🎧 Case Brief Lecture

THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. ADRIANO SOLAR, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.

G.R. No. 886. September 09, 1902 September 9, 1902

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

United States versus Solar

The Case

This is a criminal appeal from a conviction for the crime of attempt to rape. The United States prosecuted Adriano Solar, and he was convicted in the Court of First Instance of the Province of Pangasinan. The case matters because the Supreme Court here isolates the mental element of the crime — the intent to have carnal knowledge of a woman against her will — and holds that proof of a violent assault, without more, cannot supply that intent beyond reasonable doubt. It is an early and enduring lesson on the sufficiency of evidence in crimes against chastity.

Procedural History

Adriano Solar was tried and convicted in the Court of First Instance of the Province of Pangasinan of the crime of attempt to rape. He was sentenced to four years and two months of imprisonment in the public prison of the province, with costs. He appealed to the Supreme Court, and the only question raised by his appeal was the sufficiency of the evidence upon which his conviction was secured.

Facts

About ten o'clock in the morning of the fifteenth of November, nineteen hundred and one, Adriano Solar, with a knife in his hands, entered the house where Juliana Perez then was. He seized her hands, attempted to embrace her, and tried to throw her to the floor. All of this took place near an open window of the house and in the actual presence of Aniceta Solar, the aunt of Adriano Solar, and Potenciana Salcedo, the aunt of Juliana Perez. The accused said nothing from the time he entered the house and began the assault until he left it, after the complainant, with the aid of the other two women, had freed herself from him. The complainant claimed that she received injuries about the head and breast caused by the knife, from which she said she recovered in about a week.

The only witness for the defense was the accused himself. He testified that he lived in the same house as his accuser, and that she is the daughter of Antonio Perez and one Petra Salinas, who was the concubine of his father. He said that on the morning in question he went to the house and, in the presence of Tomas Tirao, Maxima his wife, and Aniceta Solar, ordered Juliana Perez to leave the house because she and her mother had stolen certain documents and money from him and had tried to bribe a man named Pedro to kill him. He denied inflicting any violence on the complainant, and said that she denounced him to the court in revenge for being ordered from the house. Neither Pedro, nor Tomas Tirao, nor his wife were produced as witnesses.

Issues

  • Whether or not the evidence is sufficient to establish beyond reasonable doubt the intent to have carnal knowledge of the complainant against her will, which is an essential element of the crime of attempt to rape.
  • Whether or not the acts of seizing the complainant's hands, embracing her, and attempting to throw her to the floor, standing alone, raise a sufficient inference of intent to rape.

Applicable Provisions

The decision does not quote any statutory provision. It states the elements of the crime as a matter of law, and that statement governs the case:

One of the essential elements of the crime of "attempt to rape" is the intent to have carnal knowledge of a woman against her will, and in despite of any resistance she may make.

This formulation fixes the mental element the prosecution had to prove beyond reasonable doubt, and it is the standard against which the evidence in this case was measured.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that if the element of intent is wanting, or if the prosecution fails to establish it by competent evidence beyond reasonable doubt, the charge is not made out and no conviction on it can be had. The evidence showed that an assault was committed, but hardly went to the extent of establishing that it was committed with the intent to rape. As the Court put it:

There is no, act, word, or deed which satisfactorily shows beyond a reasonable doubt that the accused sought to have criminal knowledge of the person of the complaining witness or that his design was any other than the infliction on her of physical violence or bodily harm.

On the second issue, the Court held that any inference or presumption of intent to violate the complainant which might be drawn from the fact that he seized her hands, put his arms about her, and attempted to throw her on the floor is overcome by the circumstances of the assault. Those acts of violence were perpetrated in broad daylight, near an open window, in the presence of close relatives of both parties. The Court reasoned that crimes against the chastity of women are not usually committed in the presence of persons not aiding and abetting the offense, and much less in the immediate personal presence of kinswomen whose active opposition might reasonably be expected. The evidence being insufficient to support the charge, the judgment based on it ought to be reversed.

Doctrine

In a prosecution for attempt to rape, the intent to have carnal knowledge of the woman against her will is an essential element, and it must be proved by competent evidence beyond reasonable doubt. Where the prosecution fails to establish that intent, the charge is not made out and no conviction can be had. An inference of intent to rape drawn from acts of seizing, embracing, and attempting to throw the complainant to the floor is overcome where those acts are committed in broad daylight, near an open window, and in the presence of close relatives of both parties, since crimes against chastity are not usually committed before persons not aiding the offense, and much less before kinswomen whose active opposition may reasonably be expected. The rule a bar candidate should retain is that proof of physical violence or bodily harm does not, by itself, prove the specific intent required for the crime.

Disposition

The Court reversed the judgment of conviction, with costs de oficio, and the accused was acquitted.

Remember This

Memorize this line: an assault is not an attempt to rape unless the intent to have carnal knowledge against the woman's will is shown beyond reasonable doubt. Examiners use this case to test the element of intent in frustrated and attempted crimes against chastity, and the weight given to the surrounding circumstances in drawing inferences of intent.