THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. MIGUEL MONTON ET AL., DEFENDANTS AND APPELLANTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
United States versus Monton
The Case
This is a criminal case in which the Government of the United States prosecuted Miguel Monton and four other defendants for the murder of Eleno Afable, a Filipino town crier of Pola, Mindoro, who was executed by insurrectionary soldiers as a spy of the Americans. The case matters because it is an early statement of the political offense doctrine in Philippine jurisprudence: a killing committed in furtherance of an armed insurrection, pursuant to the order of a superior officer, is a crime of a political character and falls within the amnesty proclamation of July 4, 1902.
Procedural History
The five defendants were tried in the Court of First Instance of Mindoro for the murder of Eleno Afable. Buenaventura Paola, Modesto Ramos, Brigido Jimenez, and Miguel Monton were convicted and sentenced to death. Victorio Pilar was convicted and sentenced to twelve years and one day of cadena temporal. The case as to the first four was brought to the Supreme Court in consulta, that is, for review of the death sentences. Victorio Pilar did not appeal. The Solicitor-General and counsel for the accused joined in a motion that the defendants be discharged on the ground that they are included in the amnesty proclamation of July 4, 1902.
Facts
Eleno Afable, a Filipino, was for some time the town crier of the pueblo of Pola, in the Island of Mindoro. In the first days of October 1901 the American forces were in possession of Pola, and he was performing such duties as the commander of those forces, through the municipal president, imposed upon him. In the early part of October he left the pueblo to bring from his sementera two of his children and some rice. He was captured by insurrectionary soldiers and taken to their camp in the mountain, six hours from the barrio of Casiligan.
There were in the camp between 150 and 200 revolutionary soldiers. The officer in command was Raymundo Corcuera, since deceased, before whom Eleno Afable was brought by his captors. The officer convened a council, of which the defendants Buenaventura Paola and Modesto Ramos, both officials inferior in rank to Raymundo, formed a part. The officer asked the opinion of the other officers as to the acts of the accused and the disposition to be made of him. The investigation resulted in an order from Raymundo Corcuera that the prisoner be killed, because he was a spy of the Americans.
Six soldiers, under the command of the defendant Brigido Jimenez, were told off to execute the sentence. Eleno Afable was taken by the guard into the forest, about a thousand yards from the camp, and there decapitated by the defendant Miguel Monton. His body was brutally mutilated and buried at the place of execution. The guard returned to the camp, and Brigido Jimenez reported verbally to Raymundo Corcuera that his orders had been carried out. The defendant Victorio Pilar was one of these six men.
Issues
- Whether or not the murder of Eleno Afable was a crime of a political character committed in the course of the insurrection against the United States.
- Whether or not the defendants were participating against the United States in the insurrection, so as to be included in the amnesty proclamation of July 4, 1902.
- Whether or not the Supreme Court may make any order in the case of Victorio Pilar, who did not appeal.
Applicable Provisions
The amnesty proclamation of July 4, 1902 grants amnesty to persons participating in the insurrection against the United States, upon compliance with the conditions stated therein. The Court applies it as the source of the defendants' entitlement to discharge:
The defendants Buenaventura Paola, Modesto Ramos, Miguel Monton, and Brigido Jimenez are, therefore, declared to be entitled to the benefit of the proclamation, upon filing in this court the oath prescribed therein as a condition of the amnesty, and upon the filing of such oath the cause will be returned to the court below with directions that the defendants be discharged, with costs de oficio.
Act Number 194 of the Commission governs the review of criminal cases on appeal or in consulta, and it is the basis for the Court's holding that it cannot act on the case of a defendant who did not appeal:
We have, however, no power to make any order in the case of Victorio Pilar, as there was no appeal as to him, and his case could not come here in consulta.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that under the circumstances narrated it is clear that the murder of Eleno Afable was a crime of a political character. It cited its own recent decisions in United States versus Villamor and United States versus Carmona, and the English and American authorities In re Castioni and In re Ezeta.
On the second issue, the Court found that at the time in question the defendants Buenaventura Paola, Modesto Ramos, and Brigido Jimenez were participating against the United States in the insurrection then existing, and that the murder was committed pursuant to an order issued by an officer engaged in that insurrection superior in rank to any of the defendants. As to Miguel Monton and Victorio Pilar, both testified that they were prisoners of the insurrectionists, and one of the six, Federico Aguilar, testified that they were all prisoners except Brigido Jimenez and Vicente Espinosa. There was, however, direct testimony that they were all insurrectionary soldiers, and the circumstances confirmed it: a formation of all in the camp was made, from which the six men were selected; the six were all armed with bolos; and they were over a thousand yards from the camp, so that if five of the six were prisoners, their escape could easily have been effected. The Court therefore concluded that Miguel Monton and Victorio Pilar were participating against the United States in the insurrection, and that all of the defendants except Victorio Pilar are included within the proclamation.
On the third issue, the Court held that it had no power to make any order in the case of Victorio Pilar, as there was no appeal as to him, and his case could not come to the Court in consulta.
Doctrine
A killing is a crime of a political character, and thus within the amnesty, when it is committed in the course of an armed insurrection against the established government, pursuant to an order issued by an officer engaged in that insurrection who is superior in rank to the accused. Participation in the insurrection may be established not only by direct testimony but by circumstantial evidence, such as the selection of the accused from a military formation, their being armed, and the absence of any real opportunity or attempt to escape. The benefit of the amnesty is conditioned on the filing of the oath prescribed in the proclamation. Finally, the Supreme Court acquires no jurisdiction over a defendant who did not appeal, and whose case cannot come up in consulta.
Disposition
The Court declared Buenaventura Paola, Modesto Ramos, Miguel Monton, and Brigido Jimenez entitled to the benefit of the amnesty proclamation upon filing the prescribed oath, and directed that upon such filing the cause be returned to the court below with directions that they be discharged, with costs de oficio.
Remember This
Remember the line that a killing committed in the course of insurrection, upon the order of a superior officer of the insurrection, is a crime of a political character and is covered by amnesty. Examiners use this case to test the political offense doctrine and the rule that the Supreme Court cannot act on a co-accused who did not appeal.