🎧 Case Brief Lecture

THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. MELCHOR ABELINDE ET AL., DEFENDANTS AND APPELLANTS.

G. R. No. 945. December 19, 1902 December 19, 1902

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

United States versus Abelinde

The Case

This is a criminal case from the early years of the American occupation, brought by the Government of the United States as complainant against Melchor Abelinde and others as defendants. The defendants were charged with the murder of the Echevarria family and several others in the hamlet of Naro, in the Province of Masbate, in August 1900. The case matters to a reviewee because it is a compact lesson on criminal liability by direct participation, on the qualifying circumstance of alevosia or treachery, on which aggravating circumstances may be counted separately and which are absorbed into treachery, and on why a common crime of robbery with killing falls outside the political amnesty.

Procedural History

The defendants were tried and convicted at first instance, and the trial court condemned them to the penalty of death for murder. Because the penalty imposed was death, the case was sent to the Supreme Court in consultation of the judgment, which was the procedure then in force. During the pendency of the appeal, counsel for the defense moved the Court to apply in favor of the defendants the amnesty of July 4 of that year. The Supreme Court resolved both the consultation of the death judgment and the motion for amnesty in a single decision.

Facts

On the night of the fourteenth or fifteenth of August 1900, the exact date not appearing, the house of the Echevarria family in the hamlet of Naro was assaulted by a band of some forty men. The malefactors fired two or three shots upon arriving, then told the people inside to come down one at a time. As each came down, the assailants took their arms, consisting of guns and revolvers, and tied them elbow to elbow. The prisoners were then killed by shooting or by stabbing with bolos, and their bodies were sewn in sacks and thrown into the sea. All the persons named in the complaint died in this manner.

The facts were established chiefly by the eyewitnesses Patricia Arma and Diego Atigera, the latter having been kidnaped by the malefactors the night before and taken to the place of the crime because he was a relative of the Echevarrias. Elvira Clemente, wife of the deceased Juan Echevarria, testified that the malefactors demanded the surrender of the family's arms, promising not to do them any injury. Other witnesses heard the shots and later saw the bodies on the beach.

As to Melchor Abelinde, the eyewitnesses saw him as part of the band that made the assault, and Patricia Arma testified that she saw him take direct part in the killing. The record showed that he remained at Naro the following morning, standing guard at the door of the house armed with a saber and a gun. As to Leon Arco, nobody saw him at the scene on the night in question, but circumstantial evidence pointed strongly against him: he was seen the next morning leaving with part of the band, armed with a bolo, and he himself captured one of the witnesses, warning him to keep quiet or be killed as the people of Naro had been. Spots of blood were noted on the sheath of his bolo, and days later he was seen with the band, his bolo stained with blood, while a member of the party declared aloud that they had killed the Echevarrias and Arco did not deny it. Both defendants admitted at trial that they were present at Naro with the slayers, but claimed they had been kidnaped and tied to trees at a distance; the Court found this claim unproven and contradicted by the evidence.

Issues

  • Whether or not the defendants are liable as principals by direct participation for the death of the victims even if they did not kill anyone with their own hands.
  • Whether or not the killing was properly classified as murder, that is, whether or not the circumstance of alevosia attended it.
  • Whether or not the trial court erred in appreciating against the defendants the aggravating circumstances of ignominy, of affront to age and sex, and of nighttime and commission by a gang.
  • Whether or not the aggravating circumstances of premeditation and of fraud should be considered against the defendants.
  • Whether or not the amnesty of July 4 should be applied in favor of the defendants.

Applicable Provisions

Article 13 of the Penal Code, on who are principals, provides:

Those who take a direct part in the execution of the act constitute principals.

The Court used this provision to hold that presence as part of the band, contributing to its power, makes one a principal by direct participation.

Paragraph 2 of article 10 of the Penal Code, on alevosia, provides:

There is alevosia when the offender commits any of the crimes against persons, employing means, methods, or forms in the execution thereof which tend directly and specially to insure its execution, without risk to the offender arising from the defense which the offended party might make.

This is the circumstance that qualified the killing as murder, because the victims were tied elbow to elbow and could make no defense.

Article 403 of the Penal Code, on murder, provides:

The crime of murder is committed by any person who, not falling within the provisions of article 402, shall kill another under any of the circumstances mentioned in article 10.

This is the provision under which the trial court classified and punished the crime.

Paragraph 7 of article 10 of the Penal Code, on premeditation, provides:

There is premeditation when the offender has reflected upon the act he is about to commit and persisted in his intention.

The Court applied this against the defendants because of the deliberate planning shown by the record.

Paragraph 8 of article 10 of the Penal Code, on fraud, provides:

There is fraud when the offender makes use of deceit or abuse of confidence.

The Court applied this because the malefactors deceived the victims with a false promise of safety in order to obtain their weapons.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that it is a matter of absolute indifference whether the accused did or did not kill the deceased by their own hands. It is sufficient that they were present as part of the band of murderers at the time and place of the occurrence, thus contributing by their presence to augment the power of the band and to aid in the successful realization of their purposes, in order to become responsible by direct participation for the death of the victims under article 13 of the Penal Code.

On the second issue, the Court held that the fact that the deceased were killed while tied elbow to elbow, and therefore prevented from making any defense, constitutes the circumstance of alevosia under paragraph 2 of article 10. Hence the crime was properly classified as murder under article 403.

On the third issue, the Court held that the trial court erred in considering the aggravating circumstances of ignominy and of affront to age and sex, there being nothing in the record to show any act tending to add ignominy or any intention to affront the age and sex of the deceased. As to nighttime and commission by a gang, the Court held that these must be regarded as involved in the circumstance of alevosia, since in the daytime, and with fewer than four malefactors, it would not have been possible to overcome so many victims who had guns and revolvers and the advantage of a defensive position in the house. Nocturnity and the gang were therefore principal and necessary elements that made alevosia possible, and could not be counted again as separate aggravating circumstances.

On the fourth issue, the Court held that premeditation must be considered against the defendants, because the agreement to form the numerous gang necessarily required mutual and reiterated communication of plans, and the kidnaping of Diego Atigera a day before the crime showed precautions taken to insure its success, evidencing reflexive and persistent deliberation. The Court likewise held that fraud must be considered, because the malefactors deceived the deceased with the false promise that no harm would be done them if they would peaceably give up their guns and revolvers, and then killed them after obtaining the weapons.

On the fifth issue, the Court overruled the motion for amnesty. It found nothing to show that the slayers had taken part in the insurrection against Spain or against the United States, or that the crime was committed to advance the insurrection or from motives connected with it. The mere fact that the deceased were Spaniards did not authorize the conclusion that their death was due to political hatred, and the record showed that the principal object was robbery, everything in the house having been stolen. No charge of robbery was included in the information and so could not be passed upon, but these facts invested the murder with all the characteristics of a common crime, not embraced by the amnesty proclamation.

Doctrine

One who is present as part of a band of murderers at the time and place of the killing, contributing by his presence to augment the power of the band and to aid in the realization of its purpose, is a principal by direct participation under article 13 of the Penal Code, even if he did not kill with his own hands.

Alevosia under paragraph 2 of article 10 qualifies the killing as murder under article 403 when the offender employs means, methods, or forms in the execution which tend directly and specially to insure it without risk to himself arising from the defense the offended party might make, as where the victims are tied elbow to elbow and cannot defend themselves.

Nighttime and commission by a gang, when they are the principal and necessary elements that made the alevosia possible, are absorbed into alevosia and cannot be appreciated as separate aggravating circumstances. Ignominy and affront to age and sex require proof of an act tending to add ignominy or an intention to affront, and are not presumed.

Premeditation under paragraph 7 of article 10 requires reflective and persistent deliberation, shown here by the planned formation of the gang and the kidnaping of a relative a day before the crime to prevent warning. Fraud under paragraph 8 of article 10 is present where the offenders obtain the victims' weapons by a false promise of safety and then kill them.

A crime committed for the principal object of robbery, and not to advance or from motives connected with the insurrection, is a common crime and is not covered by the political amnesty.

Disposition

The Court overruled the motion for amnesty and affirmed the judgment of the trial court, with the modifications indicated as to the aggravating circumstances to be considered against the defendants, with the costs of that instance against them.

Remember This

Presence as part of the band, adding to its power, makes one a principal by direct participation even without killing with his own hands, and nighttime and gang are absorbed into alevosia when they made it possible. Examiners use this case to test absorption of aggravating circumstances into treachery and the rule that a common crime of robbery with killing is outside the political amnesty.