🎧 Case Brief Lecture

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. LEOPOLDO PACAPAC, NESTOR TRANGUIA, JOHN DOE AND PETER DOE, ACCUSED.  LEOPOLDO PACAPAC AND NESTOR TRANGUIA, ACCUSED-APPELLANTS.

G.R. No. 90623. September 07, 1995 September 7, 1995

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

People versus Pacapac

The Case

This is a criminal appeal by Leopoldo Pacapac and Nestor Tranguia from a judgment of conviction for the killing and robbery of a policeman in Mandaue City. The case matters for two reasons. First, it is a compact lesson on the weight of witness credibility on appeal, the treatment of minor inconsistencies, the rule on alibi, and the claim of denial of due process where the deciding judge did not hear the witnesses. Second, and more importantly for the bar, it corrects a misnomer in the charge: there is no special complex crime of robbery in band with homicide. The correct offense is robbery with homicide, and band is merely a generic aggravating circumstance.

Procedural History

Leopoldo Pacapac and Nestor Tranguia, together with two unidentified persons designated as John Doe and Peter Doe, were charged with robbery in band with homicide before the Regional Trial Court of Cebu, sitting in Mandaue City, Branch 28. Both accused pleaded not guilty, and trial followed. The trial court rendered judgment of conviction, sentencing each accused to reclusion perpetua and ordering them to pay indemnity to the heirs of the victim. The two unidentified accused were never brought before the court, and the case against them was ordered archived. Pacapac and Tranguia appealed to the Supreme Court, assigning errors on the credibility of the witnesses, the sufficiency of the evidence, the failure to establish guilt with moral certainty, and the denial of due process because the deciding judge was not the one who heard some principal witnesses.

Facts

At around nine thirty in the evening of January 17, 1986, Patrolman Rogelio Collantes was checking the family bodega of scrap metals across his house in Jagobiao, Mandaue City. His wife Flora heard breaking bottles and footsteps. She opened the window and saw a bearded man in a striped shirt and headband, later identified as Leopoldo Pacapac, holding an unconscious man with one hand and poking something at his face with the other. Two other men flanked the unconscious man. One of them, later identified as Nestor Tranguia, pointed a gun at Flora and ordered her to close the window, saying that she had nothing to do with it. She obeyed out of fear. Moments later she heard a gunshot and a shout that this was a robbery.

Flora reopened the window halfway and saw Pacapac shout to his companions to get the necklace, ring and wallet. Pacapac then knelt beside the man on the ground, took his belongings, stood up, and said that the man was very proud and haughty, which is why he killed him. The three men then left. Faustino Collantes, Jr., the victim's brother, opened the door and was met by Tranguia pointing a revolver at him and warning him not to do anything. Domingo Semblante, who heard the gunshot, went out with companions and saw Pacapac holding a nickel plated gun, warning them not to come near because they were the military. Flora later discovered that the man on the ground was her husband. The necropsy report showed that the victim died of a gunshot wound at the right roof of his mouth, with the exit wound at the back of his head.

Policemen arrived, and Patrolman Ernesto Entise, officer in charge of the homicide section, chased and intercepted a yellow car with four occupants. Its driver introduced himself as Sergeant Leopoldo Pacapac of the R-2. Entise invited him to the scene. At the scene, Faustino remained silent when asked to identify the group, and only after they had left did he tell Entise that one of them had pointed a gun at him. In a lineup held on March 13, 1986, Flora Collantes, Faustino Collantes, Jr. and Domingo Semblante separately identified Pacapac and Tranguia. Pacapac denied the charge and interposed alibi, claiming he was at Arkane International Corporation in Jagobiao and later left with companions for a wake. Tranguia presented no evidence and instead moved to dismiss on the ground of insufficiency of evidence.

Issues

  • Whether or not the trial court erred in giving credence to the testimonies of the prosecution witnesses despite the alleged inconsistencies therein.
  • Whether or not the guilt of the accused was established beyond reasonable doubt and with moral certainty.
  • Whether or not there was a denial of due process because the judge who penned the decision was not the one who heard the testimonies of some principal witnesses.
  • Whether or not the defense of alibi can prevail over the positive identification by the prosecution witnesses.
  • Whether or not the crime committed was correctly denominated as robbery in band with homicide.

Applicable Provisions

Article 293 of the Revised Penal Code defines robbery as follows:

Any person who, with intent to gain, shall take any personal property belonging to another, by means of violence against or intimidation of any person, or using force upon anything, shall be guilty of robbery.

The Court uses this definition to test whether all the elements of robbery were proven, and it holds that they were.

Article 294, paragraph 1, of the Revised Penal Code, as amended by Republic Act Number 373, provides:

Any person guilty of robbery with the use of violence against or intimidation of any person shall suffer the penalty of reclusion perpetua to death, when by reason or on occasion of the robbery, the crime of homicide shall have been committed.

This is the provision under which the Court ultimately classifies the offense and fixes the penalty.

Article 296 of the Revised Penal Code provides:

When more than three armed malefactors shall have acted together in the commission of an offense, it shall be deemed to have been committed by a band.

The Court cites this to explain why band requires at least four armed persons, a fact the prosecution failed to establish indubitably.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court holds that the core question is factual and concerns the credibility of witnesses, a matter best left to the trial court. Its findings are entitled to the highest degree of respect and will not be disturbed absent a clear showing that it overlooked, misunderstood or misapplied facts of weight and substance. The alleged inconsistencies were minor. It was not impossible for Pacapac to order his companions to take the valuables and also to divest the victim himself, since one companion had fled and the other was pointing a gun at someone. Witnesses may differ in their recollections without being disbelieved. The apparent contradiction on whether the necklace was missing was a first impression later corrected when the necklace was found under the victim's shirt. The Court also holds that the maxim falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus, meaning false in one thing, false in everything, is not a categorical test of credibility and is not mandatory. Inconsistencies on minor details do not destroy credibility; they may even enhance it as signs of honest and unrehearsed responses.

On the conduct of Patrolman Entise, the Court finds his explanation well taken. Faustino did not point to anyone at the scene, the group could easily be summoned later since one of them was known to Entise, and Entise was apprehensive that trouble might arise at the scene since the group was armed and many persons, including the mayor, were present. The initial reluctance of witnesses to volunteer information out of fear of reprisal does not affect credibility, nor does the relationship of the witnesses to the victim. No motive to testify falsely was shown.

On the second issue, the Court holds that alibi is a weak defense and cannot prevail over positive identification by witnesses with no motive to testify falsely. For alibi to prosper, the accused must show that he was at some other place for such a period of time that it was physically impossible for him to have been at the scene at the time of the crime. Here, the place where the appellants claimed to have been was only a few hundred meters from the scene. The evidence produced moral certainty as to their guilt.

On the third issue, the Court holds that while the judge who conducted the hearing is in a better position to ascertain the truth, it does not follow that a judge who was not present during the trial cannot render a valid and just decision, since the latter can rely on the transcribed stenographic notes.

On the fifth issue, the Court corrects the denomination of the crime. There is no special complex crime of robbery in band with homicide. If robbery with homicide is committed by a band, the offense is still robbery with homicide under Article 294, paragraph 1, and band is merely a generic aggravating circumstance. The crime committed is therefore the special complex crime of robbery with homicide. The victim was shot before he was robbed, and in robbery with homicide the killing may precede or follow the robbery, so long as there is a direct relation and intimate connection between them. All who took part as principals in the robbery are also guilty as principals of the special complex crime although they did not actually take part in the homicide, unless they clearly endeavored to prevent it. Since the prosecution failed to show that more than three armed persons perpetrated the crime, and the aggravating circumstances of treachery, use of motor vehicle and taking advantage of superior strength were not satisfactorily proven, the proper penalty is reclusion perpetua.

Doctrine

There is no special complex crime of robbery in band with homicide. The indictable offense is robbery with homicide under Article 294, paragraph 1, of the Revised Penal Code, and band under Article 296 is not an element but a generic aggravating circumstance that may be offset by mitigating circumstances. In robbery with homicide, the homicide may precede or follow the robbery, so long as there is a direct relation and intimate connection between the two. All principals in the robbery are liable for the special complex crime even if they did not take part in the killing, unless they clearly endeavored to prevent it. Alibi cannot prevail over positive identification, and it fails where the accused was only a few hundred meters from the scene. Minor inconsistencies in witness testimony do not destroy credibility, and the maxim falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus, false in one thing, false in everything, is not a mandatory rule. A judge who did not hear the witnesses may validly decide the case on the stenographic notes.

Disposition

The Supreme Court affirmed the conviction but modified it, holding that the crime is robbery with homicide and ordering the appellants to pay jointly and severally to the heirs of Patrolman Rogelio Collantes civil indemnity of 50,000 pesos and 9,000 pesos representing the value of the ring and money stolen.

Remember This

Memorize this line: there is no special complex crime of robbery in band with homicide; the crime is robbery with homicide, and band is only a generic aggravating circumstance. Examiners use this case to test the correct denomination of the offense and the rule that all principals in the robbery answer for the killing even if they did not take part in it.