🎧 Case Brief Lecture

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. WALTER NACIONAL ALIAS “KA DENNIS,” ABSALON MILLAMINA ALIAS “KA ALVIN,” EFREN MUSA, RUDY LUCES, JAVIER MIRABETE ALIAS “COMMANDE…

G.R. Nos. 111294-95. September 07, 1995 September 7, 1995

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

People versus Mirabete

The Case

This is People versus Mirabete, a criminal appeal decided by the Supreme Court in September 1995. The People of the Philippines prosecuted several men for the killing of two brothers, Quirino and Joel Lagason, in Daraga, Albay, and the trial court convicted them of two counts of murder. The case matters to a reviewee for three reasons: it shows how conspiracy is proved and how it fixes liability on a member who never fired a shot, it illustrates evident premeditation as a qualifying circumstance, and it settles that a conditional pardon wipes out neither the criminal liability of the pardoned accused nor their solidary civil liability for indemnity.

Procedural History

Two separate informations for murder were filed against Walter Nacional, Absalon Millamina, Efren Musa, Rudy Luces, Javier Mirabete, and Zacarias Militante. When arraigned, all except Millamina, who remained at large, pleaded not guilty. The two cases were consolidated and tried by the Regional Trial Court, Branch 9, Legazpi City. On May 31, 1993, the trial court rendered judgment convicting the five accused present of two counts of murder, qualified by evident premeditation and attended by conspiracy, sentencing each to reclusion perpetua, ordering each to indemnify the heirs of each victim in the amount of 50,000 pesos, and to pay the costs. All five convicted accused appealed to the Supreme Court, which accepted the appeal. Walter Nacional, Zacarias Militante, and Efren Musa later withdrew their appeal, claiming the charges were political and that they had applied for conditional pardon; the Court granted the withdrawal. Rudy Luces also withdrew his appeal after receiving conditional pardon, and his appeal was dismissed. Only Javier Mirabete pursued his appeal.

Facts

The six accused were civilian members of the barangay organization of the Communist Party of the Philippines and the New People's Army at Daraga, Albay. A few days before February 21, 1985, the organization held a conference at Barangay Lacag where Quirino and Joel Lagason were identified as military informers and proposed for liquidation. Their team leader disapproved the proposal for lack of clearance from higher authorities.

On February 21, 1985, at four o'clock in the afternoon, the group gathered in front of the RCPI building at Lacag. Wilson Lita told them they were going on a mission to Salvacion to confront the two alleged informers, and that if the brothers resisted, they were to be killed. Others were assigned to provide security. Wilson Lita and Absalon Millamina were each armed with a short firearm, and the group walked toward Salvacion, four kilometers away.

Along the way, the group met Crisanto Miranda at a waiting shed and asked him to accompany them. Wilson Lita, Zacarias Militante, and Mirabete stayed behind at the waiting shed while the rest proceeded. On the road, the group met Quirino and Joel. Walter Nacional approached Quirino, pulled out a gun, and shot him between the eyebrows; he died instantly. Seconds later, Absalon Millamina shot Joel on the head, and he died a few hours later in the hospital. The group fled. Mirabete denied participation, claiming he was merely watching a volleyball game near the scene.

Issues

  • Whether or not the accused-appellant Javier Mirabete was sufficiently identified as part of the group that killed the Lagasons.
  • Whether or not conspiracy was established, making Mirabete liable as a co-principal although he was not at the exact place of the shooting.
  • Whether or not evident premeditation qualified the killings to murder.
  • Whether or not abuse of superior strength attended the crimes.
  • Whether or not the grant of conditional pardon to the other accused extinguished their civil liability for indemnity.

Applicable Provisions

Article 36 of the Revised Penal Code, on pardon, provides:

Pardon, by whatever name it may be called, shall not exempt the culprit from the payment of the civil indemnity.

This is the provision the Court invokes to hold that the conditional pardon granted to the other accused did not release them from the civil indemnity.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that Mirabete's identification was established not only by the two eyewitnesses but by other witnesses as well, including a former rebel team leader, the storekeeper he asked for directions, and his own co-accused Walter Nacional. The delay of Crisanto Miranda in revealing the identities did not impair his credibility, because he had been threatened and fled to Manila for fear of his life.

On the second issue, the Court held that conspiracy was clearly established. It defined the concept in these words:

Conspiracy arises at the very instant the plotters agree, expressly or impliedly, to commit the felony and forthwith to actually pursue it.

The Court stressed that Mirabete's presence at the waiting shed was itself part of the plan, since that shed stood strategically at the entrance to and exit from the victims' house, and his role was to provide security. It then laid down the rule of collective liability:

A conspiracy, once established, makes each of the conspirators liable for the acts of the others.

On the third issue, the Court held that evident premeditation was present, because the execution of the criminal act was preceded by cool thought and reflection, with sufficient time between the resolution and the execution for the offenders to arrive at a calm judgment. On the fourth issue, the Court agreed with the trial court that abuse of superior strength could not be appreciated, since mere superiority in number does not prove it. It also found no mitigating circumstance, because Mirabete was only 59 years old at the time of the offense, not over 70. Finally, on the fifth issue, the Court held that the conditional pardon did not extinguish the civil liability arising from the crime, and that the indemnity of 50,000 pesos for each death must be shared solidarily by all the accused.

Doctrine

A conspiracy exists from the very moment the plotters agree, expressly or impliedly, to commit the felony and forthwith pursue it. Once conspiracy is established, every conspirator is liable as a co-principal for the acts of the others, regardless of the extent of his participation, because in contemplation of law the act of one is the act of all. A conspirator who provides security at a strategic point, though absent from the exact scene of the shooting, is still liable. Evident premeditation requires cool thought and reflection, with sufficient time between the resolution and the execution for calm judgment. Mere superiority in number does not amount to abuse of superior strength. And under Article 36 of the Revised Penal Code, a conditional pardon, by whatever name it is called, does not exempt the culprit from payment of the civil indemnity.

Disposition

The Supreme Court affirmed the decision of the trial court insofar as the criminal liability of Javier Mirabete is concerned, and insofar as the civil liability of all the accused in both cases.

Remember This

Memorize the line that conspiracy arises the instant the plotters agree and forthwith pursue the felony, and that the act of one is the act of all. Examiners use this case to test conspiracy by a look-out or security man absent from the scene, and to test whether conditional pardon extinguishes civil indemnity, which it does not.