AURORA C. PAREDES, PETITIONER, VS. HON. SELMA PALACIO ALARAS, IN HER CAPACITY AS PRESIDING JUDGE, BRANCH 62, MAKATI CITY, THE PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, ELENITA V. RUBIN, LEAH C…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Paredes versus Alaras
The Case
Aurora Paredes, the petitioner, brought an action against Judge Selma Palacio Alaras, in her capacity as presiding judge of a regional trial court branch in Makati City, against the People of the Philippines, and against private complainants Elenita Rubin and Leah Rubin. The action is a special civil action for certiorari, a petition asking the Supreme Court to undo the trial judge's dispositions in a criminal case for illegal recruitment. The case matters for the bar because it shows the Supreme Court refusing to disturb a finding of probable cause and the arrest warrant that followed, and then refusing to reconsider that refusal. It is a compact lesson on the narrowness of certiorari against a judge's interlocutory orders.
Procedural History
The criminal case for illegal recruitment was lodged before the regional trial court in Makati City, presided over by Judge Alaras. The judge issued dispositions in that case, and on the strength of those dispositions a warrant for the arrest of Paredes was issued. Paredes then went up to the Supreme Court by a petition for certiorari directed against the judge's dispositions. The Supreme Court denied due course to the petition and dismissed it. Paredes, through counsel, moved for reconsideration. The Supreme Court denied the motion for lack of merit, and it is that denial which closes the case.
Facts
Paredes was proceeded against in a criminal case for illegal recruitment. The trial judge, acting on the complaint of Elenita Rubin and Leah Rubin, made dispositions in the case that led to a finding of probable cause against Paredes. On that finding, a warrant for the arrest of Paredes was issued.
Paredes challenged the judge's dispositions before the Supreme Court by petition for certiorari. The Supreme Court denied due course to the petition and dismissed it, having determined that probable cause existed against Paredes and that the warrant of arrest had been issued relative to illegal recruitment.
Counsel for Paredes then filed a motion for reconsideration. The Supreme Court found that the motion did not demonstrate any reversible error, and that its discussion was a mere rehash of what the Court had already sufficiently discussed in the resolution it sought to reconsider.
Issues
- Whether or not the Supreme Court should give due course to the petition for certiorari directed against the trial judge's dispositions in the illegal recruitment case.
- Whether or not the finding of probable cause against Paredes, and the warrant of arrest issued on that finding, may be disturbed on certiorari.
- Whether or not the motion for reconsideration raises a reversible error warranting a reversal of the Court's resolution.
Applicable Provisions
The decision text as rendered does not quote or set out any statutory or constitutional provision. What it applies is the settled standard for certiorari against a judge's interlocutory dispositions, and it states that standard in its own words rather than in a quoted text. The Court's test is whether probable cause exists against the petitioner, and whether the warrant of arrest was issued relative to the offense charged. On that test the petition was dismissed, and on that same test the motion for reconsideration was denied.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court denied due course to the petition and dismissed it. The reason is that the Court determined that probable cause exists against Paredes, and that a warrant for her arrest was issued relative to illegal recruitment. Where probable cause is found and the warrant issues in the regular course, certiorari will not lie to undo the judge's dispositions.
On the second issue, the Court did not disturb the finding of probable cause or the arrest warrant. The existence of probable cause, as determined in the proceedings below, was the very ground on which the petition was dismissed, not a ground for granting it.
On the third issue, the Court denied the motion for reconsideration for lack of merit. It held that the motion, far from demonstrating any reversible error, was a mere rehash of what the Court had sufficiently discussed in the resolution under challenge. The Court's language on this point is worth hearing:
Thereafter, a Motion for Reconsideration was interposed by counsel for petitioner but far from demonstrating any reversible error, the discussion of petitioner was a mere rehash of what We have sufficiently discussed in the course of the impugned Resolution.
And its conclusion on the motion:
Hence, petitioner's Motion for Reconsideration is hereby DENIED for lack of merit.
Doctrine
First, a petition for certiorari against a judge's dispositions in a criminal case will not be given due course where the Court finds that probable cause exists against the petitioner and that a warrant of arrest was issued relative to the offense charged. Probable cause, once found on the record, is a bar to the extraordinary remedy, not a reason to grant it.
Second, a motion for reconsideration must demonstrate a reversible error. A motion that merely rehashes what the Court has already sufficiently discussed in the resolution under challenge is denied for lack of merit. Counsel cannot convert a lost petition into a winning one by repeating the same arguments.
Third, and tying these together, the extraordinary writ of certiorari is not a substitute for the ordinary course of trial. The proper forum for contesting the evidence against an accused is the trial itself, not a collateral attack on the judge's interlocutory orders.
Disposition
The Supreme Court denied the motion for reconsideration for lack of merit, leaving standing its earlier resolution denying due course to and dismissing the petition for certiorari, so that Paredes lost and the finding of probable cause and the warrant of arrest against her remained undisturbed.
Remember This
The line to memorize is that a motion for reconsideration which is a mere rehash of what the Court has already sufficiently discussed is denied for lack of merit. Examiners use this case to test the standard for certiorari against a judge's finding of probable cause and the issuance of a warrant of arrest, and to test the requirement that a motion for reconsideration point to a genuine reversible error.