PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. GEORGE AGUSTIN Y POCNO, ACCUSED-APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
People versus Agustin
The Case
This is the People of the Philippines against George Agustin y Pocno, a criminal case that began as a prosecution for selling and delivering dried marijuana leaves and ended as a lesson on the retroactive reach of a favorable penal law. Agustin was convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment under the Dangerous Drugs Act. After a later law reduced the penalty for small quantities of marijuana, and after this Court had already affirmed his conviction, he asked the Court to modify his sentence. The case matters because it shows how a convicted person may still benefit from a mitigating amendment even after final judgment, and how the Court will treat a motion as a petition for habeas corpus to reach that just result.
Procedural History
Agustin was charged before the Regional Trial Court of Baguio City, Branch 3, under an information dated 25 January 1988, for selling and delivering ninety grams of dried marijuana leaves in violation of Section 4, Article II, of Republic Act Number 6425, as amended. The First Assistant City Fiscal of Baguio City recommended no bail. In a decision dated 06 March 1990, the trial court convicted him and imposed life imprisonment, a fine of 20,000 pesos, and costs. Agustin elevated the case to this Court, which affirmed the judgment on 13 November 1992. Later, invoking the second paragraph of Section 20 of Republic Act Number 6425, as amended by Section 17 of Republic Act Number 7659, and as construed in People versus Simon, Agustin, through the Public Attorney's Office, filed a motion for reconsideration and modification of sentence. The Court treated that motion as substantial compliance with the rules on habeas corpus and resolved it in this decision.
Facts
George Agustin y Pocno was already under detention when, on 25 January 1988, an information was filed charging him with having sold and delivered ninety grams of dried marijuana leaves, in violation of Section 4, Article II, of Republic Act Number 6425, as amended. The prosecuting fiscal recommended that no bail be granted.
On 06 March 1990, the Regional Trial Court of Baguio City, Branch 3, convicted Agustin and sentenced him to life imprisonment, with a fine of 20,000 pesos and costs. He brought the matter to this Court, which affirmed the conviction on 13 November 1992.
In the meantime, Republic Act Number 7659 amended the Dangerous Drugs Act. Under the amendment, as construed in People versus Simon, where the quantity of marijuana involved is less than 250 grams, the penalty is prision correccional, which carries a duration of six months and one day to six years. Agustin's ninety grams fell below that threshold. By 17 April 1995, his prison records showed he had been incarcerated for eight years and nineteen days, well beyond the possible maximum of six years. He then filed a motion for reconsideration and modification of sentence.
Issues
- Whether or not Agustin may still invoke the retroactive effect of the amendatory law reducing the penalty, despite the finality of the judgment affirming his conviction.
- Whether or not his motion for reconsideration and modification of sentence may be treated as a petition for habeas corpus.
- Whether or not Agustin is entitled to release, having served more than the imposable penalty.
Applicable Provisions
The second paragraph of Section 20 of Republic Act Number 6425, as amended by Section 17 of Republic Act Number 7659, provides:
If the quantity of marijuana involved is less than 250 grams, the penalty shall be prision correccional.
This provision is the basis for reducing Agustin's penalty, since the ninety grams of marijuana in his case is below the 250 gram threshold.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court recognized that the amendment, as construed in People versus Simon, lowers the penalty to prision correccional where the marijuana involved is less than 250 grams. Agustin's ninety grams fell within that rule, so the newly prescribed penalty applied to him.
On the second issue, the Court noted that the usual proper remedy for invoking the retroactive effect of Republic Act Number 7659 is a petition for habeas corpus. Following its Resolution in Rolando Angeles y Bombita versus Director of New Bilibid Prison, dated 04 January 1995, which allowed a liberal application of the rules on habeas corpus in cases of this nature, the Court treated Agustin's motion as substantial compliance with those rules.
On the third issue, the Court found that Agustin had already been incarcerated for eight years and nineteen days as of 17 April 1995, well beyond the possible maximum of six years of prision correccional in his particular case. Having served more than the imposable penalty, he was entitled to release.
Doctrine
A person convicted under the Dangerous Drugs Act may invoke the retroactive effect of Republic Act Number 7659, as construed in People versus Simon, to reduce the penalty where the quantity of marijuana involved is less than 250 grams, in which case the penalty is prision correccional. The usual remedy for invoking that retroactive effect is a petition for habeas corpus, but the Court may liberally treat a motion for reconsideration and modification of sentence as substantial compliance with the rules on habeas corpus. Where the convict has served more than the imposable penalty, release must follow.
Disposition
The Court granted the motion and ordered the Director of the Bureau of Corrections to release George Agustin y Pocno from confinement unless he is being detained for some other lawful cause, with costs de oficio.
Remember This
Remember that a convict may still benefit from a favorable amendment reducing the penalty even after final judgment, and that the Court will liberally treat his motion as a petition for habeas corpus. Examiners use this case to test the retroactive effect of penal laws and the liberal application of the rules on habeas corpus.