AMERICAN HOME ASSURANCE, COMPANY, PETITIONER, VS. THE COURT OF APPEALS AND NATIONAL MARINE CORPORATION AND/OR NATIONAL MARINE CORPORATION (MANILA), RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
American Home Assurance versus National Marine Corporation
The Case
This is a petition for review on certiorari brought by American Home Assurance Company against the Court of Appeals and National Marine Corporation. The petitioner, as insurer and subrogee of the consignee Mayleen Paper, Incorporated, seeks to recover the amount it paid for a shipment of bleached kraft pulp that was damaged or lost while in the custody of the respondent common carrier. The case matters because it settles the order of inquiry in cargo claims: whether the law on averages under the Code of Commerce may bar a claim before the carrier's negligence is even examined. The Court holds that negligence must be addressed first, and that the Civil Code governs the liability of a common carrier transporting goods to the Philippines.
Procedural History
American Home Assurance Company filed a complaint for recovery of a sum of money before the Regional Trial Court of Manila, Branch 41. National Marine Corporation moved to dismiss on the ground that the complaint stated no cause of action, invoking the law on averages under the Code of Commerce. The trial court initially deferred resolution until trial, but on reconsideration it dismissed the complaint for lack of cause of action, and it denied the insurer's motion for reconsideration.
Instead of appealing, the insurer filed a petition for certiorari with the Court of Appeals. The Court of Appeals dismissed the petition, ruling that the orders of dismissal were final orders and that the proper remedy was an appeal, not certiorari, and that any errors were plain errors of law or judgment. The insurer's motion for reconsideration was denied. The insurer then came to the Supreme Court by petition for review on certiorari, which the Court gave due course.
Facts
On or about June 19, 1988, Cheng Hwa Pulp Corporation shipped 5,000 bales of bleached kraft pulp from Haulien, Taiwan on board the vessel SS Kaunlaran, owned and operated by National Marine Corporation. The shipment was consigned to Mayleen Paper, Incorporated of Manila, which insured it with American Home Assurance Company. On June 22, 1988, the shipment arrived in Manila and was discharged into the custody of Marina Port Services, Incorporated, for eventual delivery to the consignee.
Upon delivery to Mayleen Paper, Incorporated, 122 bales were found either damaged or lost, with straps cut or loose. The loss was calculated at 4,360 kilograms with an estimated value of 61,263 pesos and 41 centavos. Mayleen demanded indemnification from National Marine Corporation, but the demand was not heeded.
Because the shipment was insured, Mayleen sought recovery from American Home Assurance Company, which paid the adjusted amount of 31,506 pesos and 75 centavos. The insurer was thus subrogated to the rights and interests of Mayleen. On June 6, 1989, the insurer, as subrogee, sued National Marine Corporation for that amount plus attorney's fees. National Marine Corporation moved to dismiss, contending that the loss was only a small fraction of the total cargo value and that the claim was barred under the law on averages.
Issues
- Whether or not certiorari was the proper remedy before the Court of Appeals, rather than an appeal from the order of dismissal.
- Whether or not the law on averages under the Code of Commerce may be applied to bar the claim before the negligence of the common carrier is determined.
- Whether or not the common carrier is liable to the insurer as subrogee for the damaged or lost shipment.
Applicable Provisions
Article 848 of the Code of Commerce, invoked by the carrier, provides:
Claims for average shall not be admitted if they do not exceed five percent of the interest which the claimant may have in the vessel or cargo if it is gross average, and one percent of the goods damaged if particular average, deducting in both cases the expenses of appraisal, unless there is an agreement to the contrary.
This is the provision the carrier used to argue that the claim, being less than one percent of the cargo value, was barred.
Article 1753 of the Civil Code, applied by the Court, provides:
The law of the country to which the goods are to be transported governs the liability of the common carrier in case of their loss, destruction or deterioration.
This fixes the governing law for cargo transported to the Philippines as the Civil Code.
Article 1766 of the Civil Code provides:
In all matters not regulated by this Code, the rights and obligations of common carriers shall be governed by the Code of Commerce and by special laws.
This makes the Code of Commerce merely suppletory to the Civil Code.
Article 1733 of the Civil Code provides:
Common carriers, from the nature of their business and for reasons of public policy, are bound to observe extraordinary diligence in the vigilance over the goods and for the safety of passengers transported by them, according to all the circumstances of each case.
This imposes the standard of extraordinary diligence on the carrier.
Article 1735 of the Civil Code provides:
In all cases other than those mentioned in Articles 1734 and 1736, if the common carrier, either by itself or through its employees, or by other persons to whom it has delegated the performance of its obligations, is presumed to have been at fault or to have acted negligently, unless it proves that it has observed the extraordinary diligence required by law.
This creates the presumption of fault against the carrier unless it proves extraordinary diligence.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the Court of Appeals did not err in ruling that an order of dismissal, whether right or wrong, is a final order and a proper subject of appeal, not certiorari. However, because the Court of Appeals nevertheless proceeded to decide the petition on specific points in a manner akin to a regular appeal, the petition was disposed of on the merits, and a review of its decision on the merits was in order.
On the second issue, the Court held that the law on averages cannot be applied to determine liability where there is negligence. The liability of a carrier for cargo transported to the Philippines is governed primarily by the Civil Code, and the Code of Commerce applies only suppletorily. Under Article 1733, the carrier must observe extraordinary diligence, and under Article 1735 it is presumed at fault unless it proves that diligence. The Court concluded that the issue of negligence must first be addressed before the Code of Commerce provisions on the extent of liability may be applied.
On the third issue, the Court noted that National Marine Corporation, instead of presenting proof of extraordinary diligence, filed a motion to dismiss, which hypothetically admitted the truth of the facts alleged in the complaint, namely that the loss was due to its negligence or fault. Since the case did not fall under any of the exceptions in Article 1734, the carrier was liable, and the insurer was entitled to reimbursement of what it paid to Mayleen Paper, Incorporated.
Doctrine
The liability of a common carrier for loss, destruction, or deterioration of goods transported to the Philippines is governed primarily by the Civil Code, and the Code of Commerce applies only in matters not regulated by the Civil Code. The law on averages under the Code of Commerce cannot be applied to bar a claim where the loss was caused by the carrier's negligence. The issue of negligence must first be resolved before the provisions on the extent of liability may be applied. A common carrier is presumed at fault unless it proves extraordinary diligence, and the filing of a motion to dismiss on the ground of lack of cause of action admits the material facts pleaded in the complaint.
Disposition
The Court reversed the decisions of the Court of Appeals and the Regional Trial Court, and ordered National Marine Corporation to reimburse American Home Assurance Company the amount of 31,506 pesos and 75 centavos.
Remember This
The single line to memorize: the law on averages cannot defeat a cargo claim where the carrier's negligence is admitted, because negligence must be addressed before the Code of Commerce on liability applies. Examiners use this case to test the suppletory application of the Code of Commerce to common carriers and the presumption of fault under the Civil Code.