REBECCO E. PANLILIO AND TRINIDAD DIAZ-ENRIQUEZ, PETITIONERS, VS. SANDIGANBAYAN, SECOND DIVISION, AND PRESIDENTIAL COMMISSION ON GOOD GOVERNMENT, RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Panlilio versus Sandiganbayan
The Case
This is a special civil action for certiorari and prohibition brought by Rebecco Panlilio and Trinidad Diaz-Enriquez against the Second Division of the Sandiganbayan and the Presidential Commission on Good Government, which I will call the PCGG. The petitioners were charged before the Sandiganbayan with violating the Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act, and they ask the Supreme Court to stop the PCGG from reinvestigating their case. The case matters because it fixes the boundary between two agencies that both reach ill-gotten wealth — the PCGG and the Ombudsman — and because it applies the settled rule that a prosecutor cannot also sit as judge in the preliminary investigation of his own complaint.
Procedural History
The PCGG filed an information against the petitioners with the Sandiganbayan. After posting bail, the petitioners moved to quash on several grounds, among them that the PCGG had no authority to file the information. They later asked that their motion be treated as a motion for reinvestigation. The Sandiganbayan denied the motion to quash but granted the prayer for reinvestigation, ordered the PCGG to conduct it, and allowed the petitioners to submit counter-affidavits and evidence. The PCGG then directed the petitioners to submit their counter-affidavits on a fixed date, and when they did not, the PCGG deemed the reinvestigation terminated. The petitioners asked the Sandiganbayan to clarify whether the PCGG still had jurisdiction in view of the Ombudsman Act of 1989; the Sandiganbayan held that the PCGG retained it. The petitioners then asked the Ombudsman to take over the reinvestigation, and the Ombudsman declined. The Sandiganbayan denied reconsideration, and at the arraignment Panlilio refused to plead, so a plea of not guilty was entered for him. The petitioners then came to the Supreme Court by this petition for certiorari and prohibition.
Facts
On the tenth of August 1989, the PCGG filed an information with the Sandiganbayan charging the petitioners with violation of Section 4, paragraph b, of the Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act. The information alleged that, from 1974 to 1980, the petitioners, as private individuals taking advantage of their close personal relation with former President Ferdinand Marcos, induced him to issue presidential directives and instructions for the acquisition and titling of lands within the former United States Calumpang Naval Reservation in Ternate, Cavite, and adjoining lands, to form part of the Puerto Azul complex, which they controlled and operated, and caused the use of government funds, personnel, and equipment in building roads and bridges within that complex.
After posting bail, the petitioners moved to quash and later asked for reinvestigation. The Sandiganbayan granted the reinvestigation and directed the PCGG to conduct it. The PCGG ordered the petitioners to submit their counter-affidavits on the twenty-eighth of December 1989. Instead of complying, the petitioners asked for an extension, because they wanted first to clarify whether the PCGG still had jurisdiction after the Ombudsman Act of 1989 took effect. The Sandiganbayan ruled that the PCGG retained jurisdiction. The petitioners then wrote the Ombudsman to request that it conduct the reinvestigation, and the Ombudsman declined, saying that the exercise of its authority over the case was inappropriate.
While the petitioners sought reconsideration before the Sandiganbayan, the PCGG issued an order holding that, because no counter-affidavits had been filed, the reinvestigation was deemed terminated. The Sandiganbayan denied reconsideration, and the petitioners elevated the matter to the Supreme Court.
Issues
- Whether or not the Ombudsman, and not the PCGG, has the primary jurisdiction to reinvestigate the criminal case against the petitioners.
- Whether or not the PCGG possesses the cold neutrality of an impartial judge and is competent to proceed with the reinvestigation.
- Whether or not the petitioners waived their right to a preliminary investigation by failing to submit their counter-affidavits.
Applicable Provisions
Section 15, paragraph 1, of the Ombudsman Act of 1989 bears on the first issue, because it is the provision said to have transferred primary jurisdiction to the Ombudsman:
Section 15. Powers, Functions and Duties. The Office of the Ombudsman shall have the following powers, functions and duties: (1) Investigate and prosecute on its own or on complaint by any person, any act or omission of any public officer or employee, office or agency, when such act or omission appears to be illegal, unjust, improper or inefficient. It has primary jurisdiction over cases cognizable by the Sandiganbayan and, in the exercise of this primary jurisdiction, it may take over, at any stage, from any investigatory agency of Government, the investigation of such cases.
Section 2 of Executive Order Number 1 defines the PCGG's task of assisting the President in the recovery of ill-gotten wealth and in the investigation of graft cases assigned to it:
Section 2. The Commission shall be charged with the task of assisting the President in regard to the following matters: (a) The recovery of all ill-gotten wealth accumulated by former President Ferdinand E. Marcos, his immediate family, relatives, subordinates and close associates, whether located in the Philippines or abroad, including the takeover or sequestration of all business enterprises and entities owned or controlled by them, during his administration, directly or through nominees, by taking undue advantage of their public office and or using their powers, authority, influence, connections or relationship. (b) The investigation of such cases of graft and corruption as the President may assign to the Commission from time to time. (c) The adoption of safeguards to ensure that the above practices shall not be repeated in any manner under the new government, and the institution of adequate measures to prevent the occurrence of corruption.
Section 3 of the same Executive Order supplies the power to investigate that underlies the authority to conduct a preliminary investigation:
Section 3. The Commission shall have the power and authority: (a) To conduct investigations as may be necessary in order to accomplish and carry out the purposes of this order.
Section 1 of Executive Order Number 14 empowers the PCGG to file and prosecute the cases it investigates:
Section 1. Any provision of the law to the contrary notwithstanding, the Presidential Commission on Good Government with the assistance of the Office of the Solicitor General and other government agencies, is hereby empowered to file and prosecute all cases investigated by it under Executive Order No. 1, dated February 28, 1986 and Executive Order No. 2, dated March 12, 1986, as may be warranted by its findings.
Section 2 of the same Executive Order fixes the forum for those cases:
Section 2. The Presidential Commission on Good Government shall file all such cases, whether civil or criminal, with the Sandiganbayan, which shall have exclusive and original jurisdiction thereof.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the petitioners were mistaken. Section 15, paragraph 1, of the Ombudsman Act gave the Ombudsman primary jurisdiction over cases cognizable by the Sandiganbayan, but it did not specifically revoke the PCGG's power of investigation. Following its earlier ruling in the Cojuangco case, the Court held that the provision gave the Ombudsman concurrent authority to investigate, with the qualification that the Ombudsman may take over at any stage in the exercise of its primary jurisdiction. The Court also noted that under Section 15, paragraph 11, of the same law, the Ombudsman was vested only with the power to investigate ill-gotten wealth amassed after the twenty-fifth of February 1986, which implicitly maintained the PCGG's authority over wealth amassed before that date. The Ombudsman retains primary jurisdiction even over the earlier wealth, but it may decline to exercise it, as it did here, leaving the PCGG to conduct the preliminary investigation.
On the second issue, the Court ruled for the petitioners. It is impossible for the PCGG to possess the cold neutrality of an impartial judge when the PCGG itself gathered the evidence and filed the complaint. As the Court put it, it cannot both be a prosecutor and a judge at the same time. The Court added that the PCGG had shown marked bias when it abruptly terminated the preliminary investigation and resolved the case against the petitioners without notifying them of the adverse resolution, preventing them from seeking reconsideration or more time to file their counter-affidavits.
On the third issue, the Court again ruled for the petitioners. There was no waiver. Their failure to submit counter-affidavits was due to the pendency of their motion for clarification before the Sandiganbayan. When that motion was denied, they went to the Ombudsman, and only when the Ombudsman declined did they seek reconsideration. Throughout, they told the PCGG prosecutor that they would submit their evidence once the question of jurisdiction was finally settled.
Doctrine
First, the Ombudsman Act gave the Ombudsman primary jurisdiction over cases cognizable by the Sandiganbayan, but it did not revoke the PCGG's concurrent power to investigate ill-gotten wealth cases. The Ombudsman may take over at any stage, or may decline to exercise its primary jurisdiction, leaving the PCGG to act.
Second, a body that gathers the evidence and files the complaint cannot conduct the preliminary investigation of its own complaint. It cannot be prosecutor and judge at the same time, because it lacks the cold neutrality of an impartial judge.
Third, the right to a preliminary investigation is not waived where the accused's failure to submit counter-affidavits is attributable to a pending motion seeking clarification of jurisdiction, and the accused repeatedly manifested an intention to submit evidence once that question was resolved.
Disposition
The petition was granted; the preliminary investigation conducted by the PCGG, including the information filed in the criminal case, was declared null and void, and the PCGG was ordered to transmit the records to the Ombudsman for appropriate action, with costs de officio.
Remember This
The line to memorize is that the PCGG cannot both be prosecutor and judge at the same time, so it must yield the reinvestigation to the Ombudsman. Examiners use this case on the concurrent jurisdiction of the PCGG and the Ombudsman, and on the impartiality requirement in preliminary investigations.