🎧 Case Brief Lecture

SEABORNE CARRIERS CORPORATION AND JERRY RONALDO GATAN, PETITIONERS, VS. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION AND ARMANDO A. TERNIDA, RESPONDENTS.

G.R. No. 88795. October 04, 1994 October 4, 1994

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Seaborne Carriers versus National Labor Relations Commission

The Case

This is a petition brought by Seaborne Carriers Corporation and its president and manager, Jerry Ronaldo Gatan, against the National Labor Relations Commission and the dismissed employee Armando Ternida. The company asks the Supreme Court to set aside the Commission's award of service incentive leave, holiday pay, thirteenth month pay, and attorney's fees, and to relieve Gatan of personal liability for those awards. The case matters because it settles two working rules every labor lawyer must know: that an employee's claim of non-payment of statutory benefits is a negative allegation that the employer must disprove, and that a corporate officer is personally liable to a dismissed employee only upon proof of evident malice and bad faith.

Procedural History

Ternida filed a complaint for illegal dismissal, illegal deduction, and unpaid wages before the labor arbiter, later amending it to include Gatan as party-respondent and to add claims for overtime pay, holiday pay, thirteenth month pay, sick leave pay, damages, and attorney's fees. Labor Arbiter Eduardo Magno rendered judgment declaring the dismissal illegal, ordering reinstatement without loss of seniority rights but without backwages, and ordering payment of the two hundred fifty pesos illegally deducted. Ternida appealed to the National Labor Relations Commission, which modified the ruling by granting full backwages from the date his salary was withheld until actual reinstatement, plus holiday pay, thirteenth month pay, service incentive leave benefits for 1987 and 1988, the amount illegally deducted, and attorney's fees of ten percent of the total award. The Commission denied the company's two motions for reconsideration for lack of merit. The company then came to the Supreme Court by petition, raising only two grounds.

Facts

Ternida began working for Seaborne Carriers Corporation on April 8, 1983 as Tug Master, with a monthly salary of two thousand four hundred seventy five pesos. On September 15, 1987, the tugboat he was manning met an accident. The cost of repairs totalled five thousand pesos; the company shouldered half, and required Ternida to pay the other half. An initial salary deduction of two hundred fifty pesos was actually made.

On September 24, 1987, Ternida sought permission to go on leave of absence so he could ask the Department of Labor and Employment whether the deduction was legal, but the request was not granted. Instead, Gatan, the company's president and manager, asked him to tender his resignation. Ternida refused, because he had not yet received any separation pay, and he was then dismissed.

He filed his complaint, which was later amended to include Gatan and to embrace additional money claims. The labor arbiter and the Commission ruled in his favor, and the company brought the matter to the Supreme Court.

Issues

  • Whether or not the private respondent is entitled to service incentive leave benefits, holiday pay, and thirteenth month pay, even though these were not specifically proven and service incentive leave was not originally pleaded.
  • Whether or not petitioner Jerry Ronaldo Gatan, as president and general manager of Seaborne, may be held personally liable with the corporation for the payment of backwages and other monetary benefits awarded by the Commission.

Applicable Provisions

Article 95 of the Labor Code, on service incentive leave, is the provision the petitioners invoke against the award:

Every employer shall grant to all his employees who have rendered at least one year of service, whether continuous or broken, a yearly service incentive leave of five days with pay.

The Court treats this as a statutory benefit, so the employer's claim that vacation leave already enjoyed bars it does not persuade; the benefit is mandated by law.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the arguments of the petitioners are untenable. Ternida's allegation of non-payment of benefits to which he is by law entitled is a negative allegation which need not be supported by evidence unless it is an essential part of the cause of action. His main cause of action was illegal dismissal, and the claim for monetary benefits was but an incident of his protest against that dismissal. Thus, the burden of proving that payment of the said benefits had been made rests upon the party who will suffer if no evidence at all is presented by either party, that is, the petitioners as employer. The Court also rejected the argument that service incentive leave could not be awarded because it was not sought in the complaint and because Ternida already enjoyed vacation leave benefits.

On the second issue, the Court ruled for Gatan. The petitioners relied on the rule that the personal liability of corporate officers to dismissed employees depends on whether such officers acted with evident malice and bad faith. The Court found this contention meritorious, because the assailed decision made no finding that Gatan acted maliciously or in bad faith. All the evidence showed was that Gatan ordered Ternida to resign and dismissed him when he refused, without considering the reason for the refusal, which was the non-payment of separation pay. Nothing on record proved that Gatan sanctioned the deduction of two hundred fifty pesos or the denial of the leave of absence. These factors were simply not sufficient to convince the Court that Gatan acted with malice and in bad faith in terminating the employment. In this regard only, the decision of the Commission was modified.

Doctrine

First, an employee's claim that statutory benefits were not paid is a negative allegation that need not be supported by evidence unless it is an essential part of the cause of action; the burden of proving payment rests on the employer, who suffers if no evidence at all is presented. Second, the personal liability of a corporate officer to a dismissed employee depends on whether the officer acted with evident malice and bad faith; the officer's mere act of ordering a resignation and carrying out the dismissal, without more, does not establish that malice and bad faith. Third, service incentive leave under Article 95 of the Labor Code is a statutory benefit, and the employer bears the burden of showing it was granted.

Disposition

The petition was dismissed and the liability of Seaborne Carriers Corporation to Ternida was affirmed, but Jerry Ronaldo Gatan was exempted from that liability for lack of material proof of his culpability, and the records were remanded to the Commission for immediate execution of judgment.

Remember This

Memorize this line: the personal liability of a corporate officer to a dismissed employee requires evident malice and bad faith, and the employer carries the burden of proving that statutory benefits were paid. Examiners use this case to test the negative-allegation rule on money claims and the personal liability of corporate officers in illegal dismissal cases.