FRANCISCO M. GO-QUICO, PLAINTIFF AND APPELLEE, VS. THE MUNICIPAL BOARD OF THE CITY OF MANILA AND THE HEIRS OF BALBINO VENTURA HOCORMA, DEFENDANTS AND APPELLANTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Go-Quico versus Municipal Board of the City of Manila
The Case
This is Go-Quico versus the Municipal Board of the City of Manila and the heirs of Hocorma, decided in November 1902. Francisco Go-Quico, a tenant in possession of land, sued the City of Manila and his landlord's heirs to stop the demolition of the houses on the property and to restrain the heirs from disturbing his enjoyment of the lot. The City appealed from orders granting and maintaining a preliminary injunction. The Supreme Court never reached the merits; it asked instead whether those orders could be appealed at all. The case matters because it fixes the rule, still vital today, that an interlocutory order does not become final merely because it gives a party all the relief he prayed for.
Procedural History
Go-Quico filed his complaint in the Court of First Instance of Manila in March 1902. On the very day of filing, without notice to the defendants, the trial judge issued a preliminary injunction upon a bond of 500 Mexican pesos. The City appeared specially and moved to dissolve it; the court granted the motion. Go-Quico then filed a second petition for a new preliminary injunction. Over the City's objection that no summons or copy of the complaint had ever been served on it, the court held it had power to issue the injunction without notice, and a temporary injunction issued in April. The City moved again to dissolve, and in May the court denied the motion, leaving the injunction in force, without prejudice to the City moving for dissolution upon filing an approved bond of 2,000 pesos, Mexican currency. The City appealed from both orders. A bill of exceptions was allowed and certified to the Supreme Court. When Go-Quico moved to amend the bill of exceptions, the Court itself suggested that the orders in question were not appealable. That question was argued and became the sole matter for decision.
Facts
Go-Quico was the tenant in possession of a parcel of land. His landlord, so he alleged, fraudulently leased the same property to others. Meanwhile the City of Manila ordered the houses on the land destroyed. Go-Quico had already begun an action against his landlord for fulfillment of their contract.
To protect his possession in the meantime, he brought this separate action and prayed that a preliminary injunction issue against the Municipal Board, restraining it from executing the demolition order until further orders, and that the heirs of Balbino Ventura Hocorma be restrained from disturbing his enjoyment of the lot.
The trial court granted the relief he asked, twice over, and refused to dissolve it. The City appealed, insisting that because the complaint prayed only for a preliminary injunction, the order granting it was in effect the final judgment in the case.
Issues
- Whether or not the orders granting and maintaining a preliminary injunction are final judgments from which an appeal lies to the Supreme Court.
- Whether or not an order is appealable merely because it grants the plaintiff all the relief prayed for in his complaint.
Applicable Provisions
Section 123 of the Code of Civil Procedure provides:
No interlocutory or incidental ruling, order, or judgment of the Court of First Instance shall stay the progress of an action or proceeding therein pending, but only such ruling, order, or judgment as finally determines the action or proceeding; nor shall any ruling, order, or judgment be the subject of appeal to the Supreme Court until final judgment is rendered for one party or the other.
This is the provision that bars the appeal, because the orders complained of are interlocutory and do not finally determine the action.
Article 143 of the same Code provides:
Upon the rendition of final judgment disposing of the action either party shall have the right to perfect a bill of exceptions.
This reiterates the prohibition, confining the right to perfect a bill of exceptions to the rendition of a final judgment.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the orders were not appealable and dismissed the appeal. The City argued that the only relief prayed for was a preliminary injunction, that the court had granted all it could grant, and that nothing further remained to adjudicate. The Court answered that there can, in the nature of things, be no such action as one for a temporary injunction and for nothing else. A temporary injunction lasts only during the pendency of the action; when the action terminates, the injunction falls. If the order granting it were a final judgment, that very act would dissolve the injunction, and the defendant would not need to appeal at all.
On the second issue, the Court refused to treat the prayer as the measure of finality. The plaintiff had used the word preliminary in his prayer, but that prayer could be amended if the defendant answered. No answer had ever been made and no issues joined, so there had been no trial of any issue of fact or law. After each order, the defendant retained the right to answer, to present additional evidence at trial, and to reargue the questions of law. The decision on a preliminary motion was not an adjudication of the questions passed upon, either on the facts or on the law. The trial court still had jurisdiction and the power to enter a final judgment for the defendant after a trial on the issues raised by an answer. As the Court put it, if it were otherwise, every preliminary injunction would be a final one in the trial court.
The Court noted that the prohibition is stronger than its American counterparts, because the evils of appeals from interlocutory resolutions under the Ley de Enjuiciamiento Civil were well known, and the article was adopted to cure them. It expressly prohibits appeals not only from interlocutory orders but also from interlocutory judgments.
Doctrine
An order granting or refusing a preliminary injunction is interlocutory and is not appealable until final judgment is rendered for one party or the other. The test of finality is not whether the order grants all the relief prayed for, but whether it finally determines or terminates the action. A preliminary injunction by its nature lasts only during the pendency of the action and cannot be the whole of it. The prohibition in Section 123 extends to interlocutory judgments as well as interlocutory orders, and Article 143 confines the bill of exceptions to the final judgment.
Disposition
The appeal was dismissed, because the orders appealed from were interlocutory and prohibited from being the subject of appeal by the applicable articles of the Code of Civil Procedure.
Remember This
Memorize this line: an order is not final merely because it gives the plaintiff everything he asked for; finality turns on whether the action itself is terminated. Examiners use this case to test the definition of a final judgment and the appealability of interlocutory orders, especially injunctions.