THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. CARLOS SANTIAGO ET AL., DEFENDANTS AND APPELLANTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
United States versus Santiago
The Case
This is a criminal prosecution brought by the United States against Carlos Santiago and his companions for the violent taking of carabaos in the Philippine countryside in the early years of American rule. The accused were charged with robbery committed by a band, and the case matters because it shows how the Supreme Court, applying the old Penal Code, treated armed group robbery, the presumption of intimidation, and the rule that circumstances inherent in a specific offense cannot be counted again as aggravating circumstances. It is a compact lesson in the elements of robbery in a band and in the correct grading of the penalty.
Procedural History
The accused were tried in the court below, which convicted them and imposed a personal penalty upon each. The case then went up to the Supreme Court on appeal. The Supreme Court reviewed the record, found the guilt of the accused fully established, but held that the trial court erred in the personal penalty imposed. It therefore reversed the judgment as to that penalty and otherwise affirmed the conviction.
Facts
On the afternoon of the twenty-ninth of September, 1901, the three accused and four others, armed with bolos and guns, seized two carabaos belonging to Don Teodoro Sandico. One of these carabaos was being ridden by a boy named Abdon Somera, nine years old, and the other by Modesto Palasigui, fifteen years old. The robbery took place at a place called Sacumvaca in the town of Talavera. At the same time, eight other carabaos belonging to Don Casimiro Tinio were taken, the total value being five hundred eighty dollars.
The three accused were subsequently arrested on the seventeenth of October, 1901, at a place called Pinambatan in the town of San Miguel de Mayumo. Part of the stolen carabaos were found in their possession, as well as Abdon Somera, one of the boys taken. The other lad, Palasigui, succeeded in escaping after being in the hands of the robbers for four days. The crime of kidnapping was prosecuted in a separate case.
The taking was established by the testimony of Modesto Palasigui, an eyewitness; by the testimony of Rosalio Somera, the father of Abdon, who upon arriving at the place where the boys had been noted their disappearance and could not find them; and by the testimony of the three policemen who captured the accused and found some of the stolen carabaos in their possession, of which the accused could give no satisfactory account. The policemen also found the boy Abdon Somera in their hands. The record showed that the seven men were brigands engaged in assaulting and robbing travelers and stealing carabaos from the fields.
Issues
- Whether or not the taking of the carabaos, even without proof of actual force or threats against the two boys, constitutes robbery by intimidation.
- Whether or not the circumstances of the robbery having been committed by a band and in an uninhabited place may be taken as generic aggravating circumstances.
- Whether or not the penalty imposed by the court below was the correct penalty under the Penal Code.
Applicable Provisions
The decision applies article 502 of the Penal Code on the crime of robbery. The Court treats the taking as robbery in a band punishable under article 502, article 503, paragraph 5, and article 504.
Robbery in a band is punishable under article 502, 503, paragraph 5, and 504 of the Penal Code.
This provision defines the offense and fixes the range of penalties for robbery committed by a band.
The decision also applies article 503, paragraph 5, which fixes the penalty for robbery by a band.
They are therefore subject to the penalty prescribed by section 5 of article 503 in the medium period of the maximum grade in accordance with the provisions of article 504 of the Penal Code.
This provision determines the specific penalty to be imposed on the accused.
The decision applies article 504 of the Penal Code on the penalty for robbery in a band.
In the commission of this crime of robbery no generic mitigating or aggravating circumstances are present, the circumstances of the robbery having been committed by a gang and in an uninhabited place being inherent in the specific offense.
This provision governs the graduation of the penalty and the rule that inherent circumstances are not aggravating.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the absence of proof of actual force or threats against the two boys made no difference. The fact that seven men armed with firearms and bolos seized the two boys, took the carabaos, and carried them off was sufficient to raise the presumption that this was against the will of the boys and that the intimidation which characterizes robbery was present, it not appearing that the boys voluntarily accompanied the robbers or voluntarily delivered the carabaos. The crime was therefore robbery by intimidation.
On the second issue, the Court held that no generic mitigating or aggravating circumstances were present, because the circumstances of the robbery having been committed by a gang and in an uninhabited place were inherent in the specific offense. They could not be counted again to raise the penalty.
On the third issue, the Court held that the trial court erred in the personal penalty imposed. The accused were subject to the penalty prescribed by section 5 of article 503 in the medium period of the maximum grade, in accordance with article 504 of the Penal Code. The Court therefore reversed the judgment as to the personal penalty and imposed the correct penalty of eight years of presidio mayor, with the accessory penalties of absolute temporal inhabilitation in its full extent and subjection to the vigilance of the authorities for a period equal to the duration of the principal penalty, counted from the expiration of the latter, and to the payment by each of one-third part of the costs of both instances. The judgment was otherwise affirmed, with the other third part of the costs de oficio.
Doctrine
A Bar candidate should retain these rules. First, robbery by a band is committed when more than three armed malefactors take personal property by means of violence or intimidation against persons. Second, intimidation is presumed when armed men seize persons and property, even without proof of actual force or threats, where it does not appear that the persons voluntarily accompanied the robbers or voluntarily delivered the property. Third, circumstances that are inherent in the specific offense, such as the robbery being committed by a band and in an uninhabited place, cannot be taken as generic aggravating circumstances. Fourth, the penalty for robbery in a band is that prescribed by article 503, paragraph 5, in the medium period of the maximum grade, in accordance with article 504 of the Penal Code.
Disposition
The Court reversed the judgment as to the personal penalty, imposed eight years of presidio mayor with the accessory penalties, and otherwise affirmed the conviction, with costs apportioned as stated.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing is that armed men who seize persons and property raise the presumption of intimidation, and circumstances inherent in the offense cannot be counted as aggravating. Examiners use this case to test the elements of robbery in a band and the rule on inherent circumstances in the grading of penalties.