PEDRO REGALADO, PLAINTIFF AND APPELLANT, VS. FELIX DE LOS SANTOS ET AL., DEFENDANTS AND APPELLEES.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Regalado versus De los Santos
The Case
This is an appeal by Pedro Regalado from a judgment of the Court of First Instance of Iloilo dismissing his executive action against Felix de los Santos and his co-debtors. Regalado had acquired, by assignment, a mortgage credit originally held by Jose Regalado Santa Ana, and he sued both for a personal judgment on the debt and for the sale of the mortgaged lands. The trial court held that it had no jurisdiction because the lands lay in Negros, and it dismissed the action. The case matters because it fixes two rules every reviewee must know: how a mortgage turns a loan into a mixed action for purposes of venue, and what counts as an express submission to a court in a contract clause.
Procedural History
Pedro Regalado filed an executive action before the judge of the Court of First Instance of Iloilo. The court admitted the suit and embargoed the mortgaged property. The defendants opposed the proceedings on eight grounds, among them want of jurisdiction, failure to notify them of the assignment, absence of an express submission to the Iloilo court, non-compliance with the mortgage registry requirements, absence of a fixed amount due, lack of prior appraisement, extinction of the debt by the assignment, and non-compliance with the regulation requiring the complaint to state the creditor's undertaking to indemnify for loss caused by malice or negligence.
The Court of First Instance of Iloilo rendered judgment on the tenth of February, 1902. It found that the mortgaged property was situated in Negros and that no part lay in Iloilo, and that the value of the property was not shown and no appraisement had been made. On those findings it declared itself without jurisdiction, dismissed the executive action, raised the preventive embargo, ordered the property returned to the defendants' control, directed the administrator to render an exact account of rents, products, and profits, and condemned the plaintiff to pay costs, damages, and injuries. Pedro Regalado appealed to the Supreme Court.
Facts
On the fourth of May, 1891, in Iloilo, Jose Regalado Santa Ana on one side and Felix de los Santos, Gil Javier, and Geronima Cabajug on the other entered into a contract of loan with mortgage before a notary public. The debtors acknowledged themselves jointly and severally bound to pay 5,259.33 pesos within one year, with interest at fifteen per cent per annum. As security, De los Santos mortgaged the hacienda San Pablo, and Cabajug mortgaged the hacienda Santa Cruz, both in the Island of Negros. De los Santos also bound himself to deliver whatever he might recover on a separate mortgage credit he held against his father, secured on the hacienda San Roque in Cadiz Nueva.
On the seventeenth of September, 1900, again in Iloilo, Jose Regalado Santa Ana transferred and assigned the mortgage, with interest due from the fourth of December, 1891, to Pedro Regalado Montelibano, acknowledging receipt of the principal and the interest at fifteen per cent.
On the third of November, 1900, Pedro Regalado, relying on that assignment, brought an executive action against the defendants before the Court of First Instance of Iloilo. The court admitted the suit and embargoed the mortgaged property. The defendants opposed, and the trial court, finding the lands situated in Negros and no appraisement made, dismissed the action for want of jurisdiction.
Issues
- Whether or not the Court of First Instance of Iloilo had jurisdiction over an action that was both personal and mortgage foreclosure, where the mortgaged property and the defendants' residence lay in Negros.
- Whether or not the clause in the mortgage contract submitting the debtors to the creditor's domicile in Iloilo amounted to an express submission to the jurisdiction of the Iloilo court.
- Whether or not the provisions of the Mortgage Law on the situs of the property and on prior appraisement applied to a mortgage executed in 1891, before that law took effect.
Applicable Provisions
Paragraph 4 of article 46 of the Spanish Code of Civil Procedure provides:
In mixed actions jurisdiction is vested in the judge of the place where the property is situated or the residence of the defendant, at the election of the plaintiff.
This fixes the venue of a mixed action such as a mortgage foreclosure, and it is the provision on which the trial court's dismissal ultimately turned.
Article 40 of the Spanish Code of Civil Procedure provides:
Any judge tacitly or expressly agreed upon by the litigant parties shall have jurisdiction over any action brought before and submitted to him.
This recognizes that the parties may by agreement confer jurisdiction on a chosen judge.
Article 41 of the Spanish Code of Civil Procedure provides:
An express submission is made when the litigant parties clearly and in definite terms renounce the right to present the matter before the proper court and unequivocally designate the judge agreed upon to determine the question.
This sets the standard the Court applied to the submission clause in the mortgage.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the action, being brought both for a personal judgment against the defendants and for an order to sell real estate in satisfaction of the debt, is in its nature a mixed action. The addition of a mortgage to a contract of loan produces what the Court called a hypothecary or mixed action. Under paragraph 4 of article 46, jurisdiction in mixed actions lies with the judge of the place where the property is situated or of the defendant's residence, at the plaintiff's election. Since the mortgaged property was in Negros, which was also the residence of all the defendants, and absent a valid submission, the action should have been brought in Negros.
On the second issue, the Court examined the clause providing for payment in current silver in Iloilo at the creditor's house, to whose domicile the debtors expressly submitted themselves, renouncing all other domicile. The Court reasoned that since payment in Iloilo had already been stipulated expressly, the submission clause would be meaningless unless read as a submission to the jurisdiction of the Iloilo court, and it gave every part of the clause effect. Designation of the judge means designation of the court, not the judge by name. The clause was therefore a valid express submission under articles 40 and 41.
On the third issue, the Court held that the Mortgage Law, enacted in 1893, did not govern a mortgage executed in 1891. Creditors whose rights were recorded before the law took effect were given the option to use the summary procedure, but the plaintiff did not avail himself of it. His suit was an executive action under the Code of Civil Procedure in force at the date of the mortgage. Hence the requirement of prior appraisement did not apply, and in any event appraisement in an executive action is made after the order directing the sale, a stage not yet reached when the case was dismissed.
Doctrine
A loan secured by a mortgage gives rise to a mixed action, and venue lies with the judge of the place where the property is situated or of the defendant's residence, at the plaintiff's election. The parties may by express submission confer jurisdiction on a chosen court, and such submission exists when they clearly and in definite terms renounce the proper court and unequivocally designate the court agreed upon. Designation of the judge means designation of the court, not the individual judge by name. Finally, a mortgage executed before the Mortgage Law took effect is governed by the procedural law in force at its execution, unless the creditor elects the summary procedure under the later law.
Disposition
The Supreme Court reversed the judgment of dismissal, ordered the case reinstated to its status at the date of the judgment of dismissal, and adjudged the costs of the appeal against the appellees.
Remember This
Memorize this line: a mortgage added to a loan makes the action mixed, and a clause submitting the debtors to the creditor's domicile is an express submission to the court of that place. Examiners use this case to test venue in mortgage foreclosure and the requisites of a valid express submission under the old Code of Civil Procedure.