🎧 Case Brief Lecture

THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. MACARIO CALLOTES, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.

G.R. No. 948. March 09, 1903 March 9, 1903

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

United States versus Callotes

The Case

This is a criminal appeal from the early years of the American regime, decided in March 1903. The United States, as complainant, prosecuted Macario Callotes for robbery committed by a band of armed men who entered a convent in the town of Bagoc, in Bataan, on the evening of September 11, 1901. Callotes admitted he was with the band but claimed he had been held against his will. The case matters for two reasons: it shows how the Court treats the defense of sequestration, meaning involuntary membership in a band of brigands, and it shows how a conviction must rest on the precise element that the evidence actually proves, so that a conviction under the wrong article cannot stand.

Procedural History

Callotes was tried and convicted in the Court of First Instance. The trial court convicted him under article 508 of the old Penal Code and sentenced him to ten years of presidio mayor, with costs. He appealed to the Supreme Court of the Philippine Islands. The Supreme Court reviewed the evidence and the applicable articles, found that the conviction under article 508 could not be supported, but convicted him instead under a different provision, and returned the case to the Court of First Instance for execution of the judgment.

Facts

On the evening of September 11, 1901, six armed men entered the convent of the pueblo of Bagoc, Bataan. Calixto Tiangco was living in the convent at the time with his family. The armed men intimidated the family, then took and carried away a small sum of money, a revolver, some provisions, and other articles belonging to Tiangco, as well as a hat belonging to Ildefonso Batol.

Callotes admitted that he was with the bandits when the convent was robbed, but claimed that he had been sequestrated by them, that is, taken and held by the band against his will. When he was arrested, Batol's hat was found in his possession. He said he took it from one of the bandits when he separated from the band. He also admitted that he had a revolver, which was given to him by Isidro Mendigoren, the leader of the band, and which he turned over to one Munti, from whom it appears to have been recovered by the inspectors. It does not appear whether or not this revolver was the one taken from the convent.

The record is silent on one point that would prove decisive: there was no evidence as to how the bandits effected an entrance into the convent.

Issues

  • Whether or not the defense of sequestration, that is, involuntary membership in the band of brigands, is entitled to credence on the evidence presented.
  • Whether or not the accused may be convicted under article 508 of the Penal Code on the evidence presented.
  • Whether or not the accused may instead be convicted under Number 5 of article 503, in connection with article 504, with the aggravating circumstance of Number 20 of article 10.

Applicable Provisions

Article 508 of the old Penal Code, the provision under which the trial court convicted, provides:

Article 508. The penalty of presidio mayor shall be imposed upon those who, being members of a band of malefactors, shall enter a town or dwelling house for the purpose of committing robbery, or shall attack the persons therein.

The conviction under this article could not stand because the record contains no evidence of how the bandits entered the convent, and the Court held that the element of entry was not proven.

Number 5 of article 503 of the old Penal Code, the provision under which the Court instead convicted, provides:

Article 503. The penalty of presidio correccional to presidio mayor shall be imposed upon the following persons: Number 5. Those who shall rob another of his property, using violence against or intimidation of persons.

This is the crime the evidence actually established, since the armed men intimidated the family of Tiangco before taking the money and articles.

Article 504 of the old Penal Code, which fixes the penalty when the robbery is committed by a band, provides:

Article 504. When the robbery shall have been committed by a band, or by three or more armed persons, the penalty shall be imposed in its maximum degree.

This provision raised the penalty to its maximum degree because the robbery was committed by six armed men.

Number 20 of article 10 of the old Penal Code, the aggravating circumstance applied, provides:

Article 10. The following are aggravating circumstances: Number 20. That the offense was committed in the dwelling of the offended party, if the latter has not given provocation.

This circumstance was applied because the robbery took place in the convent where Tiangco was living with his family.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court rejected the defense of sequestration. The Court held that this defense is a familiar one in these cases and is of such a character as not to be entitled to much consideration unless supported by strong evidence. Here there was no evidence that the defendant was an involuntary member of the band except his own assertion, and the circumstance that the leader of the band allowed him to carry a revolver strongly discredited the theory. The Court entertained no doubt as to the defendant's guilt.

On the second issue, the Court held that the conviction under article 508 could not be supported, because there was no evidence as to how the bandits effected an entrance into the convent, and entry was an element of that crime.

On the third issue, the Court convicted the defendant instead of the crime defined in Number 5 of article 503, in connection with article 504, with the aggravating circumstance of Number 20 of article 10, and fixed the penalty at ten years of presidio mayor, with costs. In other respects the judgment was affirmed.

Doctrine

First, the defense of sequestration, meaning that the accused was held by a band of brigands against his will, is not entitled to much consideration unless supported by strong evidence. The bare assertion of the accused is not enough, and circumstances such as the leader entrusting him with a revolver may discredit the claim.

Second, a conviction must rest on the precise elements of the crime charged. Where the evidence does not prove an element of the crime under the article of conviction, such as the entry into a town or dwelling house required by article 508, the conviction under that article cannot stand, and the accused may be convicted only of the crime the evidence actually establishes, such as robbery by violence or intimidation of persons under Number 5 of article 503.

Third, when robbery is committed by a band, or by three or more armed persons, article 504 requires that the penalty be imposed in its maximum degree, and where the offense is committed in the dwelling of the offended party who has given no provocation, the aggravating circumstance of Number 20 of article 10 applies.

Disposition

The Supreme Court affirmed the judgment of conviction in substance, but convicted Macario Callotes of robbery under Number 5 of article 503 in connection with article 504, with the aggravating circumstance of Number 20 of article 10, sentenced him to ten years of presidio mayor with costs, and returned the case to the Court of First Instance for execution of the judgment.

Remember This

The line worth memorizing is that the defense of sequestration is not entitled to much consideration unless supported by strong evidence, and the bare assertion of the accused will not overcome the circumstance that the band leader allowed him to carry a revolver. Examiners like to use this case on the requisites of robbery by a band and on the rule that a conviction must rest on the element actually proven, so that a conviction under the wrong article cannot stand.