🎧 Case Brief Lecture

CALIFORNIA MANUFACTURING CORPORATION, PETITIONER, VS. THE HONORABLE UNDERSECRETARY OF LABOR BIENVENIDO E. LAGUESMA ABD FEDERATION OF FREE WORKERS (FFW), CALIFORNIA MFG. CORP. SU…

G.R. No. 97020. June 08, 1992 June 8, 1992

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

California Manufacturing Corporation versus Undersecretary of Labor Laguesma

The Case

This is a petition for review on certiorari brought by California Manufacturing Corporation against the Honorable Undersecretary of Labor Bienvenido Laguesma and the Federation of Free Workers, California Manufacturing Corporation Supervisors Union Chapter. The company asks the Supreme Court to annul and set aside the resolution of the Department of Labor and Employment which denied its appeal and affirmed the order of the Med-Arbiter directing a certification election among its supervisory employees. The case matters because it settles who may ask for a certification election in an unorganized bargaining unit, whether the employer has any standing to oppose it, and whether the twenty-five percent subscription requirement still applies.

Procedural History

The Federation of Free Workers, California Manufacturing Corporation Supervisors Union Chapter filed a petition for certification election among the supervisors of California Manufacturing Corporation. The Med-Arbiter issued an order directing that a certification election be conducted among the supervisory employees within twenty days from receipt, with the usual pre-election conference, and using the payroll of the company three months prior to the filing of the petition as the basis for the list of eligible voters. The choices were the Federation of Free Workers, California Manufacturing Corporation Supervisors Union Chapter, and no union.

California Manufacturing Corporation appealed to the Department of Labor and Employment. The Department affirmed the Med-Arbiter's order in its resolution dated October 16, 1990. The company's motion for reconsideration was denied in an order dated November 17, 1990. The company then filed this petition for review on certiorari with a prayer for preliminary injunction or a temporary restraining order.

Facts

On May 24, 1990, the Federation of Free Workers, California Manufacturing Corporation Supervisors Union Chapter filed a petition for certification election among the supervisors of California Manufacturing Corporation. It alleged that it is a duly registered federation and that its chapter is a duly registered chapter; that the company employs one hundred fifty supervisors; that there is no recognized supervisors union in the company; that the petition is filed in accordance with Article 257 of the Labor Code, as amended by Republic Act Number 6715; and that the petition is supported by a substantial number of signatures of the employees concerned.

In its answer, California Manufacturing Corporation alleged that the petition should be denied because it is not supported by the required twenty-five percent of all its supervisors, and that a big number of the supposed signatories are not actually supervisors, having no subordinates to supervise and lacking the powers and functions that would classify them as supervisors. The union replied that when there is no existing bargaining unit at the time the petition is filed, the twenty-five percent rule on signatories does not apply; that an organized establishment refers to a bargaining unit, not to a company as such; that the company has at least two bargaining units, the supervisory which is unorganized and the rank-and-file which is organized; that the signatories have been performing supervisory functions; that the company is estopped from claiming they are not supervisors since it promoted them; that the supervisors were excluded from the coverage of the collective bargaining agreement of the rank-and-file employees; and that the contested signatories are indeed supervisors as shown in the company's master list of employees and publication.

The Med-Arbiter ordered a certification election among the supervisory employees. The Department of Labor and Employment affirmed, and denied reconsideration. Hence this petition.

Issues

  • Whether or not the term unorganized establishment in Article 257 of the Labor Code refers to a bargaining unit or to a business establishment.
  • Whether or not non-supervisors can participate in a supervisor's certification election.
  • Whether or not the two different and separate plants of the petitioner in Paranaque and Las Pinas can be treated as a single bargaining unit.

Applicable Provisions

Article 257 of the Labor Code, as amended by Republic Act Number 6715, governs the petition for certification election in an unorganized establishment. The Court applies it to hold that the supervisors, constituting a bargaining unit separate and distinct from the rank-and-file, have no certified bargaining agent and may therefore file the petition:

Article 257 of the Labor Code is applicable to unorganized labor organizations and not to establishments where there exists a certified bargaining agent which had previously entered into a collective bargaining agreement with the management.

Article 259, now Article 258, of the Labor Code is the exception to the rule that the employer has no standing to question a certification election. The Court cites it to explain that the employer may file a petition for certification election only when it has been requested to bargain collectively:

The only exception is where the employer has to file the petition for certification election pursuant to Article 259 (now 258) of the Labor Code because it was requested to bargain collectively.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the term unorganized establishment refers to a bargaining unit, not to a business establishment. The Court ruled that Article 257 of the Labor Code applies to unorganized labor organizations and not to establishments where there exists a certified bargaining agent which had previously entered into a collective bargaining agreement with management. The establishment concerned must have no certified bargaining agent. Here, the supervisors of California Manufacturing Corporation constitute a bargaining unit separate and distinct from that of the rank-and-file, and they have no such agent. They therefore correctly filed a petition for certification election through the union, which is indubitably a legitimate labor organization.

The company's insistence on the twenty-five percent subscription requirement is clearly immaterial. That requirement was expressly deleted by Section 24 of Republic Act Number 6715 and is presently prescribed only in organized establishments, that is, those with existing bargaining agents. Compliance need not even be established with absolute certainty. The Court quoted its own consistent ruling:

Even conceding that the statutory requirement of 30% (now 25%) of the labor force asking for a certification election had not been strictly complied with, the Director (now the Med-Arbiter) is still empowered to order that it be held precisely for the purpose of ascertaining which of the contending labor organizations shall be the exclusive collective bargaining agent.

The requirement is relevant only when it becomes mandatory to conduct a certification election. In all other instances, the discretion ought ordinarily to be exercised in favor of a petition for certification.

On the second issue, the Court held that the employer has no standing to question a certification election. Such is the sole concern of the workers. The only exception is where the employer has to file the petition for certification election pursuant to Article 259, now Article 258, of the Labor Code because it was requested to bargain collectively. Thereafter, the role of the employer in the certification process ceases; the employer becomes merely a by-stander. The Court quoted its pronouncement on management interference:

On matters that should be the exclusive concern of labor, the choice of a collective bargaining representative, the employer is definitely an intruder. His participation, to say the least, deserves no encouragement. This Court should be the last agency to lend support to such an attempt at interference with purely internal affair of labor.

On the third issue, the Court denied the petition, treating the supervisors as a bargaining unit separate and distinct from the rank-and-file, and rejecting the company's objections to the conduct of the certification election.

Doctrine

Article 257 of the Labor Code applies to unorganized labor organizations and not to establishments where there exists a certified bargaining agent which had previously entered into a collective bargaining agreement with management. The term unorganized establishment refers to a bargaining unit, not to a business establishment, so a bargaining unit with no certified bargaining agent may petition for a certification election even if another bargaining unit in the same company is organized.

The twenty-five percent subscription requirement was deleted by Section 24 of Republic Act Number 6715 and is prescribed only in organized establishments, that is, those with existing bargaining agents. Compliance need not be established with absolute certainty, and the discretion to order a certification election ought ordinarily to be exercised in favor of the petition.

The employer has no standing to question a certification election, which is the sole concern of the workers. The only exception is where the employer files the petition pursuant to Article 259, now Article 258, of the Labor Code because it was requested to bargain collectively; thereafter the employer is merely a by-stander.

Disposition

The petition was dismissed for utter lack of merit, and the resolution and order of the Department of Labor and Employment directing the certification election among the supervisory employees were sustained.

Remember This

Memorize this line: the term unorganized establishment refers to a bargaining unit, not to a business establishment, and the employer is a mere by-stander in a certification election. Examiners use this case to test the twenty-five percent subscription requirement, which now applies only in organized establishments, and the employer's lack of standing to oppose a certification election.