🎧 Case Brief Lecture

THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. EMIGDIO MENDIGOREN, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.

G.R. No. 950. January 23, 1903 January 23, 1903

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

United States versus Mendigoren

The Case

This is a criminal case from the early years of the American regime in the Philippines. The United States, as complainant and appellee, prosecuted Emigdio Mendigoren, the defendant and appellant, for robbery committed by a band that entered a house in Bataan in September 1901 and carried away clothing and money. The case matters to a reviewee because it draws the line between two distinct ways of committing robbery under the old Penal Code: robbery by a band, which the Code calls a cuadrilla, and ordinary robbery with the aggravating circumstances of time and place. The Court's short decision turns on a single evidentiary fact, namely whether every member of the party was armed, and it shows how a conviction under the wrong article must be corrected on appeal even as the judgment is otherwise affirmed.

Procedural History

The defendant was tried and convicted in the court below, which based its conviction on the article of the Penal Code punishing robbery committed by a band, that is, a cuadrilla. The defendant appealed to the Supreme Court of the Philippine Islands. The Supreme Court, speaking through Justice Ladd, found that the conviction had been placed on the wrong article, modified the judgment accordingly, and affirmed it in all other respects, with costs, remanding the cause to the court below for execution of the judgment.

Facts

On an evening in the month of September 1901, at the pueblo of Binalupijan in the Province of Bataan, four men went to the house of Severino del Castillo. The witnesses could not fix the exact day. The men terrorized the dwellers in the house and took and carried away a suit of clothes and 10 pesos in money.

The defendant, Emigdio Mendigoren, was one of the four. The defense he set up, which the Court noted is a frequent one in this class of cases, was that he was not a voluntary member of the party but had been captured by the others and forced to accompany them. The Court examined the record and found nothing in it which could fairly be said to have even a remote tendency to establish that defense.

On the evidence, two and perhaps three of the robbers carried arms. As to the fourth, the defendant, the evidence seemed to indicate that he was not armed. That single fact about the composition of the party controlled the choice of the applicable article of the Penal Code.

Issues

  • Whether or not the defendant was a voluntary member of the party that robbed the house of Severino del Castillo, rather than a person captured and forced to accompany the robbers.
  • Whether or not the party constituted a cuadrilla, that is, a band of robbers, in the sense of the law, such that the conviction should rest on the article punishing robbery by a band.
  • Whether or not the defendant is guilty of robbery under the article punishing robbery with the aggravating circumstances of time and place, and if so, what penalty should be imposed.

Applicable Provisions

Article 505 of the Penal Code, which defines the band of robbers called a cuadrilla, is the provision the trial court applied and the Court declined to apply:

Article 505. The following are guilty of brigandage: 1. Those who form a band or cuadrilla composed of more than three malefactors, armed, for the purpose of committing robbery in the country or on the highways. 2. Those who, being members of such a band or cuadrilla, take part in the commission of any of the crimes mentioned in the preceding article.

The Court held that because the defendant was unarmed, the party did not constitute a cuadrilla in the sense of this article, so the conviction based on it was erroneous.

Article 503, Number 5, of the Penal Code, which defines and punishes robbery, is the provision the Court applied instead:

Article 503. The penalty of presidio mayor shall be imposed upon any person who, with intent to gain, shall take any personal property belonging to another, by means of violence or intimidation against the person, or by the use of force or violence against things, when the crime is committed under any of the following circumstances: 5. When the robbery is committed in an uninhabited place or in a place not inhabited, or in a house or building, or in a public place, or in a place of worship, or in a vessel, or in a vehicle, or in a place where the public has a right to enter.

The Court held that the defendant is guilty of robbery as defined and punished in this article, and that the time and place of the commission of the crime constitute aggravating circumstances under Article 10, Numbers 15 and 20, of the Penal Code.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court rejected the defense of force and capture. It said that it would require very convincing evidence in any case to establish a defense of this character, and in the present record it discovered nothing which could fairly be said to have even a remote tendency in that direction. The defendant was therefore a voluntary member of the party.

On the second issue, the Court held that the party did not constitute a cuadrilla in the sense of the law, because two and perhaps three of the robbers carried arms but the defendant did not. The judgment of the court below, basing the conviction upon Article 505, was so far erroneous.

On the third issue, the Court held that the defendant is guilty of the crime of robbery as defined and punished in Article 503, Number 5, of the Penal Code, and that the time and place of the commission of the crime constitute aggravating circumstances under Article 10, Numbers 15 and 20. The defendant was accordingly sentenced to eight years of presidio mayor.

Doctrine

First, a party of robbers is a cuadrilla, a band, in the sense of Article 505 of the Penal Code only when the conditions of that article are met, including that the malefactors be armed. If one member of the party is unarmed, the party is not a cuadrilla, and a conviction based on that article cannot stand.

Second, the same acts may still constitute robbery under Article 503, Number 5, of the Penal Code, and the time and place of the commission of the crime may be taken as aggravating circumstances under Article 10, Numbers 15 and 20.

Third, the defense that the accused was captured and forced to accompany the robbers requires very convincing evidence. A bare assertion of compulsion, unsupported by the record, will not overcome the evidence of voluntary participation.

Disposition

The judgment of the court below was modified so as to convict the defendant of robbery under Article 503, Number 5, of the Penal Code and sentence him to eight years of presidio mayor, and was affirmed in all other respects with costs, the cause being remanded to the court below for execution of the judgment.

Remember This

Memorize the line that a party of robbers is not a cuadrilla unless the malefactors are armed, so an unarmed member takes the party out of Article 505 and into Article 503, Number 5. Examiners use this case to test the distinction between robbery by a band and ordinary robbery with aggravating circumstances, and to test how strictly the defense of having been forced to join the party must be proved.