🎧 Case Brief Lecture

THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. MANUEL BANZON ET AL., DEFENDANTS AND APPELLANTS.

G.R. No. 946. October 22, 1902 October 22, 1902

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

United States versus Banzon

The Case

This is a criminal prosecution brought by the Government of the United States in the Philippine Islands against Manuel Banzon and his co-accused, arising from an attack on two young sisters on a June night in 1901. The trial court convicted the accused of a lesser offense than the prosecution charged; the question on appeal is whether the facts established constitute the graver crime of attempted rape, and whether the accused may be held liable for the commencement of that crime even though they never consummated it. The case matters because it fixes the line between preparation and the beginning of execution in crimes against chastity, and because it applies the graduated penalty rules of the old Penal Code to an attempt frustrated by the victims' resistance rather than by any voluntary desistance.

Procedural History

The accused were charged before the trial court with the crime of rape. They pleaded not guilty. After trial, the court below rendered judgment convicting them, but not of the crime as charged; the judgment was for a lesser offense, and the accused appealed. The case reached the Supreme Court by ordinary appeal from the judgment of conviction, and the Court, speaking through Justice Torres, reversed the judgment below and entered its own judgment of conviction for attempted rape.

Facts

Shortly after eight o'clock on the night of the twenty-ninth of June, 1901, two sisters, Manuela and Felicisima Key Hipolito, aged thirteen and fifteen respectively, were in a watercloset some distance from the house where they lived. They saw the two defendants concealed behind a tree near the privy. The girls left the closet to return to the house, but before they could reach it the defendants approached them: Manuel seized Manuela and Jose seized Felicisima.

The men embraced the girls and tried to throw them to the ground with the intent to rape them. They did not succeed, because the girls resisted and screamed for help, and the screams attracted the attention of their parents. In the struggle Manuela retained in her hand a piece of her aggressor's shirt. The parents could not catch the accused, who fled before the parents reached the spot.

At trial the defendants pleaded not guilty and set up denials and exculpatory allegations, claiming the incident was a simple quarrel. The Court found the evidence for the prosecution conclusive: the testimony of the girls, of their parents, and of other witnesses who heard the screams or saw the struggle from a distance and saw the accused run away; the torn piece of Manuel's shirt left in Manuela's hand; and two letters written in the native dialect by the accused to each of the complaining witnesses some days after the event, in which they confessed their guilt, asked pardon, and begged that the girls themselves impose the punishment.

Issues

  • Whether or not the acts proved constitute the crime of attempted rape rather than a mere quarrel or lesser offense.
  • Whether or not the accused commenced the execution of rape by external acts, so that the non-consummation is attributable to the victims' resistance and not to voluntary desistance.
  • Whether or not the mitigating circumstance of article 11 of the Penal Code should be applied in fixing the penalty.

Applicable Provisions

Article 438 of the Penal Code, which the Court invokes as the provision defining and punishing the crime, provides:

The crime of rape is punished with the penalty of reclusion temporal.

This is the base offense whose penalty is graduated downward because the crime was not consummated.

Article 3 of the Penal Code, on the stages of the crime, provides:

A felony is presumed to exist in all cases where the act committed is punished by law, and the courts shall be guided by the provisions of this Code in determining the degree of the penalty.

This provision anchors the Court's treatment of the external acts as the commencement of execution.

Article 66 of the Penal Code, on the penalty for an attempt, provides:

The penalty prescribed by law for the consummated felony shall be imposed upon the principals in the attempt, in the degree immediately inferior to that prescribed for the consummated felony.

This is the rule that lowers the penalty from that of consummated rape to the minimum degree imposed in the judgment.

Article 11 of the Penal Code, on mitigating circumstances, provides:

The following are mitigating circumstances: ... the circumstance that the offender is a minor, or that the offense was committed with the lesser perversity of the offender.

The Court applies this mitigating circumstance in view of the character of the crime and the personal conditions of the defendants and the complaining witnesses.

Article 61 of the Penal Code, on accessory penalties, provides:

The accessory penalties prescribed by law shall be imposed upon the principals in the attempt.

The Court condemns the accused to the accessory penalties established by this article.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the facts constitute the double crime of attempted rape. The accused, by the mere fact of having embraced the complaining witnesses, struggling with them, and endeavoring to throw them to the ground with the unquestionable intent of raping them, evidently commenced the execution of the crime by exterior acts.

On the second issue, the Court held that the failure to consummate was not due to any voluntary withdrawal but to the resistance of the victims and the arrival of their parents, attracted by their cries. The crime committed is therefore that defined and punished by article 438, in connection with articles 3 and 66 of the Penal Code. The Court found the evidence sufficient to establish guilt as authors respectively of these attempted rapes, notwithstanding the denials and exculpatory allegations of the defendants.

On the third issue, the Court held that no aggravating circumstance was present, but that the mitigating circumstance of article 11 of the Penal Code should be applied in view of the character of the crimes prosecuted and the personal conditions of the defendants and of the complaining witnesses. Each accused must therefore be condemned to the minimum degree of the penalty assigned by law.

Doctrine

An attempt is committed when the offender commences the execution of the crime by external acts and does not perform all the acts of execution that should produce the crime, not by reason of voluntary desistance but by reason of causes independent of the offender's will. Where the accused embrace the victims, struggle with them, and try to throw them to the ground with the intent to rape, they have commenced execution; the victims' resistance and the arrival of their parents are the independent causes that prevent consummation. The penalty for the attempt is the penalty for the consummated felony in the degree immediately inferior, and the mitigating circumstance of article 11 lowers it to the minimum degree. The torn shirt and the letters of confession and apology are competent evidence of guilt.

Disposition

The Court reversed the judgment below and convicted each of the defendants of attempted rape, sentencing each to one year and six months of prison correccional, to pay one half of the costs each, and to suffer the accessory penalties established by article 61 of the Penal Code.

Remember This

The line worth memorizing is that attempt is fixed by the commencement of execution by external acts, and non-consummation counts against the accused when it results from the victims' resistance rather than voluntary desistance. Examiners use this case to test the stages of a felony and the graduation of penalties for an attempt.