FIRST SOVEREIGN ASSET MANAGEMENT (SPV-AMC), INC., AS SUCCESSOR-IN-INTEREST OF THE MANILA BANKING CORPORATION, PETITIONER, VS. SPOUSES FELIX TEE JATAP AND TERESITA JATAP, RESPOND…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
First Sovereign Asset Management versus Jatap
The Case
This is a case about a bank that foreclosed on a family home and then found itself ordered to pay back what it had collected. First Sovereign Asset Management, as successor-in-interest of the Manila Banking Corporation, sought relief from the Supreme Court after the Office of the President ruled against it in a housing and land use dispute with the spouses Felix Tee Jatap and Teresita Jatap. The case matters for two reasons. First, it shows how the Supreme Court treats a motion for reconsideration that offers no new argument. Second, and more usefully for the reviewee, it shows that a losing party is not necessarily left without a remedy: the very decision it complains of may itself contain the directive that preserves its rights.
Procedural History
The dispute began before the Housing and Land Use Arbiter, who rendered a decision on April 4, 2003. That decision was penned by Arbiter Marino Bernardo M. Torres. The case then went up to the Office of the President, where it was docketed as O.P. Case Number 08-G-241. The Office of the President issued a Decision on September 30, 2011, and later an Order dated December 19, 2011. Both rulings went against the petitioner bank.
The bank then came to the Supreme Court by petition. On February 25, 2014, the Supreme Court rendered a Decision dismissing the petition and affirming the September 30, 2011 Decision and the December 19, 2011 Order of the Office of the President. The bank moved for reconsideration on March 20, 2014, pleading grave injustice. That motion for reconsideration is the matter resolved in the present resolution.
Facts
The petitioner is First Sovereign Asset Management, an asset management company acting as successor-in-interest of the Manila Banking Corporation. The respondents are the spouses Felix Tee Jatap and Teresita Jatap. The dispute arose from a loan owed by the spouses to the bank, secured by what the proceedings treat as their home, and from the bank's foreclosure of that security.
The controversy was litigated first before the Housing and Land Use Arbiter, who decided the case on April 4, 2003. The arbiter's decision did not simply resolve the foreclosure. It contained an express directive for the payment of any outstanding balance on the loan owed to the petitioner, and likewise directed the reimbursement of any amount already paid by the petitioner to the respondents.
The bank elevated the matter to the Office of the President, which affirmed the arbiter in its Decision of September 30, 2011 and its Order of December 19, 2011. The bank then brought the case to the Supreme Court, which dismissed the petition on February 25, 2014. The bank moved for reconsideration on March 20, 2014, insisting that the disposition worked a grave injustice upon it.
Issues
- Whether or not the motion for reconsideration of the February 25, 2014 Decision should be granted.
- Whether or not the petitioner is left without recourse after the dismissal of its petition and the affirmance of the rulings of the Office of the President.
Applicable Provisions
The decision resolves a motion for reconsideration and does not quote or construe any statutory provision. It turns instead on the settled rule that a motion for reconsideration must be grounded on a cogent reason, and on the express directives contained in the April 4, 2003 Decision of the Housing and Land Use Arbiter. No provision of law is therefore quoted here, because none is quoted or discussed in the decision text.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court denied the motion for reconsideration for lack of merit. It held that no cogent reason appeared for the reconsideration sought. The bank had merely repeated its plea of grave injustice; it offered no new or substantial argument that would justify disturbing the February 25, 2014 Decision.
On the second issue, the Court addressed the bank's fear that it would be left without a remedy. It noted that the April 4, 2003 Decision subject of the case includes an express directive for the payment of any outstanding balance on the loan owed to the petitioner, as well as for the reimbursement of any amount already paid by the petitioner to the respondents. On that basis the Court concluded that the petitioner is not left without recourse and may yet enforce its rights through the proper remedies.
Doctrine
Three rules may be carried into an answer. First, a motion for reconsideration must rest on a cogent reason; a bare plea of grave injustice, without more, is not enough, and the motion will be denied for lack of merit. Second, the denial of a petition does not extinguish a party's substantive rights where the very decision affirmed contains a directive in that party's favor. The winning of the appeal and the preservation of the right are two different things. Third, a party who obtains such a directive in the judgment may enforce it through the proper remedies, which in this case means recovering any outstanding balance on the loan and the reimbursement of amounts already paid.
Disposition
The Supreme Court denied the motion for reconsideration for lack of merit, leaving the February 25, 2014 Decision and the rulings of the Office of the President undisturbed, while noting that the petitioner may still enforce its rights under the April 4, 2003 Decision through the proper remedies.
Remember This
Memorize this line: a denial of the petition is not a denial of the right, because the affirmed decision itself may carry the directive that preserves it. Examiners use this case to test whether a student understands that a motion for reconsideration needs a cogent reason, and that a litigant who loses on procedure may still win on substance.