THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. CATALINO COLOCAR ET AL., DEFENDANT AND APPELLANTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Colocar versus United States
The Case
This is a criminal prosecution brought by the United States against Catalino Colocar and several others for the killing of Mariano Finohermoso, a man believed to be a spy of the American Army. The defense rested on the claim that the killing was done in obedience to a military order issued during the insurrection against the American Government in Mindoro, and that the accused therefore fell within the amnesty proclamation. The case matters because it is an early statement of the rule that a killing committed for a political purpose, in obedience to an order of a military authority, is a political offense and not a common crime, and so is reached by amnesty.
Procedural History
The defendants were tried and convicted in the court below for the killing of Mariano Finohermoso. They appealed that judgment to the Supreme Court of the Philippine Islands. The Supreme Court, speaking through Chief Justice Arellano, did not resolve the appeal on the ordinary question of guilt. Instead, it examined whether the facts brought the accused within the amnesty proclamation, and it held that they did.
Facts
Catalino Colocar was regarded as an officer with the rank of second lieutenant of infantry, and in that capacity he took part in the insurrection against the American Government in Mindoro. He received from Major Estanislao Cayton orders to kill Mariano Finohermoso, who was considered to be a spy of the American Army.
Ceferino Colocar protected his son Catalino in the matter. The other defendants were accused of having participated in some degree in the actual killing, their participation consisting in the digging of the grave and the burial of Finohermoso, all done by order of Catalino Colocar.
The Court noted that it did not appear that there was, or could have been, any other motive for the killing. That single finding is what moved the case from ordinary homicide into the field of political offense.
Issues
- Whether or not the killing of Mariano Finohermoso was a crime of a political character, committed by Catalino Colocar as principal offender in obedience to an order received from a military authority.
- Whether or not the accused, including those who merely dug the grave and buried the body by order of Catalino Colocar, are embraced by the amnesty proclamation.
Applicable Provisions
The amnesty proclamation of July 4, 1902, is the measure the Court construes, and its terms are the reason the case falls within it. The Court states the governing condition in these words:
We therefore hold that Catalino Colocar, Ceferino Colocar, Lucio Alcala, and Diego Cueto, defendants in the present case, are embraced by the amnesty proclamation, upon condition of their taking and subscribing before a competent authority the oath prescribed in the proclamation of July 4, 1902, with the costs de oficio.
This is the operative condition of the proclamation as the Court applies it: amnesty is extended, but only upon the taking and subscribing of the prescribed oath before a competent authority.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that, upon the hypothesis of the guilt of the defendants, the killing was a crime of a political character. Catalino Colocar was the principal offender, and he acted in obedience to an order received from a military authority. Because no other motive for the killing appeared, the act was not private vengeance or ordinary homicide but an act done in the service of the insurrection.
On the second issue, the Court held that the case falls strictly within the terms of the amnesty proclamation. The benefit was not confined to Catalino Colocar. It reached Ceferino Colocar, who protected his son, and Lucio Alcala and Diego Cueto, whose participation consisted in digging the grave and burying the body by order of Catalino Colocar. The Court expressed the conclusion in this language:
Upon the hypothesis of the guilt of the defendants, it would be, therefore, a crime of a political character committed by the defendant Catalino Colocar, the principal offender, in obedience to an order received from a military authority, and consequently the case falls strictly within the terms of the amnesty proclamation.
The grant, however, was conditional. The accused were embraced by the proclamation only upon their taking and subscribing, before a competent authority, the oath prescribed in the proclamation of July 4, 1902, with costs de oficio, meaning costs at the expense of the public treasury.
Doctrine
A killing committed for a political purpose, in obedience to an order received from a military authority during an insurrection, is a political offense and not a common crime. Where no other motive for the killing appears, the political character of the act is established, and the case falls strictly within the terms of the amnesty proclamation.
The benefit of the amnesty is not limited to the principal offender. Those who participate in some degree in the act, such as by digging the grave and burying the body upon the order of the principal, are likewise embraced by the proclamation.
Amnesty under the proclamation is conditional. It is extended only upon the taking and subscribing, before a competent authority, of the oath prescribed in the proclamation of July 4, 1902, and it carries with it costs de oficio.
Disposition
The Court held that Catalino Colocar, Ceferino Colocar, Lucio Alcala, and Diego Cueto are embraced by the amnesty proclamation, upon condition of their taking and subscribing before a competent authority the oath prescribed in the proclamation of July 4, 1902, with costs de oficio.
Remember This
The line to memorize is that a killing done in obedience to a military order, for a political purpose and with no other motive, is a political offense that falls strictly within the terms of the amnesty proclamation. Examiners use this case to test the distinction between political offenses and common crimes, the reach of amnesty to accessories who act upon the principal's order, and the conditional nature of amnesty, which requires the prescribed oath before a competent authority.