ISETANN DEPARTMENT STORE, INC., PETITIONER, VS. THE NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION, SECOND DIVISION AND ROSITA BAUTISTA, RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Isetann Department Store versus National Labor Relations Commission
The Case
This is a petition for certiorari brought by Isetann Department Store, Incorporated against the National Labor Relations Commission, Second Division, and its former floor supervisor Rosita Bautista. Isetann asks the Supreme Court to annul the Commission's resolution affirming a labor arbiter's award of reinstatement and backwages to Bautista, whom the company had dismissed for loss of trust and confidence. The case matters because it fixes the standard of proof for a valid dismissal grounded on loss of trust: not proof beyond reasonable doubt, but substantial evidence — some basis, or reasonable grounds to believe — and it shows how a labor tribunal commits grave abuse of discretion when it misapprehends the facts.
Procedural History
Rosita Bautista filed a complaint for illegal dismissal before the National Labor Relations Commission, National Capital Region Arbitration Branch. After hearings on the merits, Labor Arbiter Felipe Pati rendered judgment on July 31, 1989, ordering Isetann to reinstate her to her former position without loss of seniority rights, to pay full backwages and other benefits from the time of her illegal dismissal until actual reinstatement, plus ten percent of the total award as attorney's fees. The arbiter found that no fraud attended the purchase order, only an error admitted by the stock head, and that the company failed to substantiate its charges.
Isetann appealed to the National Labor Relations Commission. On August 29, 1990, the Second Division dismissed the appeal and sustained the arbiter, finding the confessions of the two stock heads incredible because of delay and because of an alleged threat. Isetann then came to the Supreme Court by petition for certiorari, alleging that the Commission's resolution was rendered with grave abuse of discretion.
Facts
Rosita Bautista was Floor Supervisor at the third floor of Isetann's store in Carriedo, Manila. Her sister, Yolanda Chan, was a regular supplier of shoes. On June 2, 1987, Chan delivered 1,379 pairs of Valencia shoes priced at 22 pesos a pair, and 940 pairs of deerskin shoes priced at 25 pesos a pair, for a total of 53,838 pesos. Because the shoes differed in price and material, they had to be sorted. The sorting began on June 13, 1987 under Head of Stock Connie Capua, and was completed under another Head of Stock, Iglesia Mangoba, when Capua went on leave.
Mangoba then prepared a purchase order that erroneously listed 940 pairs of Valencia shoes and 1,379 pairs of deerskin shoes, with a total value of 55,155 pesos. The switch was discovered in July 1987 when the shoes were transferred to the Cubao branch. The purchase order was cancelled, a new check for the correct amount of 53,838 pesos was prepared and paid to Chan, and Chan continued to supply shoes until September 1987. Confronted by the buyer and the merchandiser, Mangoba admitted her mistake.
On November 28, 1987, however, Mangoba executed a written statement saying that Capua had instructed her to mix Valencia shoes with the deerskin shoes so that Chan would not lose, and that Bautista had told her to interchange the numbers in the purchase order. Capua followed on December 2, 1987 with a statement that Bautista had instructed her to do the mixing, and that she had received 400 pesos and a pair of shoes for her cooperation. Hearings were held on December 11, 14 and 16, 1987. On December 24, 1987, Isetann terminated Bautista effective December 28, 1987, for willful breach of trust, citing company rules on bribery, anomalous transactions, unauthorized work for personal gain, and causing loss to the company through negligence.
Issues
- Whether or not the National Labor Relations Commission committed grave abuse of discretion in affirming the labor arbiter's finding that Bautista was illegally dismissed.
- Whether or not the employer had a valid cause to dismiss Bautista on the ground of loss of trust and confidence.
Applicable Provisions
The decision does not quote a statute; it states the governing rule on loss of trust and confidence, which the Court applies as the standard for a valid dismissal:
The recognized rule is that the employer has a distinct prerogative to dismiss an employee if the former has ample reason to distrust the latter or if there is sufficient evidence to show that the employee has been guilty of breach of trust. The law does not require proof beyond reasonable doubt of the employee's misconduct before the employer can invoke such authority. It is sufficient that there is some basis for the loss of trust or that the employer has reasonable grounds to believe that the employee is guilty of misconduct and that the nature of the employee's action renders him or her unworthy of the trust and confidence demanded by the position.
This rule bears on the case because it lowers the employer's burden: Isetann need only show some basis for its loss of trust, not guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the Commission and the labor arbiter gravely abused their discretion in rejecting the corroborating testimonies of Capua and Mangoba, acting under a gross misapprehension of facts. There was no contradiction between payment on June 29, 1987 and the claim that the anomaly was discovered in July or November. What was discovered in July was only the switch of figures, then ascribed to carelessness; only in November, when Mangoba executed her statement, was Bautista's hand in the interchange revealed as an aborted fraudulent scheme. It was thus not illogical that Chan continued to supply shoes until September.
The arbiter's reason that nobody would enter into a losing business was immaterial: what mattered was not whether Chan truly stood to lose, but that this was the reason Bautista gave in urging Capua to mix the shoes. As to Mangoba's statement on cross-examination that "they are threatening me," the Court held this strengthened rather than diminished her credibility, explaining the delay in disclosing Bautista's involvement. "They" referred not to management but to Bautista and her husband, reputedly a policeman. It would be absurd to suppose that Isetann threatened its own witness to suppress information that would benefit the company.
On the second issue, the Court ruled that Isetann had shown by sufficient evidence Bautista's involvement in the fraudulent transaction, and that there was valid cause for losing the trust and confidence reposed in her as a supervisorial employee.
Doctrine
An employer may dismiss an employee for loss of trust and confidence where there is ample reason to distrust the employee or sufficient evidence of breach of trust. The law does not require proof beyond reasonable doubt; it is enough that there is some basis for the loss of trust, or that the employer has reasonable grounds to believe the employee is guilty of misconduct, and that the act renders the employee unworthy of the trust demanded by the position. A labor tribunal commits grave abuse of discretion when it affirms findings grounded on a gross misapprehension of facts, and the Supreme Court will annul such a resolution.
Disposition
The petition was granted; the Commission's resolution and the labor arbiter's decision were annulled and set aside, and Bautista's complaint for illegal termination was dismissed.
Remember This
Loss of trust needs only some basis or reasonable grounds — never proof beyond reasonable doubt. Examiners use this case to test the quantum of evidence in dismissal for loss of trust and confidence, and to show when a labor tribunal's factual findings may be overturned for grave abuse of discretion.