THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE VS. TEODORO REYES, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
United States versus Reyes
The Case
This is a criminal prosecution brought by the United States against Teodoro Reyes for the killing of a man who was surprised cutting bamboo on land the defendant claimed as his own. The trial court convicted the defendant, and he appealed to the Supreme Court. The case matters because it is an early, clean illustration of self-defense under the old Penal Code: the Court acquits not because the killing did not happen, but because the only real question was whose account of the encounter deserved credence, and the defendant's account, corroborated by distant eyewitnesses, established a legitimate defense. It is a lesson in how the burden of proof and the quality of the evidence shape an acquittal even where the fact of the wounding is undisputed.
Procedural History
The defendant was tried in the court below, which found him guilty and rendered judgment against him. He appealed that judgment to the Supreme Court. On appeal, the Court did not need to resolve every evidentiary objection; it held that even if the deceased's dying declaration were properly admitted, the defendant must still be acquitted. The Supreme Court reversed the judgment of conviction and entered a judgment of acquittal.
Facts
The deceased was surprised by the defendant cutting bamboo on what the defendant claimed was his land. An altercation ensued, and the deceased received a wound that caused his death. The prosecution's only evidence of what happened was a declaration made by the deceased during the preliminary investigation a few hours before his death, together with some statements the deceased made to his brother.
The deceased's declaration was vague and general. In substance, it said that the defendant found the deceased cutting bamboo, took him to task using insulting language, that the deceased replied, and that the defendant then attacked him and stabbed him in the stomach with a clasp penknife. The statements to the brother differed somewhat: they said the deceased asked pardon and offered to pay for the bamboo if the defendant would not give it to him, but the defendant made no reply and at once attacked him.
The defendant testified in his own behalf and gave a full and circumstantial account. He said he found the deceased cutting bamboo on his land and asked why he was cutting such young cane. The deceased replied in effect that it was none of his business because the land was not his. The defendant, who was teniente of the barrio, then threatened to arrest the deceased, whereupon the deceased approached and aimed a blow at him with a bolo, which he avoided by letting himself fall from his horse. He retreated while the deceased pursued and struck at him with the bolo. At last he opened his knife and put himself in an attitude of defense. The deceased did not desist, so he grappled with him, wrested the bolo away, and in the course of the combat thinks he must have wounded the deceased with the knife. Two persons who witnessed the encounter from a field some four hundred yards away corroborated him to a certain extent: they saw a man fall from his horse and another man pursue him and finally grapple with him, though they were not near enough to distinguish who the men were.
Issues
- Whether or not the trial court erred in admitting the declaration of the deceased made during the preliminary investigation a few hours before his death.
- Whether or not, on the evidence, the defendant's account of the encounter is more worthy of credence than the declaration and statements of the deceased.
- Whether or not the defendant acted in the legitimate exercise of his right to defend himself, thereby relieving him of criminal responsibility.
Applicable Provisions
Number 4 of article 8 of the Penal Code, as invoked by the Court, provides:
The following are exempt from criminal liability: ... 4. He who acts in defense of his person or rights, provided that there is rational necessity for the means employed.
This is the provision under which the Court relieves the defendant of responsibility, once it accepts that he was repelling an unprovoked and wrongful attack.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court found it unnecessary to decide whether the trial court erred in admitting the deceased's declaration, because even if that evidence were properly in the case, the defendant must be acquitted. The declaration was, in the Court's words, "in such vague and general terms as to detract greatly from its value as evidence."
On the second issue, the Court weighed the conflicting accounts. The defendant's testimony appeared "in effect, and especially as thus corroborated, more worthy of credence than the declaration and statements made by the deceased." The Court added that "in such a conflict of evidence we should not be justified in rejecting it as untrue." The corroboration by the two witnesses who saw a man fall from his horse and another pursue and grapple with him, though they could not identify the men, tipped the balance.
On the third issue, accepting the defendant's statement as true, the Court held it clear that he was acting in the legitimate exercise of his right to defend himself by repelling the unprovoked and wrongful attack upon him, and was therefore relieved from responsibility under Number 4 of article 8 of the Penal Code.
Doctrine
Self-defense under Number 4 of article 8 of the Penal Code exempts from criminal liability one who acts in defense of his person or rights, provided there is rational necessity for the means employed. Where the prosecution's evidence of the aggression consists only of a vague and general declaration of the deceased, and the defendant gives a full, circumstantial, and corroborated account of an unprovoked attack that he repelled, the Court will not reject the defense as untrue. The rule a candidate should retain is that the quality and corroboration of the evidence determine whose version prevails, and once the defendant's version is accepted, the exemption under Number 4 of article 8 applies and acquittal follows.
Disposition
The Supreme Court reversed the judgment of the court below and acquitted the defendant, with costs of both instances de oficio.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing is that a defendant who repels an unprovoked and wrongful attack acts in the legitimate exercise of self-defense and is relieved from responsibility under Number 4 of article 8 of the Penal Code. Examiners use this case to test how a court weighs a vague dying declaration against a corroborated claim of self-defense, and to remind students that the exemption turns on rational necessity for the means employed.