🎧 Case Brief Lecture

ATTY. NERIO G. ZAMORA, COMPLAINANT, VS. TOMAS A. JUMAMOY AND DOMINGO B. BRUNIDOR, RESPONDENTS.

A.M. No. P-93-781. December 02, 1994 December 2, 1994

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Zamora versus Jumamoy

The Case

This is an administrative case brought by Atty. Nerio G. Zamora against Tomas A. Jumamoy and Domingo B. Brunidor, both deputy sheriffs of the Municipal Trial Court in Cities of Tagbilaran City. The complainant charged them with gross inefficiency, incompetence, and malpractice prejudicial to the government service, arising from their failure to enforce writs of execution and their acceptance of compromise payments from losing parties. The case matters because it settles two things every bar candidate must know: that a sheriff who sits on a writ and waits on the promises of a judgment debtor is guilty of gross inefficiency, and that an administrative complaint against a public officer, once taken cognizance of by the Court, cannot be withdrawn at the complainant's whim.

Procedural History

The sworn letter-complaint, dated 19 January 1993 and addressed to the Executive Judge of the Regional Trial Court of Bohol, was forwarded to the Office of the Court Administrator. Acting on the Administrator's memorandum, the Supreme Court required the respondents to comment. The Court then referred the case to Executive Judge Antonio H. Bautista of the Regional Trial Court of Bohol for evaluation, report, and recommendation. At the scheduled hearing, the complainant offered to withdraw the complaint if the respondents would apologize and promise to perform their duties faithfully; the respondents apologized in open court, and the complainant withdrew and adduced no evidence. Judge Bautista recommended dismissal. The Supreme Court referred the case back to him for investigation, citing its ruling that an administrative complaint cannot simply be withdrawn because the complainant has lost interest. After investigation, Judge Bautista found the charges admitted under oath and recommended suspension of two months without pay. The Office of the Court Administrator recommended approval, and the case came before the Supreme Court as an administrative matter.

Facts

For more than two years, the complainant alleged, the two deputy sheriffs reported for work at their whims and caprices and deliberately failed to implement writs of execution in several civil cases and one criminal case, to the damage of the complainant and his clients. He further alleged that, without authority of the court, they accepted compromise payments from losing parties and appropriated these for their own benefit.

Respondent Jumamoy denied the charges and claimed the complaint was pure harassment. He said he had already returned the writs in three civil cases, stating in his returns that the judgment debtors had asked for time to raise funds, that one had made a partial payment of 500 pesos and promised the balance, and that another had promised to pay but failed. The returns were made without prejudice to the plaintiff moving for alias writs. Respondent Brunidor alleged that partial payments were made in two civil cases and that the accused in the criminal case had consigned 1,200 pesos with the clerk of court; he added that no motions for alias writs had been filed and that he received the alias writ in the criminal case only on 26 February 1993.

At the hearing before Judge Bautista, the respondents apologized to the complainant and promised to perform their duties faithfully. The complainant then withdrew the complaint. On referral back for investigation, both complainant and respondents testified, and the respondents admitted the charges under oath in open court, showing remorse and repentance.

Issues

  • Whether or not the respondents are liable for gross inefficiency, incompetence, and conduct prejudicial to the best interest of the service for failing to enforce the writs of execution with due diligence.
  • Whether or not the withdrawal of the complaint by the complainant, upon the respondents' apology and promise of diligence, bars the continuation of the administrative proceedings.

Applicable Provisions

Section 15, Rule 39 of the Rules of Court provides:

When the judgment is for the payment of money, the officer making the service of the writ shall proceed to collect the amount thereof out of the personal property of the judgment debtor, or if sufficient personal property cannot be found, out of his real property, not exempt from execution, and shall make a return of the writ within sixty (60) days after receipt thereof, stating the whole amount collected, and if the judgment is not satisfied, the reason therefor.

This provision fixes the sheriff's positive duty to collect from the judgment debtor's property rather than wait on promises, and the Court held the respondents should have complied with it.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held the respondents liable. Having admitted the charges in open court while under oath, no further evidence was necessary. Their own comments showed they withheld due implementation of the writs on the mere pleas of judgment debtors for time to raise funds or to pay in installments, and then returned the writs unsatisfied or partially satisfied, hoping the prevailing party would ask for alias writs. In short, they deliberately failed to exercise due diligence. There being no proof that the judgment debtors had no property exempt from execution, the respondents should have complied with Section 15, Rule 39. They should not have folded their arms and waited for the fulfillment of promises. A delay in execution may let scheming debtors bring their property beyond the reach of the writs. Compassion and sympathy, the Court said, must never compromise the public-trust character of their office.

On the second issue, the Court did not look with favor on the complainant's offer to withdraw conditioned on an apology and a promise of diligence. His grievances related to public duty, not a purely personal matter, and so transcended his personal pique or pride. Once the Court had taken cognizance of the case, the complaint could no longer be withdrawn just because the respondents had apologized or repented; such a withdrawal could only invite suspicion that the complainant was not sincere. The Court cannot be bound by the unilateral act of a complainant in a matter involving its disciplinary authority.

Doctrine

A sheriff who, instead of levying on the judgment debtor's property under Section 15, Rule 39 of the Rules of Court, simply waits on the debtor's promises and returns the writ unsatisfied or partially satisfied is guilty of gross inefficiency, incompetence, and conduct prejudicial to the best interest of the service. The conduct of everyone connected with an office charged with the dispensation of justice, from the presiding judge to the lowliest clerk, is circumscribed with the heavy burden of responsibility. And an administrative complaint for misconduct against a public officer or employee cannot be withdrawn at any time by the complainant; public interest demands that the proceedings continue regardless of the complainant's motion to dismiss, for complainants are, in a real sense, only witnesses.

Disposition

The Court found the respondents guilty and suspended each of them from office for two months without pay, the suspension to take effect upon notice.

Remember This

Memorize the line that a sheriff may not fold his arms and wait on the promises of a judgment debtor, for delay in execution lets scheming debtors spirit their property away. Examiners use this case on the ministerial duty of sheriffs under Section 15, Rule 39, and on why an administrative complaint, once taken cognizance of by the Court, survives the complainant's withdrawal.