🎧 Case Brief Lecture

JOSE A. ABAYA, ANICETO O. CADA, JR., PRESIDIO M. CARINO, AIDA D. FULGENCIO, ERNESTO G. GARCIA, BONIFACIO S. MOLINA, REMIGIO P. PUGAT AND DOMINGO C. TOBIAS, PETITIONERS, VS. CIVI…

G.R. No. 98027. October 07, 1994 October 7, 1994

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Abaya versus Civil Service Commission

The Case

This is a petition for certiorari brought by eight employees of the Department of Agriculture in Pangasinan who were dislodged from the Personnel Placement List during the reorganization of the Department under Executive Order No. 116, issued in January 1987. They ask the Supreme Court to set aside the resolutions of the Reorganization Appeals Board and the Civil Service Commission that excluded them from the list and removed them from their positions as Municipal Agricultural Officers. The case matters because it shows how the Court treats a challenge to a reorganization when earlier decisions have already condemned that same reorganization, and how it separates a petitioner who attacks the whole reorganization from one who attacks only his own dropping from the placement list.

Procedural History

The Reorganization Appeals Board, in its Resolution No. 17 dated 7 November 1988, modified the ranking in the Personnel Placement List, excluding Abaya, Cada and Fulgencio and ousting them as Municipal Agricultural Officers. The aggrieved parties sought re-evaluation, and in Resolution No. 17-A dated 26 March 1990 the Board affirmed the earlier exclusions and further disqualified Cariño, Garcia, Pugat, Tobias and Molina for failing to land in the first forty-eight places. The petitioners appealed to the Civil Service Commission, which dismissed the appeal for lack of merit on 28 September 1990 and denied reconsideration on 8 February 1991. The petitioners then came to the Supreme Court on certiorari. Several incumbent Municipal Agricultural Officers whose rankings were upheld moved to intervene, initially to seek dismissal of the case and to cite the petitioners for contempt on the ground of forum shopping.

Facts

The petitioners were employees of the Department of Agriculture in Pangasinan when President Corazon Aquino issued Executive Order No. 116 reorganizing the Department. Abaya, Cada, Cariño and Garcia were Municipal Agriculture and Food Officers, while Fulgencio, Molina, Pugat and Tobias held lower positions. In the reorganization the position of Municipal Agriculture and Food Officer was abolished and replaced with Municipal Agricultural Officer, and former holders did not automatically become Municipal Agricultural Officers. Under Memorandum Circular No. 7, only those who took the evaluation examination and qualified to the Personnel Placement List were considered. On 5 March 1988 the petitioners took the examination, qualified, and were appointed Municipal Agricultural Officers effective upon assumption of duty but not earlier than 1 July 1988.

Aspirants who failed to qualify lodged a protest with the Reorganization Appeals Board, and a second evaluation was conducted on 7 November 1988. The Board then modified the ranking, excluding Abaya, Cada and Fulgencio from the list and ousting them. A later resolution affirmed those exclusions and disqualified the remaining petitioners for failing to land in the first forty-eight places, the number of positions to be filled.

Meanwhile, the Court had already struck down this same reorganization in the consolidated Bustamante and Dominguez cases, and again in Pari-an versus Civil Service Commission and Sison versus Civil Service Commission, ordering the reinstatement of former Municipal Agriculture and Food Officers to their renamed positions or their equivalents. In the present case, Cada was reappointed Municipal Agricultural Officer of San Quintin, Pangasinan on 1 April 1993 because of devolution under the Local Government Code. Abaya was never heard from after filing; Fulgencio could not be reached in the United States; Garcia was dropped as petitioner because he already held the position he prayed for; Pugat chose a lower position; and Tobias retired. Only Molina pursued the case to the end.

Issues

  • Whether or not the petitioners are entitled to reinstatement to their former positions or their equivalents under the Pari-an and Sison rulings.
  • Whether or not the Reorganization Appeals Board committed grave abuse of discretion in altering the ranking in the Personnel Placement List and dislodging Molina.
  • Whether or not the Civil Service Commission committed grave abuse of discretion in sustaining the Board despite the failure of the Board and the Undersecretary to file their comment, and in deciding the appeal beyond the statutory period.
  • Whether or not the intervenors may obtain affirmative relief in the case.

Applicable Provisions

Section 2, paragraph 3 of Article Nine of the Constitution provides:

No officer or employee of the civil service shall be removed or suspended except for cause provided by law.

This is the constitutional guarantee the Court invoked when it invalidated the reorganization in the earlier cases, and it anchors the reinstatement of the former Municipal Agriculture and Food Officers.

Executive Order No. 17, which supplies the grounds for separation or termination of personnel, provides:

Existence of a case for summary dismissal pursuant to Section 40 of the Civil Service Law; Existence of a probable cause for violation of the Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act as determined by the Ministry Head concerned; Gross incompetence or inefficiency in the discharge of functions; Misuse of public office for partisan political purposes; Any other analogous ground showing that the incumbent is unfit to remain in the service or his separation or replacement is in the interest of the service.

The Court held that the reorganization failed to comply with these guidelines, which is why the removals were set aside.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the case is on all fours with Pari-an and Sison, and that the petitioners should be returned to positions equivalent to what they held before the reorganization. Former Municipal Agriculture and Food Officers Abaya, Cada, Cariño and Garcia should be appointed Municipal Agricultural Officers, while the rest should revert to their prior positions or their equivalents. But only Molina could be deemed to have pursued his case to the end and thus entitled to a decision on the merits. The petition became moot as to Cada because his reappointment, though by a different appointing authority due to devolution, amounted to a reconsideration of the objection to his appointment.

On the second issue, the Court held that Molina failed to show bad faith on the part of the Board. The substantial advance in the ranking of protestants who were disqualified in the initial evaluation does not by itself constitute bad faith, since the re-ranking came as a result of the late submission of authenticated documents by some aspirants. Notwithstanding the similarity of the criteria and the composition of the reviewing board, it is not improbable for the Board to alter its findings. On the issues raised by Molina independently of Pari-an and Sison, the petition must fail.

On the third issue, the Court held that the failure of the Board and the Undersecretary to file their comment, or the fact that the Commission rendered its decision beyond the statutory period, does not result in a reversal. Although delay is not countenanced, it cannot be a valid basis for granting the petition.

On the fourth issue, the Court held that the intervenors, having moved solely to seek dismissal of the case and to cite the petitioners for contempt, cannot claim any affirmative relief.

Doctrine

A reorganization that does not comply with the guidelines in Executive Order No. 17, with the constitutional guarantee that no civil service officer or employee shall be removed or suspended except for cause provided by law, and with the applicable statute, is invalid, and the employees removed under it must be reinstated to their former positions or their equivalents under the new staffing pattern. A petitioner who does not challenge the whole reorganization but only the orders dislodging him from the Personnel Placement List must show bad faith or grave abuse of discretion on the part of the Reorganization Appeals Board; the mere fact that the ranking of other aspirants rose after a re-evaluation, where late submission of authenticated documents explains it, does not establish bad faith. Procedural lapses of the administrative agencies, such as failure to file a comment or delay in deciding an appeal, do not by themselves warrant reversal. Intervenors who seek only the dismissal of the case and contempt cannot obtain affirmative relief.

Disposition

The petition was dismissed and the motion to intervene was denied.

Remember This

The single line worth memorizing is that a reorganization which disregards the grounds for separation in Executive Order No. 17 and the constitutional security of tenure is invalid, and the affected employees must be restored to their former positions or their equivalents. Examiners use this case to test the distinction between a petitioner who attacks the entire reorganization and one who attacks only his exclusion from the placement list, and to test whether procedural delay by an administrative agency is a ground for certiorari.