency rate of sixty-five per cent. On the ninth of May 1988 the personnel manager told him that his position might be sacrificed because of the delay. He went on leave, and on the seventeenth of May he was told to resign and offered twelve thousand pesos, which he rejected. On the twenty-fifth of May 1988 a letter of termination was handed to him through a security guard. He filed his complaint five days later.
The company answered that he was dismissed for negligence in failing to install preventive measures and in failing to supervise the contractor's repair. Meanwhile, Pepsi-Cola Products Philippines, Incorporated informed the Commission that it was returning a writ of execution unsatisfied, insisting it was a separate and distinct corporation. The petitioners added that the original company had closed its business in July 1989 and that the new franchise holder was a new entity.
Issues
- Whether or not the private respondent was accorded due process before his dismissal.
- Whether or not the private respondent was terminated from employment for a just cause, namely loss of trust and confidence.
- Whether or not the National Labor Relations Commission acted with grave abuse of discretion in holding the petitioner company and its successor in interest liable for reinstatement.
Applicable Provisions
Section 13 of Batas Pambansa Bilang 130, as implemented by the Rules, requires two written notices before termination, and the Court states the requirement in these words:
The law requires that the employer must furnish the worker sought to be dismissed with two (2) written notices before termination of employment can be legally effected: (1) notice which apprises the employee of the particular acts or omissions for which his dismissal is sought; and (2) the subsequent notice which informs the employee of the employer's decision to dismiss him.
This provision bears on the case because the petitioners never furnished the first notice, and the Court held that conferences are no substitute for it.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that due process was not observed. The petitioners relied on a conference with the personnel manager, but the Court answered that consultations or conferences are not a substitute for the actual observance of notice and hearing. Worse, when the employee's lawyer asked by telephone whether he had been or was about to be dismissed, the personnel manager emphatically answered no, and a few days later the termination letter was handed to him. He was never given the opportunity to prepare his defense, and the failure to comply with the mandatory procedure taints the dismissal with illegality.
On the second issue, the Court held that there was no just cause. Loss of trust and confidence must have some basis, and the Court quoted with approval its earlier ruling that loss of confidence should not be simulated, should not be used as a subterfuge for causes which are improper, illegal or unjustified, may not be arbitrarily asserted in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary, and must be genuine, not a mere afterthought to justify earlier action taken in bad faith. The Labor Arbiter's findings, which the Court adopted, showed that the company itself hired the contractor, that the contractor had complete control over the work, that the employee was bypassed and never consulted, and that he in fact succeeded where the contractor had failed. The dismissal was an afterthought to cover up management's embarrassment, and the officers were the architects of it.
On the third issue, the Court held that the new corporation could be held liable. The complaint was filed while the old company still existed, Pepsi-Cola never stopped doing business in the Philippines, and in the appeal bond both companies bound themselves to answer the monetary awards. The Court stressed that a manager's right to fire must be exercised with utmost prudence and with humane consideration. Reinstatement would ordinarily follow as a matter of right, but considering the supervening facts and the strained relations between the parties, the Court awarded separation pay in its place.
Doctrine
First, the employer must serve two written notices: one apprising the employee of the particular acts or omissions charged, and a subsequent one informing him of the decision to dismiss. Conferences do not substitute for this mandatory procedure, and failure taints the dismissal with illegality. Second, loss of trust and confidence must rest on an actual breach of duty committed by the employee, not on the employer's caprices; it must be genuine and not a mere afterthought. Third, findings of fact of labor agencies, supported by substantial evidence, are accorded respect and at times even finality. Fourth, reinstatement follows as a matter of right upon a finding of illegal dismissal, but separation pay may be awarded in lieu of reinstatement where the relationship has been strained.
Disposition
The Court modified the decision and resolution of the National Labor Relations Commission: backwages were limited to three years, and in lieu of reinstatement Encabo was granted separation pay equivalent to one month for every year of service plus ten thousand pesos in attorney's fees, with costs against the petitioners, while the writs of execution were nullified and the temporary restraining order made permanent.
Remember This
Memorize the line that loss of confidence must rest on an actual breach of duty committed by the employee and not on the employer's caprices. Examiners use this case for the two-notice rule, for the strict standard of loss of trust and confidence, and for separation pay in lieu of reinstatement.