🎧 Case Brief Lecture

PRAUTCH, SCHOLES & COV PLAINTIFFS AND APPELLEES, VS. DOLORES HERNANDEZ DE GOYENECHEA, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.

G.R. No. 910. February 10, 1903 February 10, 1903

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Prautch, Scholes and Company versus Hernandez de Goyenechea

The Case

This is an early Philippine decision, rendered in February 1903, on the juridical personality of a partnership. The firm of Prautch, Scholes and Company sued Dolores Hernandez de Goyenechea to enforce a claim arising from a lease. The defendant resisted on the ground that the firm, never having complied with the Code of Commerce, had no legal personality and could not sue in its firm name. The case matters because it fixes the test for distinguishing a civil partnership from a mercantile one, and because it holds that a commercial partnership which fails to record its articles cannot maintain an action in its firm name.

Procedural History

The action was brought in the Court of First Instance, which allowed the firm of Prautch, Scholes and Company, as a juridical entity, to recover. The defendant objected to that ruling and assigned it as error on appeal. The case reached the Supreme Court on a bill of exceptions. No motion for a new trial was filed in the court below. On appeal, the Supreme Court reversed the judgment and granted a new trial, with the costs of the second instance against the appellee. Justice Mapa concurred in the result, and Justice Cooper filed a dissenting opinion.

Facts

Prautch and Scholes formed a partnership engaged in the business of buying and selling cows, woods, bricks, and the products of the country. In other words, it bought personal property with the purpose of reselling it in the same form at a profit. The proofs showed that the firm never attempted to comply with any of the requirements of the Code of Commerce. It did not state its agreements in a public writing, and it did not record them in the Mercantile Registry.

The firm entered into a contract of lease with the defendant. That contract was signed by the partners as individuals, and not under any firm name. The firm later brought this action in its own name. The trial court found that Prautch had succeeded to all the rights of the firm, and allowed a recovery in the name of the firm for the sole benefit of Prautch.

On appeal, the defendant insisted that the partnership had no personality and could not sue. The plaintiff answered that the partners brought with them from the United States the law there in force on partnerships, that the defendant was estopped from denying the personality because she had dealt with the firm, and that a reversal would take away rights the partners already held.

Issues

  • Whether or not the partnership of Prautch, Scholes and Company, not having complied with the Code of Commerce, became a civil partnership and thereby acquired a juridical personality of its own.
  • Whether or not a commercial partnership which has not recorded its articles of agreement may maintain an action in its firm name.
  • Whether or not the Supreme Court may examine the evidence, absent a motion for a new trial, on the claim that there is no evidence to support a finding of fact.
  • Whether or not the finding that Prautch succeeded to all the rights of the firm is supported by the evidence.

Applicable Provisions

Article 35 of the Civil Code provides:

The corporations, associations, and institutions of public interest recognized by law. Their personality begins from the very instant in which, in accordance with law, they are validly established. The associations of private interest, be they civil, commercial, or industrial, to which the law may grant proper personality, independent of each member thereof.

This is the source of the personality claimed by the firm, and it ties personality to valid establishment in accordance with law.

Article 36 of the Civil Code provides:

The associations referred to in Number 2 of the foregoing article, shall be governed by the provisions of their articles of association, according to the nature of the latter.

This is the provision the Court applies: the governing law of the association depends on its nature, which is why the civil or mercantile character of the firm had to be settled first.

Article 24 of the Code of Commerce provides:

Articles constituting associations not recorded shall be binding between the members who execute the same but they shall not prejudice third persons, who, however, may make use thereof in so far as advantageous.

This fixes the consequence of non-recording: the unrecorded articles bind the members among themselves but do not clothe the association with personality as against third persons.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the partnership was commercial in nature, and that its failure to comply with the Code of Commerce did not convert it into a civil partnership or give it legal personality. The distinction between a civil and a mercantile partnership turns on the object to which it is devoted, not on the machinery with which it is organized. The Court said:

It is therefore the purpose which determines the character of a partnership as civil or mercantile.

Since the firm was a typical commercial partnership, it was governed by the Code of Commerce under Article 36. The Court rejected the claim that the partners carried with them the American law on partnerships, and found no estoppel, because the only contract with the defendant was signed by the partners as individuals and not under the firm name.

On the second issue, the Court held that a commercial partnership which has not recorded its articles cannot maintain an action in its firm name. Article 116 of the Code of Commerce impliedly denies personality to a partnership not organized in accordance with that Code. The Court explained the reason:

When several persons unite for a common end and desire to transact their joint business in the name of a new artificial being which they create, they should notify the public who the persons are that are responsible for the acts of this new entity.

On the third issue, the Court held that although it cannot retry questions of fact absent the exceptions in the law, whether there is any evidence to support a finding of fact is always a question of law, which it may examine and decide.

On the fourth issue, the Court held that the finding that Prautch succeeded to all the rights of the firm had no support in the evidence. The lone testimony of Prautch that he succeeded to the firm name and signature was insufficient, as a matter of law, to show an assignment of Scholes's interest.

Doctrine

A partnership is civil or mercantile according to the object to which it is devoted, not according to the form of its organization. A partnership organized for commerce remains commercial even if it fails to comply with the Code of Commerce; non-compliance does not convert it into a civil partnership. Under Article 36 of the Civil Code, such a partnership is governed by the Code of Commerce. Because Article 116 of the Code of Commerce grants personality only to partnerships organized in accordance with that Code, a commercial partnership which has not recorded its articles has no legal personality and cannot sue in its firm name. Its members may, however, sue in their individual capacity on contracts they have entered into. Finally, whether there is any evidence to support a finding of fact is a question of law that the Supreme Court may review.

Disposition

The Supreme Court reversed the judgment and granted a new trial, with the costs of the second instance against the appellee, because the firm had no legal personality and could not maintain the action in its name.

Remember This

The one line to memorize: the purpose, not the form, determines whether a partnership is civil or mercantile, and a commercial partnership that has not recorded its articles cannot sue in its firm name. Examiners use this case to test the civil versus mercantile distinction and the consequences of non-compliance with the Code of Commerce on juridical personality.