JOHN GRUINDROD, PLAINTIFF AND APPELLANT, VS. LIZARRAGA HERMANOS, DEFENDANT AND APPELLEE.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Gruindrod versus Lizarraga Hermanos
The Case
This is John Gruindrod against Lizarraga Hermanos, a case decided by the Supreme Court in November 1902, in the early years of the Philippine Reports. Gruindrod was the plaintiff and appellant; Lizarraga Hermanos was the defendant and appellee. The matter before the Court was not the merits of the dispute at all, but a motion to dismiss the bill of exceptions Gruindrod had brought up. The question was whether the resolution he sought to appeal from was a final judgment. The case matters because it fixes, in the clearest terms, the rule that only a final judgment may be appealed, and that an order setting aside a judgment and directing a new trial is not final but interlocutory.
Procedural History
The action began in the Court of First Instance of Iloilo. Before that court, a judgment had been rendered by the Superior Provost Court. The Court of First Instance then issued a resolution setting aside that judgment and placing the action on its calendar for a new trial. From that resolution, Gruindrod excepted and perfected a bill of exceptions, seeking to bring the matter to the Supreme Court. Lizarraga Hermanos moved to dismiss the bill of exceptions on the ground, among others, that the resolution excepted to is not a final judgment. The Supreme Court resolved that motion in this decision.
Facts
The record is short. A judgment was rendered in the case by the Superior Provost Court. That judgment came before the Court of First Instance of Iloilo, which issued a resolution setting the judgment aside and ordering that the action be placed on the calendar of the Court of First Instance of Iloilo for a new trial.
Gruindrod took exception to that resolution and perfected a bill of exceptions, evidently intending to challenge the setting aside of the provost court's judgment before the Supreme Court. Lizarraga Hermanos responded with a motion to dismiss the bill of exceptions, arguing that the resolution was not a final judgment and so could not be appealed.
Nothing in the decision suggests that the merits of the original dispute were ever reached by the Supreme Court. The sole matter before the Court was the procedural question of appealability.
Issues
- Whether or not the resolution of the Court of First Instance setting aside the judgment of the Superior Provost Court and ordering a new trial is a final judgment that may be the subject of appeal to the Supreme Court.
- Whether or not the bill of exceptions perfected from that resolution should be dismissed.
Applicable Provisions
Article 123 of the Code of Civil Procedure provides:
No interlocutory or incidental ruling, order, or judgment of the Court of First Instance shall stay the progress of an action or proceeding therein pending, but only such ruling, order, or judgment as finally determines the action or proceeding; nor shall any ruling, order, or judgment be the subject of appeal to the Supreme Court until final judgment is rendered for one party or the other.
This is the provision that bars the appeal, because it permits an appeal only from a ruling that finally determines the action.
Article 143 of the Code of Civil Procedure provides:
Upon the rendition of final judgment disposing of the action, either party shall have the right to perfect a bill of exceptions.
This confirms that the right to perfect a bill of exceptions arises only upon a final judgment disposing of the action.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the resolution excepted to is not a final judgment. The Court examined what the resolution actually ordered. It set aside the judgment of the Superior Provost Court and placed the action on the calendar of the Court of First Instance of Iloilo for a new trial. The Court reasoned that this determination, so far from finally disposing of the case, expressly held that there had been no final judgment therein, and retained it for a new trial. In so holding, the Court relied on its earlier ruling in Francisco M. Go-Quico versus Municipal Board of Manila.
On the second issue, because the resolution was not a final judgment, the bill of exceptions taken from it could not stand. The Court applied the plain terms of Article 123, which provides that no ruling, order, or judgment shall be the subject of appeal to the Supreme Court until final judgment is rendered for one party or the other, and of Article 143, which grants the right to perfect a bill of exceptions only upon the rendition of final judgment disposing of the action.
Doctrine
Only a final judgment may be appealed. An interlocutory or incidental ruling, order, or judgment of the Court of First Instance does not stay the progress of the action, and it may not be the subject of appeal to the Supreme Court until final judgment is rendered for one party or the other, as Article 123 of the Code of Civil Procedure commands.
The test is whether the ruling finally determines the action or proceeding. An order that sets aside a judgment and directs a new trial does not finally dispose of the case. It expressly holds that there has been no final judgment and retains the case for further proceedings. It is therefore interlocutory and not appealable.
The right to perfect a bill of exceptions arises only upon the rendition of final judgment disposing of the action, in the words of Article 143. A bill of exceptions perfected from a non-final resolution is premature and must be dismissed.
Disposition
The Court granted the motion and dismissed the bill of exceptions, with costs against the appellant Gruindrod.
Remember This
Memorize the line that an order setting aside a judgment and directing a new trial is not a final judgment but an interlocutory order, and so cannot be appealed until final judgment is rendered for one party or the other. Examiners use this case to test the rule on appealability of interlocutory orders and the timing of the right to perfect a bill of exceptions.