DOMINGO GARCIA Y CASANOVA, PLAINTIFF AND APPELLEE, VS. EMETERIO RUIZ Y URBINA, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Garcia versus Ruiz
The Case
This is an action of lesser import brought by Domingo Garcia y Casanova, a ship captain, against Emeterio Ruiz y Urbina, the owner of the merchant steamer Irene Urbina. Garcia sues for the salary accruing to him from the day he was discharged until he could return to Manila, together with his passage money, damages, and costs. The case matters because it fixes the rule on the right of a ship captain, engaged for an indefinite term, to be paid his wages until he is returned to the port where his contract was made, even after the shipowner has discharged him. It is an early decision of the Supreme Court applying the Code of Commerce to a contract of maritime service.
Procedural History
Garcia filed his complaint in the court of first instance on the twelfth of July, 1898. Ruiz refused to accept a copy of the complaint and the summons, and upon motion of the plaintiff he was declared in default, with the complaint admitted as answered. The court rendered judgment against him by default. Ruiz filed written notice of appeal to the former Audiencia, and the appeal was allowed.
Before the Audiencia, counsel for Ruiz raised an incidental issue asking that all proceedings from and after the order of August 8, 1898 be set aside. The Audiencia, by judgment of the fifteenth of November, 1900, denied the annulment sought, without special judgment for costs. The case then came before the Supreme Court on appeal from the judgment rendered against Ruiz by default.
Facts
On the twenty-second of August, 1897, Garcia took command as skipper of the merchant steamer Irene Urbina under a verbal contract with its owner, Ruiz, entered into in the city of Manila. Under that contract Garcia was to command the steamer in its voyages between the ports of Misamis and in service as a tug. The contract did not stipulate the time it was to continue in force or during which the services were to be rendered.
On the eleventh of June, 1898, upon Garcia's arrival with the steamer at the port of Lapinig, in the town of Talisayan de Misamis, Ruiz wrote him a letter discharging him. Garcia alleged that none of the causes which justify the dismissal of the captain or other member of the crew were present. He claimed the salary of one hundred dollars per month which he had been receiving until such time as he could return to Manila, together with his passage money, and sixty dollars as indemnification for damages, having been abandoned at a place where it was impossible for him to support himself by the exercise of his calling.
Garcia presented his claim to the marine authorities, and Ruiz denied his right, stating among other things that he would only accede to the demand if the law compelled him to do so. The marine authorities declared themselves incompetent to try the case. When cited and notified to appear in the court of Misamis, Ruiz refused to accept a copy of the complaint or to sign an acknowledgment of service, thereby voluntarily becoming in default, and he did not allege that he was prevented by force majeure from appearing.
Issues
- Whether or not the silence of the defendant Ruiz, who voluntarily allowed himself to be declared in default, must be taken as an admission of the facts alleged in the complaint.
- Whether or not the plaintiff Garcia was entitled to receive his salary from the eleventh of June, 1898, at the rate of one hundred dollars per month, until his return to the city of Manila, notwithstanding that the shipowner discharged him on that day.
- Whether or not the appellate court could still pass upon the formal defects or errors of procedure raised in the incidental issue, they having been already passed upon by a final decision.
Applicable Provisions
Article 604 of the Code of Commerce is the provision the Court invokes as the legislative sanction and recognition of the captain's right:
Article 604. The captain shall be entitled to receive his salary from the day he takes charge of the vessel until the day he is discharged, and in case of discharge, until he returns to the port where the contract was entered into.
This provision bears directly on the case because it fixes the period for which the discharged captain's salary continues, which is the very relief Garcia sought.
Article 636 of the Code of Commerce is also cited by the Court in support of the propriety of the claim:
Article 636. The captain may be discharged by the shipowner or by the person who may have chartered the vessel, but the former shall be obliged to pay him the salary agreed upon until his return to the port where the contract was entered into.
This provision confirms that the shipowner's power to discharge does not extinguish the obligation to pay the captain's salary until his return to the port of contract.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the defendant's silence must be taken as an admission of the facts alleged. The documents attached to the complaint showed that Ruiz was fully aware of the terms of the complaint and the facts alleged, because the written claim filed by Garcia with the governor of the district was replied to by Ruiz with a statement of the reasons for his conduct. When subsequently cited and notified to appear, Ruiz refused to accept a copy of the complaint or to sign an acknowledgment of service, thereby voluntarily becoming in default, and he did not allege that he was prevented by force majeure from appearing. Nothing having occurred to prevent him from defending himself, his silence was an admission of the facts.
On the second issue, the Court held that the question reduced to determining whether Garcia was entitled to receive his salary from the eleventh of June, 1898, at the rate of one hundred dollars per month, until his return to the city of Manila, notwithstanding that Ruiz discharged him on that day. The Court held that the principle established by Article 604 of the Code of Commerce is a legislative sanction and recognition of Garcia's right, and that nothing appeared in any way tending to deprive him of his unquestionable right to receive his salary until his return to the port where his contract for an unlimited time was entered into. The propriety of his claim was therefore unquestionable, and the Court cited Article 636 of the Code of Commerce in support.
On the third issue, the Court held that it was precluded from discussing the formal defects or errors of procedure which had been passed upon by a final decision, referring to the Audiencia's judgment of the fifteenth of November, 1900 denying the annulment sought by the appellant.
The Court noted that the judge of first instance had limited the plaintiff's right to receive his salary to the time of the notification of the judgment, which took place on the twelfth of September, 1898, and that it did not appear that Garcia had taken any exception to this decision. No other error complained of appearing in the appealed judgment, the Court affirmed the same.
Doctrine
A ship captain engaged for an indefinite term, who is discharged by the shipowner without any of the causes that justify dismissal, is entitled to receive his salary from the day he takes charge of the vessel until the day he is discharged, and in case of discharge, until he returns to the port where the contract was entered into. This is the rule of Article 604 of the Code of Commerce, which the Court called a legislative sanction and recognition of the captain's right.
The shipowner's power to discharge the captain under Article 636 of the Code of Commerce does not extinguish the obligation to pay the salary agreed upon until the captain's return to the port where the contract was entered into. The discharge terminates the service but not the obligation to pay wages until the captain is returned to the port of contract.
A defendant who, with full knowledge of the complaint and the facts alleged, refuses to accept service and voluntarily allows himself to be declared in default, without alleging force majeure, is deemed to have admitted the facts alleged in the complaint. His silence is an admission.
Formal defects or errors of procedure that have already been passed upon by a final decision of the appellate court cannot be discussed anew in the decision on the merits.
Disposition
The Supreme Court affirmed the appealed judgment, with costs against the appellant Ruiz.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing is that a captain discharged without cause is entitled to his salary until he returns to the port where the contract was entered into, for the shipowner's power to discharge does not extinguish the obligation to pay. Examiners use this case to test the rule on the wages of a discharged ship captain under the Code of Commerce and the effect of a defendant's voluntary default as an admission of the facts alleged.