🎧 Case Brief Lecture

JOSE RODRIGO P. MANALO, DINNAH MARIE C. CINENSE, LLOYD B. TADEO, AND MA. GENE CINENSE, REPRESENTED BY NESTOR CINENSE, PLAINTIFFS-APPELLEES, VS. DIONISIA RINDOLE FRANCIA AND ROBE…

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Manalo versus Francia

The Case

This is a civil action brought by Jose Rodrigo P. Manalo, Dinnah Marie C. Cinense, Lloyd B. Tadeo, and Ma. Gene Cinense, represented by Nestor Cinense, against Dionisia Rindole Francia and Roberto Francia. The plaintiffs sought relief before the Regional Trial Court of Guimba, Nueva Ecija, and the case ultimately reached the Supreme Court, which denied the appeal and affirmed the trial court's decision. The case matters to the reviewee less for its substantive doctrine than for what it teaches about finality: once the Supreme Court has spoken, a motion for reconsideration that merely recycles arguments already considered and resolved will not reopen the case.

Procedural History

The case began in the Regional Trial Court, Branch 33, Guimba, Nueva Ecija, in Civil Case Number 1573-G. On September 19, 2011, the trial court rendered a Decision in favor of the plaintiffs. The defendants appealed to the Supreme Court, which, on August 20, 2014, issued a Decision denying the appeal for lack of merit and affirming the September 19, 2011 Decision of the Regional Trial Court. On October 1, 2014, the Court received the defendants-appellants' Motion for Reconsideration. The plaintiffs-appellees filed their Comment on the Motion for Reconsideration on November 4, 2014. The Court then resolved the motion, denying it for lack of merit.

Facts

The plaintiffs, Jose Rodrigo P. Manalo, Dinnah Marie C. Cinense, Lloyd B. Tadeo, and Ma. Gene Cinense, represented by Nestor Cinense, filed a civil action against the defendants, Dionisia Rindole Francia and Roberto Francia, before the Regional Trial Court, Branch 33, Guimba, Nueva Ecija, docketed as Civil Case Number 1573-G.

On September 19, 2011, the trial court rendered a Decision in the case. The defendants appealed that Decision to the Supreme Court.

On August 20, 2014, the Supreme Court issued its Decision denying the appeal for lack of merit and affirming the September 19, 2011 Decision of the Regional Trial Court. The defendants then filed a Motion for Reconsideration, which the Court received on October 1, 2014. The plaintiffs filed their Comment on the Motion on November 4, 2014. Upon examination, the Court found that the arguments raised in the motion had already been duly considered and resolved in its earlier Decision.

Issues

  • Whether or not the appeal should be denied for lack of merit and the September 19, 2011 Decision of the Regional Trial Court, Branch 33, Guimba, Nueva Ecija affirmed.
  • Whether or not the Motion for Reconsideration filed by the defendants-appellants should be granted.

Applicable Provisions

The decision text before the Court does not quote or construe any specific statutory or constitutional provision. Its disposition rests on the settled procedural principle that a motion for reconsideration raising arguments already considered and resolved by the Court is denied for lack of merit. No verbatim provision is reproduced in the decision, and none is supplied here.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court denied the appeal for lack of merit and affirmed the September 19, 2011 Decision of the Regional Trial Court, Branch 33, Guimba, Nueva Ecija, in Civil Case Number 1573-G. The Court's dispositive portion reads:

WHEREFORE, the appeal is hereby DENIED for lack of merit. Accordingly, the September 19, 2011 Decision of the Regional Trial Court, Branch 33, Guimba, Nueva Ecija in Civil Case No. 1573-G is AFFIRMED.

On the second issue, the Court denied the Motion for Reconsideration for lack of merit. It explained that an assiduous examination of the motion showed that the arguments raised therein by the defendants-appellants had already been duly considered and resolved by the Court, and that it would be an exercise in futility to repeat its discussion thereof. The Court's dispositive portion reads:

WHEREFORE, the motion for reconsideration is hereby DENIED for lack of merit.

Doctrine

A motion for reconsideration that merely reprises arguments already duly considered and resolved by the Court in its Decision will be denied for lack of merit. The Court will not repeat a discussion it has already made; to do so would be an exercise in futility. Once the Court has passed upon the issues and resolved them, a party cannot obtain a second hearing by restating the same grounds. The proper recourse, if any, lies elsewhere, not in a recycled motion for reconsideration.

Disposition

The Supreme Court denied the appeal for lack of merit, affirmed the September 19, 2011 Decision of the Regional Trial Court, Branch 33, Guimba, Nueva Ecija, and denied the defendants-appellants' Motion for Reconsideration for lack of merit.

Remember This

The single line worth memorizing is that a motion for reconsideration raising arguments already considered and resolved is denied for lack of merit, for it would be an exercise in futility to repeat the discussion. Examiners use this case to test the rule on motions for reconsideration and the finality of judgments, particularly the principle that recycled arguments do not warrant a second look.