JOSE EMETERIO GUEVARA, PETITIONER, VS. TUASON & CO., RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Guevara versus Tuason and Company
The Case
This is the case of Guevara versus Tuason and Company, an early decision of the Supreme Court under the American regime, penned by Justice Willard and promulgated in October 1901. Jose Emeterio Guevara, the petitioner, asked the Court to be allowed to appeal from a judgment rendered against him by the court of Quiapo in an action of forcible entry and detainer, invoking the relief then available under Act Number 75 of the Civil Commission. The case matters because it fixes the meaning of the statutory ground of mistake or excusable negligence: the Court holds that this ground refers to a mistake or negligence of the party, not to a judicial error of the court, and that it cannot be used as a substitute for an ordinary appeal.
Procedural History
Guevara was the defendant in an action of forcible entry and detainer before the court of Quiapo, which rendered judgment against him in December 1898. He was represented by his attorney during the trial, and that attorney was properly notified of the judgment in the same month. Guevara did not appeal. Instead, he later filed a petition seeking to bring himself within the provisions of Act Number 75 of the Civil Commission, praying that he be permitted to appeal from the judgment. The Supreme Court resolved the petition directly, denying it with costs against the petitioner. Justices Torres, Cooper, Ladd, and Mapa concurred, while Chief Justice Arellano did not sit in the case.
Facts
Guevara was sued in forcible entry and detainer before the court of Quiapo, and judgment was rendered against him in December 1898. His attorney, who represented him at the trial, was properly notified of the judgment later that same month. No appeal was taken.
In his petition, Guevara offered two reasons for his failure to appeal. First, he argued that the court of Quiapo had no jurisdiction over the matter, since the property in question is located in what is now the Province of Rizal, outside the limits of the territory then occupied by the Government of the United States. Second, he alleged that, having been persuaded that the proceedings of the court of Quiapo could have no validity or efficacy, both for that reason and because the judicial terms under a royal decree issued in July 1898 by the colonial office of the Spanish Government were suspended until the date of the Treaty of Paris in December 1898, he did not appeal, and that his omission was due to an excusable accident, namely the past occurrences which produced radical changes in all of the orders and in the royal decree.
The Court observed that these were the only reasons alleged, and that it was not the royal decree which induced the petitioner to delay his appeal, since he himself stated that the decree remained in force only until December 1898.
Issues
- Whether or not the petitioner may be relieved from his failure to appeal under Act Number 75 of the Civil Commission on the ground of mistake or excusable negligence, when his omission rested on his own belief that the judgment was invalid and that an appeal would be useless.
- Whether or not the alleged lack of jurisdiction of the court of Quiapo, which the petitioner says it erred in deciding in its own favor, constitutes the mistake contemplated by the said Act.
Applicable Provisions
The decision applies the relief granted by Act Number 75 of the Civil Commission, which the Court construes through its ground of mistake or excusable negligence. The Court states the governing principle in these words:
In general terms the "mistake or excusable negligence" of which the said act treats should be understood as that committed by the party and not that of the court.
This formulation controls the whole case, because it confines the statutory relief to the party's own mistake or negligence and excludes the errors of the court, which are correctible by appeal.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the petitioner had not shown himself entitled to the relief. It does not suffice that a mistake appear; it must likewise appear that the party was unable to interpose the appeal by reason of that mistake. Here, the royal decree could not have caused the delay, since by the petitioner's own account it remained in force only until December 1898, and no fraud was alleged, nor any circumstance showing that an appeal could not have been attempted.
On the second issue, the Court held that even on the supposition that the petitioner was right about jurisdiction, his allegation could not prevail, because it rested on the claim that the court committed an error in deciding that it was competent. The word mistake, in the Act, does not apply and never was intended to apply to a judicial error committed by the court in the trial. Such errors may be corrected by means of an appeal, and the Act cannot in any way be employed as a substitute for that remedy. The Court added that the erroneous opinion of one of the parties concerning the incorrectness of the judicial decision of the court cannot constitute grounds for the relief, since in no wise has the party been prevented from interposing his appeal; the most that may be said is that, by reason of an erroneous interpretation of the law, he believed that all recourse of appeal would be useless.
Doctrine
The mistake or excusable negligence contemplated by Act Number 75 of the Civil Commission is the mistake or negligence of the party, not the error of the court. A judicial error committed by the court in the course of the trial is corrected by appeal, and the relief under the Act cannot be used as a substitute for that remedy. It is not enough that a mistake be shown; it must also appear that the party was prevented from appealing by reason of that mistake. A party's own erroneous belief that the judgment is invalid, or that an appeal would be useless, is not the mistake that confers the relief, because it did not in any way prevent him from appealing.
Disposition
The Supreme Court denied the petition, with costs against the petitioner, Guevara.
Remember This
The line to memorize is that the mistake or excusable negligence under the Act is that committed by the party and not that of the court, and it cannot substitute for an appeal. Examiners use this case to test whether a party's erroneous belief about a court's jurisdiction or the futility of an appeal can justify relief from judgment, and the answer is no.