🎧 Case Brief Lecture

MANILA WATER COMPANY INC., PETITIONER, VS. HLURB BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS AND HOMEOWNERS OF PHASES 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 & 8, REP. BY THEIR PHASE HOMEOWNER REPRESENTATIVES PH.1: JES…

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Manila Water versus HLURB Board of Commissioners

The Case

This is the case of Manila Water versus the HLURB Board of Commissioners and the homeowners of Phases 1 to 8. Manila Water Company, the petitioner, is the water utility that entered into an arrangement with a homeowners association. The homeowners, represented by their phase homeowner representatives, brought a complaint before the Housing and Land Use Regulatory Board. The question is whether that Board, which lawyers call the HLURB, had the authority to hear and resolve the controversy between the water company and the homeowners. The case matters because it fixes which law governs the Board's jurisdiction over conflicts between associations and their members or service providers, and because it teaches that a motion for reconsideration that ignores the very ground of the decision is destined to fail.

Procedural History

The homeowners filed their complaint before the HLURB. The Board took cognizance of the controversy and resolved it. Manila Water questioned the Board's authority, but the Supreme Court, in its Decision of February 4, 2014, affirmed both the competence of the HLURB and the propriety of its resolution of the issues raised by the homeowners under their arrangement with the water company. Manila Water then filed a Motion for Reconsideration, insisting that the principal respondent was devoid of authority over the matter. That motion is what the Court resolves here, and it is denied.

Facts

Manila Water Company entered into an arrangement with a homeowners association covering several phases of a subdivision. Out of that arrangement arose a controversy between the water company and the homeowners, who were represented by the homeowner representatives of each phase.

On March 22, 2011, the homeowners filed a complaint before the HLURB. Manila Water resisted, invoking Presidential Decree Number 957 and Executive Order Number 648 to argue that the HLURB was not clothed with the appropriate authority to entertain the complaint.

The Supreme Court upheld the HLURB. Manila Water moved for reconsideration, but its motion was silent on the Court's observation that the relevant law at the time of filing was Republic Act Number 9904, which permitted the HLURB to resolve inter-association controversies and conflicts. The motion attacked the disposition without answering the ground on which it rested.

Issues

  • Whether or not the HLURB had jurisdiction and competence to entertain and resolve the homeowners' complaint against Manila Water.
  • Whether or not the provisions of Presidential Decree Number 957, invoked by Manila Water to deny the HLURB's authority, still governed when the complaint was filed on March 22, 2011.
  • Whether or not the Motion for Reconsideration raised any ground that could overturn the Court's prior Decision.

Applicable Provisions

Section 13 of Executive Order Number 648 provides:

Provisions of Presidential Decree No. 957 inconsistent with Executive Order No. 648 were repealed accordingly by Section 13 of Executive Order No. 648.

This is the Court's own statement of the repealing effect, and it disposes of Manila Water's reliance on Presidential Decree Number 957.

Section 20 (d) of Republic Act Number 9904 provides:

Section 20 (d) thereof permitted the HLURB to resolve inter-association controversies and conflicts.

This is the provision the Court identifies as the relevant law when the complaint was filed, and it is the source of the HLURB's authority over the controversy.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the HLURB was competent. Its prior Decision had already affirmed the competence of the HLURB and the propriety of its resolution of the issues raised by the homeowners under their arrangement with the petitioner, and the Motion for Reconsideration gave the Court no reason to depart from that holding.

On the second issue, the Court held that Manila Water's reliance on Presidential Decree Number 957 was misplaced. The Court explained that the provisions of that decree which are inconsistent with Executive Order Number 648 were repealed by Section 13 of the latter. More importantly, the Court stressed that the relevant law when the complaint was filed on March 22, 2011 was Republic Act Number 9904, which expressly permitted the HLURB to resolve inter-association controversies and conflicts under Section 20 (d). The governing law is thus determined by the date the complaint was filed, not by the older decree the petitioner preferred.

On the third issue, the Court held that the Motion for Reconsideration was devoid of merit. It was mute on the incremental observations the Court had made about Presidential Decree Number 957, Executive Order Number 648, and Republic Act Number 9904. A motion that does not meet the ground of the decision cannot succeed.

Doctrine

First, the HLURB has authority to resolve inter-association controversies and conflicts, and this authority is expressly conferred by Section 20 (d) of Republic Act Number 9904.

Second, the governing law over a complaint is the law in force at the time the complaint was filed. Where the complaint was filed on March 22, 2011, Republic Act Number 9904 governs, and provisions of Presidential Decree Number 957 inconsistent with Executive Order Number 648 stand repealed by Section 13 of that Executive Order.

Third, a motion for reconsideration must squarely address the ratiocination of the decision it attacks. A motion that is silent on the Court's central observations raises no meritorious ground and must be denied.

Disposition

The Court denied Manila Water's Motion for Reconsideration, and the Decision of February 4, 2014 affirming the HLURB's competence and the propriety of its resolution stood.

Remember This

Memorize this line: the relevant law is the law in force when the complaint was filed, and under Republic Act Number 9904 the HLURB may resolve inter-association controversies and conflicts. Examiners use this case on jurisdiction over homeowners' disputes and on the requisites of a valid motion for reconsideration, which must confront the very ground of the decision.