ALBAY I ELECTRIC COOPERATIVE, INC. (ALECO I), PETITIONER, VS. RICARDO S. MARTINEZ, SR., ARNOLD B. BONAGUA AND CONRADO S. BUBAN, RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Albay I Electric Cooperative versus Martinez
The Case
This is a special civil action for certiorari brought by the Albay I Electric Cooperative against Ricardo Martinez, Senior, in his capacity as Regional Director of the Department of Labor and Employment for the Bicol region, together with two of its own employees, Arnold Bonagua and Conrado Buban. The cooperative asks the Supreme Court to annul two orders of the Regional Director awarding the two employees salary differentials and thirteenth month pay, on the ground that those orders were issued in excess of jurisdiction. The case matters because it draws the boundary line between the summary adjudicative power of the Regional Director over small money claims and the exclusive original jurisdiction of the Labor Arbiter over claims exceeding five thousand pesos, and it warns against stretching the visitorial power of the Department of Labor into a general power to hear and decide all employee claims.
Procedural History
The two employees filed a complaint with the Office of the Regional Director for the recovery of salary differentials corresponding to their new positions. The cooperative moved to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction, but the Regional Director issued an order requiring the cooperative to pay the two employees their underpaid wages. The cooperative filed a notice of appeal and a memorandum of appeal, but instead of giving the appeal due course, the Med-Arbiter denied it and directed the parties to present evidence. The cooperative then assailed the denial in its position paper and pressed the argument that because the amounts claimed exceeded five thousand pesos, the Regional Director had no jurisdiction. The Regional Director issued a second order, this time awarding salary differentials and thirteenth month pay, and a writ of execution followed. The cooperative came to the Supreme Court by petition for certiorari.
Facts
On the fifteenth of August, 1988, Israel Garcia, the acting general manager of the cooperative, designated Conrado Buban as acting manager of the Commercial Services Department and Arnold Bonagua as supervisor of the Service Center. The difficulty was that Garcia's own appointment had already been recalled by the National Electrification Administration through an office order issued on the tenth of August, 1988, effective immediately. On the twenty-seventh of August, 1988, the Board of Directors of the cooperative considered these appointments, made at midnight so to speak, as null and void. Later, in a memorandum dated the seventh of June, 1989, the chief of the legal service office of the National Electrification Administration considered the appointments defective, there being serious doubts as to their validity.
On the fifteenth of August, 1989, the two employees filed their complaint with the Office of the Regional Director, claiming salary differentials for their new positions. They also argued that since they had held those positions for more than one year, their status should be considered permanent and they should be paid the corresponding salaries. The cooperative moved to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction, but the Regional Director ordered it to pay Bonagua and Buban their underpayment of wages for the new positions.
The cooperative appealed, but the Med-Arbiter denied the appeal and directed the parties to present evidence. On the third of September, 1990, the Regional Director issued another order requiring the cooperative to pay Bonagua and Buban their salary differentials and thirteenth month pay. He held that because the two had been allowed to discharge their functions for more than one year without objection, this amounted to acquiescence and an implied approval of their appointments. A writ of execution was issued on the twenty-sixth of September, 1990. Hence the petition.
Issues
- Whether or not the Regional Director had jurisdiction to hear and decide the employees' claims for salary differentials and thirteenth month pay, each of which exceeded five thousand pesos.
- Whether or not the Regional Director could validly assume jurisdiction over those claims by invoking his visitorial power under Article 128 of the Labor Code.
- Whether or not the orders and the writ of execution issued by the Regional Director are valid, given that he acted without jurisdiction from the very start.
Applicable Provisions
Article 129 of the Labor Code, as amended, provides:
Article 129. Recovery of wages, simple money claims and other benefits. Upon complaint of any interested party, the Regional Director of the Department of Labor and Employment or any of the duly authorized hearing officers of the Department is empowered, through summary proceeding and after due notice, to hear and decide any matter involving the recovery of wages and other monetary claims and benefits, including legal interest, owing to an employee or person employed in domestic or household service or househelper under this Code, arising from employer-employee relations. Provided, That such complaint does not include a claim for reinstatement; Provided, further, That the aggregate money claims of each employee or househelper do not exceed five thousand pesos.
This provision fixes the ceiling of five thousand pesos on the Regional Director's adjudicative power, and each of the claims here exceeded that ceiling.
Article 217 of the Labor Code, as amended, provides in its relevant portion:
Article 217. Jurisdiction of Labor Arbiters and the Commission. Except as otherwise provided under this Code, the Labor Arbiters shall have original and exclusive jurisdiction to hear and decide, within thirty calendar days after the submission of the case by the parties for decision without extension, even in the absence of stenographic notes, the following cases involving workers, whether agricultural or non-agricultural: x x x (6) Except claims for employees compensation, social security, medicare and maternity benefits, all other claims arising from employer-employee relations, including those of persons in domestic or household service, involving an amount exceeding five thousand pesos, whether or not accompanied with a claim for reinstatement.
This provision lodges exclusive original jurisdiction over claims exceeding five thousand pesos in the Labor Arbiter, and it is the provision the Court applies to oust the Regional Director.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court ruled that jurisdiction over the dispute lies exclusively and originally with the Labor Arbiter, the claims being in excess of five thousand pesos each. The Court read Article 129 as conferring adjudicative power on the Regional Director only when three requisites concur, as summarized in the Brokenshire case: the claim is presented by an employee or househelper under the Code; the claimant, no longer being employed, does not seek reinstatement; and the aggregate money claim does not exceed five thousand pesos. In the absence of any of the three requisites, the Labor Arbiters have exclusive original jurisdiction over all claims arising from employer-employee relations, other than the excepted statutory benefits. Since each claim here exceeded the ceiling, the Regional Director acted without jurisdiction.
On the second issue, the Court held that the employees could not invoke the visitorial power under Article 128 either. To construe that power as including the power to hear and decide employee claims exceeding five thousand pesos would emasculate and render meaningless the provisions of Article 217 and Article 129. The Court explained the reason of the law: proceedings before the Secretary of Labor or his agents under the visitorial power are summary in nature, while proceedings before the Labor Arbiter are more formal and in accord with the rules of evidence; a summary procedure may be justified for small claims, but not for a claim that is substantial from the standpoint of both employee and management. The Court added that when the employer contests the findings of the Regional Director, the case must be referred to the Labor Arbiter, because the matter is a question of fact that cannot be dealt with in a summary proceeding.
On the third issue, the Court applied the settled rule that when a tribunal acts in excess or lack of jurisdiction, all decisions, orders and processes emanating from it are null and void. Since the Regional Director already acted beyond the scope of his jurisdiction in taking cognizance of the case at the first instance, all orders and processes subsequently issued by him are without force and effect. The denial of the appeal therefore need not be separately resolved.
Doctrine
First, the Regional Director's power to hear and decide money claims under Article 129 is limited to claims not exceeding five thousand pesos for each employee; where the claim exceeds that amount, jurisdiction is exclusively and originally with the Labor Arbiter under Article 217.
Second, the visitorial power under Article 128 cannot be used to expand that jurisdiction, for to do so would render Article 129 a useless surplusage and would sanction the hearing of all employee claims, regardless of amount, in a summary proceeding not suited to substantial claims.
Third, where the employer contests the findings of the Regional Director and raises issues that cannot be resolved without considering evidentiary matters not verifiable in the normal course of inspection, the case must be referred to the Labor Arbiter.
Fourth, orders and processes issued by a tribunal without or in excess of jurisdiction are null and void.
Disposition
The cooperative won. The Supreme Court set aside and declared null and void the two orders of the Regional Director and the writ of execution, and referred each claim of the private respondents for salary differentials and thirteenth month pay to the proper Labor Arbiter for appropriate determination.
Remember This
Memorize the line: the Regional Director's adjudicative power stops at five thousand pesos per employee, and the visitorial power cannot be stretched to cover what Article 129 excludes. Examiners use this case to test jurisdiction over money claims, the three requisites of Article 129, and the rule that void orders produce no effect.