RIZALIA CAPUNO AND THELMA VILLANUEVA, COMPLAINANTS, VS. JUDGE AUSBERTO B. JARAMILLO, JR., RESPONDENT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Rizalita Capuno and Thelma Villanueva versus Judge Ausberto Jaramillo, Junior
The Case
This is a consolidated administrative matter. Two sets of complainants, Rizalia Capuno and her daughter Thelma Villanueva in the first, and Celia Pampolina in the second, charged Judge Ausberto Jaramillo, Junior, presiding judge of the Regional Trial Court of San Pablo City, with corrupt practices detrimental to the administration of justice. The first complaint alleged that the judge demanded money from litigants in exchange for a favorable arrangement in a land case pending in his sala. The second alleged that he used a luxury car under court custody for his personal convenience, among other things. The case matters because it fixes the standard of conduct for judges outside the courtroom, and because it shows that grave misconduct in office carries the supreme penalty of dismissal, not mere suspension.
Procedural History
The complaints were filed directly with the Supreme Court as administrative complaints against a judge. The Court referred the first complaint to Justice Corona Ibay-Somera of the Court of Appeals for investigation, report and recommendation, and the second to Deputy Court Administrator Reynaldo Suarez. The Court directed the respondent judge to go on leave and ordered the consolidation of the two complaints. After the investigators submitted their reports, the Court resolved the administrative liability of the respondent on the basis of their findings and recommendations.
Facts
Rizalia Capuno had borrowed fifteen thousand pesos from Pedro Calara, Junior, and mortgaged her small lot as security. Despite partial payments, the property was extrajudicially foreclosed, and Calara bought it at the auction. Calara later obtained a writ of possession from the branch of Judge Jaramillo. Through the sheriff, the complainants were told that the judge wanted to see them. They went to his chambers, and according to the complainants, the judge told them that if Rizalia wished to avoid eviction, they should give him two hundred thousand pesos in cash, preferably in one hundred peso bills, plus a postdated check for one hundred fifty thousand pesos.
The daughter, Thelma, said they could not raise that amount. The judge reduced his demand, but required the money at two o'clock in the afternoon of that same day, and warned them not to talk to anybody. Because they failed to comply, Rizalia was evicted and her house was demolished.
The judge denied the demand. He claimed he was merely mediating, at the request of his sheriff, to help the parties settle the repurchase price, and that it was Thelma who volunteered that she could pay. The investigating justice found the complainants credible, noting that the meetings were held inside the judge's chambers without counsel and without his staff, and that Calara never attended any of them. The investigating justice recommended suspension for one month without pay, with admonition and reprimand. In the second complaint, involving the use of a car under court custody and a conference at a public restaurant, the investigator found that most of the issues were matters already raised in a petition for certiorari then pending before the Court of Appeals.
Issues
- Whether or not the respondent judge is guilty of grave misconduct in office for demanding money from a party litigant in a case pending in his court.
- Whether or not the meetings held in his chambers without counsel and without the other party constitute conduct unbecoming a judge and a violation of the Canons of Judicial Ethics.
- Whether or not the penalty recommended by the investigating justice is the proper penalty under the circumstances.
Applicable Provisions
The decision invokes the Canons of Judicial Ethics on the conduct of a judge, which provides:
A judge's official conduct should be free from the appearance of impropriety, and his personal behavior, not only upon the bench and in the performance of judicial duties, but also in his everyday life, should be beyond reproach.
This canon is the standard against which the respondent's private meetings and money demands were measured.
The decision also cites the canon on the purpose of courts, which provides:
The courts exist to promote justice; and thus to aid in securing the contentment and happiness of the people. Their administration should be speedy and careful. Every judge should at all times be alert in his rulings and in the conduct of the business of his court so far as he can, to make it useful to litigants and to the community. He should avoid unconsciously falling into the attitude of mind that the litigants are made for the courts instead of the courts for the litigants.
This passage grounds the ruling that the complainants were denied justice precisely because they could not deliver the amount demanded.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court found the respondent guilty. The investigating justice found a color of truth in the complaint, and the Court held that the active mediation was highly questionable: it was initiated not by the parties or their lawyers but by the respondent's sheriffs; the meetings were unrecorded and unattended by counsel; and the respondent met only with the complainants, never with Calara. The Court ruled that the act of meeting with complainants without counsel, warning them not to tell anyone, and demanding money under the guise of forging peace constitutes grave misconduct. It quoted the settled rule that:
Acts of the respondent judge of demanding x x x money from a party-litigant before his court constitute serious misconduct in office.
On the second issue, the Court held that the respondent's excuse that parties in the province have no counsel is a faulty and unacceptable practice. Unless a judge is conducting a pre-trial under Rules 20 and 118, his role is to decide contentious cases with finality, and in the absence of their lawyers a judge ought not to meddle in issues confronting the parties even on the pretext of settling their cases. The Court reminded judges that the office of a judge is a public office and, as such, it is a public trust, and that a judicial office demands that the incumbent conduct himself in such a manner as to merit the respect, reverence and confidence of the people.
On the third issue, the Court held that a more severe penalty than one month suspension without pay should be imposed. It noted that a judge who established a common fund and solicited contributions from litigants and visitors was dismissed from the service, and declared that it could do no less in this case.
Doctrine
A judge who demands money from a party litigant in a case pending in his court is guilty of grave misconduct in office, and the penalty is dismissal from the service, not mere suspension. A judge must avoid in-chambers sessions with one party without the other party and his counsel present, and must observe prudence at all times so that he not only acts impartially and with propriety but is also perceived to be impartial and proper. Mediation by a judge outside the rules on pre-trial is improper, especially when initiated by court personnel and conducted without counsel. The office of a judge is a public trust, and his conduct must be beyond reproach, free from the appearance of impropriety.
Disposition
The Court found the respondent judge guilty of grave misconduct and dismissed him from the service.
Remember This
Memorize the line that demanding money from a party litigant before his court constitutes serious misconduct in office, and that the penalty is dismissal. Examiners use this case in legal ethics and judicial conduct questions, particularly on in-chambers meetings, mediation outside pre-trial, and the penalty for grave misconduct by a judge.