FRANCISCO IRURETA GOYENA, PLAINTIFF AND APPELLEE, VS. ILDEFONSO TAMBUNTING, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Irureta Goyena versus Tambunting
The Case
This is an action for the enforcement of a contract of purchase and sale of a parcel of land in Manila, brought by Francisco Irureta Goyena against Ildefonso Tambunting. The plaintiff owned the land and the building on it, known as Number 20 Calle San Jose in Ermita, and the defendant agreed in writing to buy it for 3,200 pesos. When the formal deed was to be signed, the defendant refused, claiming the lot was smaller than the broker had represented and that he had bought at so much per meter. The case matters because it fixes the rule on the sale of real property for a lump sum, as against a sale at a rate per unit of measure, and it teaches that a perfected contract binds the parties to what its words say, not to what one party privately intended.
Procedural History
The plaintiff commenced the action in the Court of First Instance of Manila under article 1451 of the Civil Code, seeking to compel the defendant to carry out the contract. The trial court rendered judgment in favor of the plaintiff, and the defendant appealed. The case reached the Supreme Court on appeal from that judgment, and the Supreme Court affirmed the decision of the lower court.
Facts
The plaintiff's principal owned a tract of land, containing 152.46 square meters, together with the building on it at Number 20 Calle San Jose, Ermita, Manila. A broker representing the plaintiff told the defendant that the lot was for sale and, on information received from the plaintiff, that it measured 23 meters in front and 8 meters in depth. After that, the broker had nothing more to do with the matter, and the plaintiff and the defendant negotiated between themselves.
On March 12, 1901, the defendant signed a document stating that on that date he had bought from the plaintiff a lot at Number 20 Calle San Jose, Ermita, for the sum of 3,200 pesos, to be paid as soon as the bill of sale was signed. The plaintiff signed a similar document. There was no evidence that the parties came to any agreement on the sale other than what appeared in those papers of March 12.
The defendant took the title papers from the notary's office, which showed the area to be 152.46 square meters, kept them for several days, and returned them. On the day set for the execution of the instrument, all the parties being in the notary's office, the defendant told the notary to insert the price of 3,200 pesos and then refused to sign, because the lot did not contain the area the plaintiff, through the broker, had represented. He offered to sign if a proportional reduction were made in the price. The plaintiff refused, and this action followed.
Issues
- Whether or not the private document of March 12, 1901, was a perfected and binding contract of purchase and sale, notwithstanding that a public instrument was still to be executed.
- Whether or not the sale was made at the rate of a certain price for a unit of measure, so as to entitle the defendant to a proportional reduction in the price under article 1469.
- Whether or not the plaintiff's offer, made after the defendant objected, to grant a proportional reduction proved that the contract was one by measure.
Applicable Provisions
Article 1445 of the Civil Code defines the contract of purchase and sale:
By the contract of purchase and sale one of the contracting parties undertakes to deliver a specific thing, and the other to pay therefore a price certain, in money or in some thing representing it.
This supplies the elements the Court checks the private document against.
Article 1450 of the Civil Code fixes when the sale is perfected:
The sale shall he perfected between vendor and vendee and shall be binding on both of them, if they have agreed upon the thing which is the object of the contract and upon the price, even when neither has been delivered.
This is the basis for holding that the agreement of March 12 was already a perfect contract.
Article 1278 of the Civil Code makes contracts obligatory in whatever form, provided the essential elements are present:
Contracts shall be obligatory whatever may he the form in which they have been entered into, provided that the essential elements for their validity are present.
This answers the objection that the private document was not yet enforceable because a public instrument was contemplated.
Article 1469, paragraph 2, of the Civil Code is the provision the defendant invoked for a reduction of price:
If the sale of real property should be made with a statement of its area, at the rate of a certain price for a unit of measure or number, the vendor shall be obliged to deliver to the vendee, if the latter should require it, all that may have been mentioned in the contract; but should this not be possible, the vendee may choose between a proportional reduction in the price or the rescission of the contract: Provided, That in the latter case the decrease in the real estate is not less than one-tenth of the area given it.
This applies only where the sale states an area and a rate per unit, which the Court found was not the case here.
Article 1471 of the Civil Code governs a sale for a fixed price:
In the sale of real estate made for a fixed price and not at the rate of a specified sum for a unit of measure or number, the increase or decrease of the same shall not be considered, even when greater or less area or amount than that stated in the contract may be found.
This is the rule the Court applied to deny the reduction.
Article 1225 of the Civil Code gives a private document the force of a public instrument between the signers:
A private document, legally acknowledged, has the same value as the public instrument between those who have signed the same, and their privies.
This supports holding the defendant to the words of the document he signed.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the private document was a perfect contract of purchase and sale. Nothing was lacking: the specific thing was identified without controversy, and the price of 3,200 pesos was stated plainly and without any condition. The document was not a mere draft or project of sale, and it was not subject to any term making perfection wait upon the public instrument. The Court reasoned that the least that could be said of it was that it contained a promise to buy, and a promise to buy confers on the parties the right to reciprocally demand performance. A thing which has no existence can produce no effect, so if the contract were not perfected no such right would arise. Because it was a private document contemplating a later public instrument, it did not follow that it was unenforceable as it stood.
On the second issue, the Court held that this was a sale for a fixed price, not a sale at a rate per unit of measure, so article 1471 applied and the decrease in area was not to be considered. The defendant bought a specific article and agreed to pay 3,200 pesos for it, and the fact that the article was not as large as he thought did not relieve him of paying that price. The Court said it was just such cases that article 1471 was intended to cover, and that if the defendant intended to buy by the meter he should have so stated in the contract. Not only did the contract not so state, but there was no evidence that the parties ever discussed the price to be paid for each meter.
On the third issue, the Court held that the plaintiff's statement, made after the defendant objected, that he had agreed to a proportional reduction, was not enough to prove a contract by measure against the written document and the absence of other evidence. That statement was made when the plaintiff thought the difference was slight, not more than a meter or two, and that the reduction would not exceed 20 or 30 pesos. The Court construed it as a willingness to abate a trifle to obtain an amicable settlement and avoid litigation.
Doctrine
A contract of purchase and sale is perfected, and binds both parties, once they agree upon the specific thing and a certain price, even if neither has been delivered, and even if the agreement is embodied only in a private document that contemplates a later public instrument. Under article 1278, contracts are obligatory in whatever form, provided the essential elements of a determinate thing, a price certain, and a meeting of the minds are present. Where real property is sold for a fixed price and not at the rate of a specified sum for a unit of measure or number, any increase or decrease in area is not considered, even if the area is greater or less than that stated in the contract. The remedy of proportional reduction or rescission under article 1469 belongs only to a sale made with a statement of area at a rate per unit of measure. A party is bound by the words of the contract he signed, and his unexpressed intention will not prevail over them.
Disposition
The Supreme Court affirmed the judgment of the lower court in favor of the plaintiff, with costs of the appeal against the defendant.
Remember This
The one line to memorize: if the sale of real estate is for a fixed price and not at so much per unit of measure, the increase or decrease in area is not considered, and the buyer pays the price he agreed to. Examiners use this case to test the distinction between a lump-sum sale and a sale by measure, and to test whether a private document awaiting a public instrument is already a perfected, enforceable contract.