🎧 Case Brief Lecture

THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS CATALINO ORTIZ ET AL., DEFENDANTS AND APPELLANTS.

G.R. No. 964. November 04, 1902 November 4, 1902

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

United States versus Ortiz

The Case

This is a criminal case for murder, tried in the Court of First Instance of Mauban, Tayabas, against Catalino Ortiz, Miguel Arevalo, and Germiniano Almagro. The victim, Mariano de Mesa, was killed one night in July 1901 by a party of revolutionists who believed he was a spy of the American Army. The case matters because it is the Supreme Court's early statement on the reach of the amnesty proclamation of July 4, 1902, and on the difference between an accused whose conviction has become final and one whose appeal is still pending when amnesty is invoked.

Procedural History

The case was tried in the Court of First Instance of Mauban, Tayabas, for the crime of murder. By judgment dated May 12, 1902, the trial court condemned Catalino Ortiz, Miguel Arevalo, and Germiniano Almagro to the penalty of life imprisonment, with the accessories, and to the payment of civil damages. Arevalo and Almagro appealed to the Supreme Court. Ortiz did not appeal. While the case was pending on appeal, Mr. Lionel D. Hargis and the Solicitor-General filed a joint motion asking the Court to declare that the defendants are entitled to the benefits of the amnesty proclamation of July 4, 1902, and that they be acquitted and restored to liberty after taking the required oath.

Facts

One night in July 1901, Mariano de Mesa was held as a prisoner by a party of revolutionists scouring the province under the command of Major Ruperto Reus. It was supposed that Mesa was a spy of the American Army, and he was put to death.

Catalino Ortiz and Miguel Arevalo actually committed the crime by order of Germiniano Almagro, who was the captain of the party and who in turn acted upon orders received from Major Reus. The aggressors tied the victim to a telegraph pole so that he could not defend himself, and while he was in this defenseless condition they inflicted upon him with a cutting weapon three wounds, in the head, on the chin, and in his right side, which wounds resulted in his death. His body was found the following day by the police of the town of Atimonan, and attached to it was a paper stating that he had been killed as a spy.

The Court found that the murder was of a political character, the result of political hatred or political dissensions between Filipinos, as both the deceased and the defendants were natives of the Islands. The defendants were revolutionists and members of the revolutionary faction. They killed the supposed spy by order of Major Reus, transmitted through Almagro. It did not appear that the crime was due to any personal resentment, but simply to the belief that Mesa was in fact a spy and an enemy to the revolution.

Issues

  • Whether or not the murder of Mariano de Mesa is a political crime that entitles the defendants to the benefits of the amnesty proclamation of July 4, 1902.
  • Whether or not the defendants who appealed from the judgment of conviction may be granted the benefits of the amnesty while their appeal is pending.
  • Whether or not the Court may apply the amnesty to Catalino Ortiz, who did not appeal and whose conviction had become final.

Applicable Provisions

The amnesty proclamation of July 4, 1902, as invoked by the joint motion of Mr. Hargis and the Solicitor-General, is the executive act the Court construes. The decision does not set out its text verbatim; it refers to the oath prescribed in the proclamation and to the excepted cases foreseen in the amnesty decree. The proclamation bears on the case because it grants amnesty to persons charged with political offenses, subject to taking the prescribed oath, and because it excepts certain cases, including those already finally decided.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the murder is of a political character. The defendants were revolutionists, the deceased was supposed to be a spy of the American Army, and the killing was carried out by order of Major Reus, without any showing of personal resentment. Being a political crime, it falls within the amnesty.

On the second issue, the Court held that because Almagro and Arevalo appealed from the judgment rendered against them in the court below, and the appeal is now pending before the Court, it is evident that they have not been convicted by final judgment, and therefore they are entitled to the benefits of the amnesty proclamation.

On the third issue, the Court held that Catalino Ortiz did not appeal, and therefore with respect to him the judgment below became a finality. He therefore falls within one of the excepted cases foreseen in the amnesty decree, and consequently the Court is without jurisdiction to apply the amnesty to him. The Court added that he may present a special petition to that end to the proper executive authorities.

Doctrine

A crime is political, for purposes of amnesty, when it results from political hatred or political dissensions and is committed in furtherance of a revolutionary cause by order of its commanders, and not from personal resentment. An accused whose conviction is not yet final because his appeal is pending may be granted the benefits of the amnesty proclamation upon taking the prescribed oath. An accused who did not appeal and whose conviction has become final falls within the excepted cases of the amnesty decree, and the courts have no jurisdiction to apply the amnesty to him; his remedy is a special petition to the proper executive authorities.

Disposition

The Court held that Germiniano Almagro and Miguel Arevalo are entitled to the benefits of the amnesty of July 4, 1902, and, upon taking before a competent officer the oath prescribed in the proclamation, they will be set at liberty, with the judge directed to forward proof of compliance and the original oaths to the Court.

Remember This

The single line worth memorizing is that amnesty reaches an accused whose conviction is not yet final, but not one who failed to appeal and whose judgment has become a finality. Examiners use this case to test the political-crime concept and the finality-of-judgment bar to amnesty.