THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. JOHN H. FLEMISTER, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
United States versus Flemister
The Case
This is a criminal case in which the Government of the United States, as complainant and appellee, prosecuted John H. Flemister, the defendant and appellant, for the offense known in the old Penal Code as allanamiento de morada — in plain English, the unlawful entry into another person's dwelling against the will of the owner. The case matters to a reviewee because the Supreme Court draws a sharp and memorable line: the owner of a house who takes a guest by the hand, asks whether he has come to dance, and invites him to be seated is not prohibiting him from entering the house at all. The decision is a lesson in reading the elements of a crime strictly against the evidence, and in refusing to convict on facts that are reprehensible but do not fit the offense charged.
Procedural History
The defendant was tried in the court below and convicted of the offense of allanamiento de morada. From that judgment of conviction he appealed to the Supreme Court of the Philippine Islands. The Supreme Court, speaking through Justice Willard, reviewed the evidence and reversed the judgment of conviction, acquitting the defendant, with the costs of both instances de oficio, that is, at public expense.
Facts
On the evening of November 28, 1901, Don Teodoro Suller gave a ball at his house in the pueblo of Cabuyau. The defendant went to the ball without any invitation from the owner, danced with an American doctor, and then went away. He returned after a short time.
What then occurred was described by Don Teodoro himself. He met the defendant almost at the door of the stairway, took him by the hand, and said, "Friend, what do you wish; do you come to dance?" Without making any answer, the defendant roughly withdrew his hand and struck Don Teodoro, so that he fell. Don Teodoro also testified that he had heard the defendant had some design of attacking Captain Davison, who was in the sala, and that he stopped the defendant because he was attempting to enter that apartment. The witness Ramos likewise testified that the owner of the house attempted to stop the defendant as he was entering the sala.
The defendant admitted that he struck Don Teodoro so that he fell, and that he had a quarrel with Captain Davison, in which he drew his revolver. The Court found the conduct of the defendant extremely reprehensible, and the efforts of the owner to prevent the meeting praiseworthy. Yet the Court held that, under the evidence, the defendant could not be convicted of the offense of allanamiento de morada.
Issues
- Whether or not the defendant committed the offense of allanamiento de morada, that is, unlawful entry into the dwelling of another against the will of the owner, when the owner's acts showed he was barring the defendant not from the house but from the sala.
- Whether or not the defendant's reprehensible conduct in striking the owner and drawing a revolver on Captain Davison could sustain a conviction for that specific offense.
Applicable Provisions
The decision does not quote the text of the Penal Code; it names and applies the offense of allanamiento de morada, which requires entry into the dwelling of another against the will of the owner. The Court's reasoning turns on that element of the owner's will, as the passages below show.
"It seems clear to us that the purpose of the owner of the house was to prohibit the defendant not from entering his house but from entering the sala in order to avoid a quarrel between the two Americans."
This passage fixes the element of the owner's will: the prohibition must be against entering the house, and here it was directed only at the sala.
"His taking the defendant by the hand, asking him if he came to dance, and requesting him to be seated, are inconsistent with the idea that he was attempting to keep the defendant from entering the house."
This passage shows why the evidence negates the very element the offense requires.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the defendant did not commit allanamiento de morada. The purpose of the owner was to prohibit the defendant not from entering his house but from entering the sala, in order to avoid a quarrel between the two Americans. The owner's taking the defendant by the hand, asking if he came to dance, and requesting him to be seated were inconsistent with any attempt to keep him from entering the house. The element of entry against the owner's will was therefore absent.
On the second issue, the Court acknowledged that the owner's efforts to prevent the meeting were praiseworthy and the defendant's conduct extremely reprehensible. Nevertheless, it held that the defendant could not, under the evidence, be convicted of the offense of allanamiento de morada. Reprehensible conduct alone does not supply an element that the evidence negates. The Court found it unnecessary to consider the other questions argued by counsel for the defendant.
Doctrine
For the Bar candidate, the rule is this: in allanamiento de morada, the entry into the dwelling of another must be against the will of the owner, and that will must be directed at entry into the house itself. Where the owner's acts — taking the guest by the hand, asking whether he came to dance, and inviting him to be seated — show that he was excluding the guest only from a particular room and not from the house, the element of entry against the owner's will is not established, and conviction cannot follow. A person may be guilty of grave misconduct and still not be guilty of the offense charged; the prosecution must prove every element of the specific crime, and a court will not stretch the facts to fit the label.
Disposition
The Supreme Court reversed the judgment of conviction and acquitted the defendant, with the costs of both instances de oficio.
Remember This
Memorize the line that the owner's purpose was to prohibit the defendant not from entering his house but from entering the sala — the will of the owner must be against entry into the house, not merely a room. Examiners use this case to test the elements of allanamiento de morada and the principle that reprehensible conduct is not enough where an essential element of the offense is absent.