JEBSENS MARITIME, INC., PETITIONER, VS. RAMON A. GALUTIRA, RESPONDENT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Jebsens Maritime versus Galutira
The Case
This is Jebsens Maritime, Incorporated versus Ramon A. Galutira, a petition for review brought under Rule 43 of the Rules of Court, which seeks to reverse and set aside the Decision of the Office of the Panel of Voluntary Arbitrators of the National Conciliation and Mediation Board of the National Capital Region. The petitioner, a manning agency, was ordered, together with Hapag-Lloyd Aktiengesellschaft, to pay the respondent seafarer disability benefits and attorney's fees, jointly and severally. The case matters less for any novel maritime doctrine than for what it teaches about the life of a pending petition: that a compromise agreement between the parties, accepted through counsel and coupled with a release of all rights, can end the litigation before the Supreme Court ever reaches the merits. It is a study in the finality of amicable settlement and in the procedural mechanics of withdrawing a petition.
Procedural History
The case began before the Office of the Panel of Voluntary Arbitrators of the National Conciliation and Mediation Board of the National Capital Region. That panel rendered a Decision ordering Jebsens Maritime, Incorporated to pay the respondent, jointly and severally with Hapag-Lloyd Aktiengesellschaft, the sum of 60,000 dollars as disability benefits, plus 10 percent of the total award as attorney's fees. From that Decision, the petitioner went up to the Supreme Court by petition for review under Rule 43. On 21 October 2014, the Court directed the respondent to file a Comment on the petition. Instead of a Comment, the respondent filed a Manifestation informing the Court that the parties had come to an agreement to settle the case amicably, and that the petitioner had offered, and the respondent through counsel had accepted, settlement in exchange for payment of 60,000 dollars. The Compromise Agreement was executed on 30 October 2014. The respondent likewise submitted a Release of All Rights, in Filipino a Pagpapaubaya ng Lahat ng Karapatan, and a Joint Motion to Dismiss was submitted on the ground that the parties had entered into a compromise agreement and a final amicable settlement. The petitioner, for its part, filed a Manifestation and Motion confirming the final settlement of the respondent's claims and moving for the withdrawal of the petition.
Facts
The respondent, Ramon A. Galutira, pursued a claim for disability benefits against the petitioner manning agency and its foreign principal. The claim was resolved in his favor by the Panel of Voluntary Arbitrators, which awarded him 60,000 dollars in disability benefits and 10 percent of the total award as attorney's fees, chargeable jointly and severally against Jebsens Maritime, Incorporated and Hapag-Lloyd Aktiengesellschaft.
Aggrieved, the petitioner elevated the matter to the Supreme Court through a petition for review under Rule 43. While the petition was pending, and after the Court called for a Comment, the parties instead chose the path of settlement. The petitioner offered, and the respondent through counsel accepted, the sum of 60,000 dollars in exchange for a full settlement of the case.
The parties reduced their agreement to a Compromise Agreement executed on 30 October 2014. The respondent executed a Release of All Rights, and the parties jointly moved to dismiss the case on the strength of the compromise and final amicable settlement. The petitioner confirmed the settlement and asked leave to withdraw its own petition.
Issues
- Whether or not the compromise agreement entered into by the parties, together with the release of all rights, operates to terminate the case and render the pending petition moot.
- Whether or not the petitioner's motion to withdraw the petition should be granted in light of the final amicable settlement.
Applicable Provisions
The decision does not quote any statutory provision; it rests on the parties' Compromise Agreement and Release of All Rights as the instruments of settlement. The governing procedural framework is Rule 43 of the Rules of Court, under which the petition for review was filed, and which supplies the vehicle the petitioner now seeks to withdraw.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the compromise agreement and the release of all rights ended the controversy. The parties had manifested that they had come to an agreement to settle the case amicably, that the petitioner had offered and the respondent through counsel had accepted settlement in exchange for payment of 60,000 dollars, and that the Compromise Agreement had been executed on 30 October 2014. The respondent had likewise submitted a Release of All Rights and a Joint Motion to Dismiss grounded on the compromise and final amicable settlement. The Court noted these manifestations and treated the case as closed and terminated.
On the second issue, the Court granted the petitioner's motion. The petitioner had filed a Manifestation and Motion confirming the final settlement of the respondent's claims and moving for the withdrawal of the petition. The Court granted that motion, deemed the petition withdrawn, and consequently considered the case closed and terminated.
Doctrine
A compromise agreement freely entered into by the parties, accepted through counsel and coupled with a release of all rights, puts an end to the litigation and renders the pending petition moot. Once the parties manifest a final amicable settlement and jointly move to dismiss, the Court will note the manifestations, grant the withdrawal of the petition, and consider the case closed and terminated. A seafarer who accepts a settlement sum and executes a release of all rights is bound by that act, and the reviewing court will not proceed to resolve the merits of a controversy the parties themselves have laid to rest.
Disposition
The Court noted the parties' manifestations, granted the petitioner's motion, deemed the petition withdrawn, and considered the case closed and terminated.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing: a compromise agreement and release of all rights, accepted through counsel, close the case and render the pending petition moot. Examiners use this case to test whether a candidate recognizes that settlement terminates litigation and that a withdrawn petition leaves no merits to decide.