🎧 Case Brief Lecture

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. ELBERT AMAR Y SOLEDAD AND ALDEFONSO DE LA PENA Y HERNANDEZ, ACCUSED-APPELLANTS.

G.R. Nos. 104872-73. June 01, 1994 June 1, 1994

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

People versus Amar

The Case

This is a criminal appeal in which the People of the Philippines prosecuted Elbert Amar and Aldefonso de la Pena for the killing of Sergeant Emmanuel Caballero. Two separate murder charges were filed, the two accused were tried jointly, and both were convicted. The case matters for the bar for three reasons: it shows how the courts test the credibility of evidence, both for the prosecution and for the defense; it illustrates the rule on conspiracy and how the act of one conspirator binds all; and it demonstrates the correct treatment of evident premeditation as a qualifying circumstance, whose absence reduces murder to homicide.

Procedural History

Two informations for murder were filed against the accused, one against Elbert Amar and another against Aldefonso de la Pena. Each was raffled to a different branch of the Regional Trial Court of Manila. Both accused pleaded not guilty. Upon motion of the private prosecutor, the two cases were consolidated and tried jointly. The Regional Trial Court of Manila, Branch 5, sitting as a special criminal court, rendered a judgment of conviction, sentencing both accused to life imprisonment and ordering each of them to indemnify the heirs of the victim in the amount of 30,000 pesos. The accused appealed directly to the Supreme Court, assigning errors against the findings of the trial court.

Facts

At about six o'clock in the evening of 26 June 1988, Amadeo Lactao was having a drinking session near his house at Ulilang Kawayan, Paco, Manila, together with Elbert Amar, Aldefonso de la Pena, and two others. Sergeant Emmanuel Caballero passed by on his way to the house of Virgilio de Luna. The group invited him to drink, but he declined, saying he had to speak with de Luna about finding a job for a certain Evelyn who was with him. Caballero and Evelyn then proceeded to de Luna's house.

On their way back, Caballero and Evelyn again passed the group. According to the prosecution eyewitness Virgilio de Luna, Lactao shot Caballero but hit Elbert Amar instead. Caballero then drew his service pistol and shot Lactao. Aldefonso de la Pena went behind Caballero and hacked his right hand with a bolo, causing him to drop his gun. Elbert Amar then ran toward Caballero and repeatedly stabbed him. As Caballero fell, Lactao got up and shot him four times. Caballero died on the spot from hemorrhagic shock due to multiple gunshot wounds on the head and stab wounds on the body. Lactao himself died two days later from his gunshot wounds.

The defense told a different story. Four defense witnesses testified that Caballero first accosted Lactao, pushed him into an open canal, and shot him; that Amar was only trying to pacify Caballero when de Luna tried to stab Amar from behind; and that Lactao then got up and shot Caballero, while de la Pena merely stood by, seemingly in shock. The trial court gave more credence to the prosecution witnesses, and the Supreme Court found the prosecution account more consistent with the autopsy findings.

Issues

  • Whether or not the trial court erred in finding the accused guilty beyond reasonable doubt on the basis of the eyewitness testimony of Virgilio de Luna, which the defense claims contradicts the autopsy findings.
  • Whether or not the trial court erred in not giving more weight to the testimonies of the defense witnesses, whose version the defense claims is more consistent with the autopsy findings.
  • Whether or not the trial court erred in failing to appreciate the alleged ill motive of the witness Virgilio de Luna in testifying against the accused.
  • Whether or not conspiracy and the qualifying circumstance of evident premeditation were established, and what crime and penalty are proper.

Applicable Provisions

Section 14, Rule 110 of the Rules of Court, on amendment of the information, provides:

Section 14. Amendment. The information or complaint may be amended, in substance or form, without leave of court, at any time before the accused pleads; and thereafter and during the trial as to all matters of form, by leave and at the discretion of the court, when the same can be done without prejudice to the rights of the accused.

The Court cited this provision to point out that when the identities of the unknown co-conspirators were established, the first information should have been amended rather than a second information filed, which would have avoided the raffle of two informations to two branches and the need for consolidation.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the prosecution evidence was more consistent with the autopsy findings than the defense version. The victim suffered several gunshot wounds, four stab wounds, an incised wound, a lacerated wound, and a hack wound that almost severed his right hand at the wrist. The Court found that no defense witness could explain how Caballero sustained four stab wounds if only de Luna was armed with a bladed weapon, and that even assuming de Luna wielded a bolo, the defense version remained unbelievable because, by the defense's own account, no one else was present at the scene who could have inflicted those stab wounds. The Court stressed that evidence must first be believable and logical before it can be accorded any weight.

On the second issue, the Court held that the trial court's findings on the credibility of witnesses are accorded the highest respect absent any special or compelling circumstances. The Court also held that the rule requiring evidence to be credible in itself, consistent with common experience, applies not only to prosecution evidence but also to the evidence for the defense, without violating the presumption of innocence, since the prosecution must still prove guilt with moral certainty.

On the third issue, the Court rejected the claim of ill motive, finding no basis to discredit the eyewitness on that ground.

On the fourth issue, the Court found that the accused and the deceased Amadeo Lactao clearly conspired to inflict injury on Caballero, so all of them are liable for his death. However, the Court agreed with the Solicitor General that the qualifying circumstance of evident premeditation was not clearly established. Accordingly, the killing was deemed homicide and not murder, and the penalty was reduced to 8 years and 1 day of prision mayor as minimum to 14 years, 8 months and 1 day of reclusion temporal as maximum. The civil indemnity was increased from 30,000 pesos each to 50,000 pesos each.

Doctrine

First, for evidence to be believed, it must not only come from a credible witness; it must be credible in itself, such as common experience and observation can approve as probable under the circumstances. Courts are not required to believe that which they judicially know to be unnatural, unusual, and improbable. This test applies to the evidence of both the prosecution and the defense.

Second, absent any special or compelling circumstances, the findings of the trial court on the credibility of witnesses are accorded the highest respect by the Supreme Court.

Third, when the accused conspire to inflict injury on the victim, all of them are liable for the victim's death, and the act of one is the act of all.

Fourth, evident premeditation must be clearly established to qualify a killing as murder; if it is not, the killing is homicide and the penalty must be reduced accordingly.

Disposition

The judgment of conviction was affirmed with modification: the accused were convicted of homicide rather than murder, sentenced to the reduced penalty, and ordered to pay increased civil indemnity of 50,000 pesos each to the victim's heirs.

Remember This

The single line worth memorizing is that evidence must be credible in itself, tested against common experience, and this standard applies to the defense as much as to the prosecution. Examiners like to use this case to test the doctrine on credibility of witnesses, the rule on conspiracy, and the effect of failure to prove evident premeditation, which reduces murder to homicide.