INTERNATIONAL CONTAINER TERMINAL SERVICES, INC. (ICTSI), PETITIONER, VS. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION (2ND DIVISION), ADUANA SKILLED AND UNSKILLED UNION (ADSULU), LUZVIMI…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
International Container Terminal Services versus Aduana Skilled and Unskilled Labor Union
The Case
This is a petition for certiorari under Rule 65 filed by International Container Terminal Services, also called ICTSI, against the National Labor Relations Commission and the Aduana Skilled and Unskilled Labor Union, together with the Luzviminda Integrated Stevedoring Labor Union and several individual workers. ICTSI asks the Supreme Court to reverse and set aside the Commission's resolution of February 7, 1991 and its order of April 19, 1991 denying partial reconsideration. The case matters because it fixes the rule on the non-absorption of workers by a successor employer, on when such non-absorption becomes a constructive illegal dismissal, and on the precise limits of the penalty of dismissal for participation in an illegal strike.
Procedural History
The labor dispute began with notices of strike and two actual strikes at the ICTSI terminal. The Secretary of Labor certified the dispute to the National Labor Relations Commission for compulsory arbitration. The Commission rendered a resolution on February 7, 1991 declaring both strikes illegal, holding the non-absorption of certain workers to be a constructive illegal dismissal, ordering their reinstatement with backwages, and ordering the reinstatement without backwages of Domingo Paano and twenty others. ICTSI moved for partial reconsideration, which the Commission denied on April 19, 1991. ICTSI then went directly to the Supreme Court by petition for certiorari under Rule 65, alleging grave abuse of discretion.
Facts
The Manila International Container Terminal was owned and operated by the Philippine Ports Authority. Its operation was awarded to private operators in succession, and on July 21, 1987 the Authority took over the terminal itself when it did not renew the permit of the last operator. On May 19, 1988, the Authority awarded the management and operation of the terminal to ICTSI, which took over on June 12, 1988. Their contract allowed ICTSI to screen the existing workers individually and to retain only those it chose, and it required ICTSI to enter into a collective bargaining agreement with one labor union.
ICTSI screened the workers, and more than six hundred of the fifteen hundred workers were not absorbed. As to twenty-three workers, however, ICTSI extended their services beyond the June 12 cut-off, and their salaries for the extended period were paid in pay envelopes bearing the ICTSI letterhead and reflecting deductions for Social Security System and Medicare premiums. Meanwhile, the Aduana Skilled and Unskilled Labor Union and the Luzviminda Integrated Stevedoring Labor Union filed a petition for certification election, which the Bureau of Labor Relations later dismissed because the unions had no legal personality to represent the bargaining unit at ICTSI. The unions staged a strike on August 16 and 17, 1988, and another strike on March 1, 2 and 3, 1989. ICTSI issued suspension letters and then dismissal letters to twenty-one workers on the grounds of insubordination, engaging in union activities during working hours, and participating in an illegal strike.
Issues
- Whether or not the non-absorption of the workers whose services were extended beyond the cut-off period constituted constructive illegal dismissal.
- Whether or not the order of reinstatement of Domingo Paano and the twenty others was justified despite their participation in the strike.
Applicable Provisions
Article 264, paragraph (a) of the Labor Code, as quoted in the decision, provides:
Any union officer who knowingly participates in an illegal strike and any worker or union officer who knowingly participates in the commission of illegal acts during a strike may be declared to have lost his employment status.
This provision fixes who may be dismissed for strike participation, and it distinguishes union officers from ordinary members.
Article 280 of the Labor Code, as amended, is invoked by the Commission through its resolution, which states:
To hold otherwise, would render meaningless the security of tenure granted by law (Article 280, Labor Code, as amended) to regular employees who, like the dismissed employees in the case at bar, perform functions and duties reasonably necessary or desirable in the usual trade or business of their employers.
This provision anchors the security of tenure that survives in favor of employees absorbed by a successor employer.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the non-absorption was a constructive illegal dismissal. ICTSI had the prerogative to choose whom to retain, and the non-absorption of six hundred workers was legal. But as to the twenty-three whose services ICTSI itself extended beyond the cut-off period, the extension could only mean that ICTSI found them qualified and chose to retain them. Their rights and privileges as employees therefore survived against the successor employer. The Court rejected the claim that the Philippine Ports Authority had extended their services, because the Authority had already ceased to have any say in the terminal's operations, and because the salaries were paid in ICTSI pay envelopes with Social Security System and Medicare deductions.
On the second issue, the Court held that reinstatement was proper. Under Article 264, a union officer may be dismissed for knowingly participating in an illegal strike, but an ordinary worker may be dismissed only for knowingly participating in illegal acts during the strike. The Court found nothing in the records showing that Paano and the twenty others were the leaders of the strike; Paano's testimony merely described those who were active in picketing. Since ICTSI presented no evidence that they agitated, cajoled or led others to join, they were at most mere union members, and their failure to heed their superior's order not to join the picket line amounted only to insubordination, not an illegal act during the strike. The Court also deferred to the Commission's findings of fact, which are accorded respect and even finality when supported by substantial evidence.
Doctrine
First, a successor employer may choose whom to absorb, but once it extends the services of workers beyond the cut-off period, it is deemed to have absorbed them, and their employment status and privileges survive against it; their subsequent termination without cause is a constructive illegal dismissal. Second, under Article 264, paragraph (a) of the Labor Code, a union officer may be dismissed for knowingly participating in an illegal strike, but an ordinary worker may be dismissed only for knowingly participating in illegal acts during the strike, whether the strike is legal or illegal. Third, mere participation in a picket line, or insubordination in joining it, is not an illegal act during a strike that justifies dismissal.
Disposition
The petition was dismissed for lack of merit, and the resolution of the National Labor Relations Commission dated February 7, 1991 was affirmed.
Remember This
Memorize this line: extension of services beyond the cut-off absorbs the worker, and non-absorption then becomes constructive illegal dismissal. Examiners use this case on successor employers and on the distinction between union officers and ordinary members under Article 264 of the Labor Code.