THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. BENIGNO DE VERA, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
United States versus De Vera
The Case
This is a criminal appeal from a conviction for abduction. The Government of the United States, as complainant and appellee, prosecuted Benigno de Vera, the defendant and appellant, for carrying off a young woman against her will and with lewd intent. The case matters to a reviewee for two reasons. First, it fixes the elements of the crime of abduction under the old Penal Code: taking a woman against her will, and doing so with a lewd design. Second, and more importantly for procedure, it settles that the crime of abduction may be prosecuted on the initiative of the public prosecutor, and that no formal written denunciation by the offended party is required to begin the case. It is an early decision of the Supreme Court under the new American sovereignty, applying the Spanish Penal Code that remained in force.
Procedural History
The case began in the Court of First Instance of Pangasinan, where an information for abduction was filed by the provincial fiscal. After trial, the court below rendered judgment on the twentieth of January, 1902, convicting the defendant of abduction and sentencing him to seventeen years, four months, and one day of imprisonment with hard labor, with the corresponding accessories, and to pay the costs. The defendant appealed that judgment to the Supreme Court. The appeal was heard by the Court en banc, with Justice Torres writing the opinion and Chief Justice Arellano and Justices Cooper, Willard, and Ladd concurring. Justice Mapa did not sit in the case.
Facts
After ten o'clock one night in the year 1900, the exact day and month being unknown, Benigno de Vera and several other men, all provided with arms, went to the house of Rosa Magalon. De Vera immediately entered the house and seized Severina de Guzman, a girl some eighteen years of age and the daughter of the owner of the house.
Notwithstanding her opposition, and her attempt to cling to her mother, he forcibly carried her off against her will and took her out of the house. In the struggle he struck the girl's mother a blow in the chest, upon which she fled from the house. The three women living in the house were unable to call for assistance or to prevent the aggression, as they were overcome with fear.
The abducted girl was placed on horseback by De Vera and taken to his house at a place called Bagnat, where she was held for three days and, by threats, compelled to accede to his lewd desires. This continued until Mariano Gonzalez, accompanied by several other men, came to the house and, notwithstanding the opposition of the defendant, succeeded in recovering the girl and restoring her to her mother's house.
Issues
- Whether or not the evidence is sufficient to establish the guilt of the defendant for the crime of abduction, notwithstanding his plea of not guilty.
- Whether or not the aggravating circumstances of nocturnity and commission in the dwelling of the offended party may be appreciated against the defendant.
- Whether or not the proceedings should be dismissed on the ground that the prosecution was commenced without the express solicitation or instance of the offended party.
Applicable Provisions
Article 445 of the Penal Code, which defines the crime charged, provides:
The abduction of a woman against her will, and with a lewd intent, is punishable as abduction.
This is the provision under which the defendant was convicted, and it supplies the two elements the Court applies: taking against the will, and lewd intent.
Article 448 of the Penal Code, on the form of denunciation, provides:
It is not necessary that a formal petition be filed by the offended party in order that the crime of abduction may be prosecuted.
This provision answers the defendant's motion to dismiss, because it expressly dispenses with a formal written denunciation as a condition for prosecution.
Number 15 of article 10 of the Penal Code, on nocturnity, provides:
To take advantage of the darkness of night is an aggravating circumstance.
The Court applies this because the defendant availed himself of the darkness and silence of night to consummate the crime.
Number 20 of article 10 of the Penal Code, on the place of the crime, provides:
To commit the crime in the dwelling of the offended person is an aggravating circumstance.
The Court applies this because the abduction was carried out inside the house of the offended party's mother.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the evidence is sufficient to establish guilt. The commission of the offense was fully proven by the testimony of the injured party, of her mother, and of another woman who lived with them in the house, all of whom uniformly testified to the occurrence in all its details. The defendant, who was present when the prosecuting witness testified and heard each witness for the prosecution, never contradicted the evidence, never alleged any exculpation, and made no attempt to show his innocence.
On the second issue, the Court appreciated both aggravating circumstances. Nocturnity under Number 15 of article 10 was considered because the defendant availed himself of the darkness and silence of night for the consummation of the crime. The circumstance of committing the crime in the dwelling of the offended person under Number 20 of article 10 was likewise applied. The Court then held that this second circumstance is compensated in its effects by article 11 as a mitigating circumstance, in view of the nature of the crime, the disturbed condition of the country at the time the abduction took place, and the personal conditions of the defendant. Because of these circumstances, the penalty assigned by law was imposed in its maximum degree.
On the third issue, the Court refused to dismiss the proceedings. It reasoned from the object and purpose of the penal law, which does not require a formal written denunciation as a basis for prosecuting abduction. The Court pointed to article 448 of the Code, which expressly declares that a formal petition is not necessary. Here, the provincial fiscal filed the information by virtue of the complaint made to him by the complaining witness, who, together with her mother, sustained and confirmed during the trial the action brought by the fiscal in the name of the Government. There was therefore no legal ground to set the proceedings aside.
Doctrine
Abduction, under article 445 of the Penal Code, is committed when a woman is taken against her will and with a lewd intent. Both elements must concur, and the taking must be forcible and against the will of the victim.
The crime of abduction may be prosecuted by the public prosecutor on his own initiative. No formal written denunciation or express solicitation by the offended party is required, because article 448 of the Penal Code expressly dispenses with that formality. A complaint made to the fiscal, later sustained and confirmed by the offended party at trial, is sufficient to support the information.
Nocturnity under Number 15 of article 10, and commission of the crime in the dwelling of the offended person under Number 20 of article 10, are aggravating circumstances that may be appreciated where the evidence shows the offender took advantage of the darkness of night and carried out the crime inside the victim's home.
Disposition
The Court reversed the judgment of the court below and convicted Benigno de Vera, sentencing him to seventeen years, four months, and one day of reclusion temporal, with the accessories designated in article 59, to indemnify the girl Guzman in the amount of 500 Mexican pesos as a dowry, to acknowledge and support any issue, and to pay the costs of both instances.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing is that abduction may be prosecuted without a formal written denunciation by the offended party, because article 448 of the Penal Code expressly says so. Examiners like to use this case to test the elements of abduction and the rule that the fiscal may initiate the prosecution on a complaint later confirmed by the victim at trial.