THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. BENIGNO PASCUA ET AL., DEFENDANTS AND APPELLANTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
United States versus Pascua
The Case
This is a criminal appeal from the Court of First Instance of the Province of Ilocos Norte, in which the Government of the United States, as complainant, prosecuted Benigno Pascua and several others for a violent nighttime attack on a private citizen. The accused were charged with serious physical injuries, arson, and robbery, arising from an incident in which they went to the house of Sexto Rubio pretending to be policemen, shot and wounded him, burned his house, and carried off his goats. The case matters to a reviewee for three reasons: it illustrates the rule against convicting an accused of an offense not charged in the complaint, it shows how the aggravating circumstances of nighttime and entry into a dwelling are appreciated, and it states the standard for the defense of alibi against positive identification by eyewitnesses. It also addresses the requisites for amnesty under the proclamation of the President.
Procedural History
The defendants were charged in the Court of First Instance of the Province of Ilocos Norte with lesiones graves, arson, and robbery. The trial judge dismissed the charges of robbery and arson and placed the defendants on trial instead for the offense of discharging firearms and for lesiones graves. After trial, four of the accused — Benigno Pascua, Remigio Quimangan, Bernardino Gampona, and Juan Baldivino — were found guilty of lesiones graves and of discharging firearms at the injured party, and each was sentenced to four years and two months of prision correccional, with its accessories, and to pay the injured party 67 pesos and 50 cents. The accused Roman Agapay was acquitted. The convicted defendants appealed to the Supreme Court, and they also applied for discharge under the amnesty proclamation of the President dated the fourth of July, 1902.
Facts
At about twelve o'clock at night on the twenty-seventh of December, 1900, the accused went to the house of Sexto Rubio. They claimed to be policemen acting under the authority of the local president of the town of Aring, with orders to take Rubio before the president. When Rubio replied that he could not go at that hour, the accused shot him with a revolver in the left foot and struck him several blows on the head with a bolo. They then set fire to his house, burning it, and left, carrying off three goats belonging to him.
At trial, the complainant and his wife testified directly and positively, identifying the accused as the persons who committed the acts. They had known the accused for a number of years, the accused lived in the same town, and the witnesses fully identified them as the persons who came to the house that night. Sexto Rubio testified that Benigno Pascua fired seven shots at him with a revolver, wounding him on the left foot and incapacitating him for nine months; that Juan Baldivino fired three shots from a Remington rifle, one striking him on the right foot and causing a slight wound cured in two days; that Remigio Quimangan gave him three blows on the head with a bolo, causing three wounds from which he recovered in nine months; that Melchor Mangobo inflicted two wounds by kicking him; and that Bernardino Gampona set fire to the house while Pascua and Baldivino were discharging their firearms.
The defense was alibi for each of the accused. The proof of alibi was well supported by the testimony of witnesses, but the Court held that such proof can have little weight when the identity of the defendants as the persons who committed the offense has been fully established by eyewitnesses. On the amnesty application, the record showed that the defendants were members of the insurgent army and that no motive for the offense was shown, but there was an entire absence of proof that the acts were the result of political dissensions or disturbances.
Issues
- Whether or not the trial court erred in convicting the defendants of the offense of discharging firearms at the person of another when that offense was not charged in the complaint.
- Whether or not the defendants may be discharged under the amnesty proclamation of the President of the fourth of July, 1902.
- Whether or not the aggravating circumstances of nighttime and entry into the dwelling of the offended party attended the commission of the crime.
- Whether or not the defense of alibi can prevail against the positive identification of the defendants by eyewitnesses.
Applicable Provisions
Article 416 of the Penal Code, as applied by the Court for the crime of lesiones graves, provides:
The penalty of prision correccional in its minimum and medium degrees shall be imposed upon any person who shall cause another serious physical injury which shall incapacitate him for his usual occupation for a period of more than ninety days.
This is the provision under which the Court ultimately convicted the four accused, the wounds having disabled the complainant from his usual occupation for more than ninety days.
Article 408 of the Penal Code, under which the trial court also convicted the defendants for discharging firearms, provides:
The penalty of arresto mayor in its maximum degree to prision correccional in its minimum degree shall be imposed upon any person who shall discharge any firearm at the person of another.
The Court held that this offense could not be the basis of conviction because it was not alleged in the complaint.
Article 10, numbers 15 and 20, of the Penal Code, on aggravating circumstances, provides:
That the act was committed at nighttime, or in an uninhabited place, or by a band, whenever such circumstances may facilitate the commission of the offense.
That the act was committed in the dwelling of the offended party, if the latter has not given provocation.
The Court found both circumstances present, since the defendants entered the house of the complainant in the nighttime for the purpose of committing the crime.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the trial court erred in convicting the defendants of discharging firearms at the person of another, because the complaint did not charge that offense. The judgment of the court below was therefore reversed as to that conviction. The Court explained that the conviction had been based on article 408 and article 416, in connection with article 89, presenting a case in which a single act constitutes two or more crimes and the penalty of the more serious crime is imposed in its maximum degree; but since the complaint did not charge the offense of discharging firearms, the conviction for it could not stand.
On the second issue, the Court denied the motion for amnesty. Although the record showed that the defendants were members of the insurgent army and no motive for the offense appeared, there was an entire absence of proof that the acts were the result of political dissensions or disturbances. The Court noted that the defendants would still have the opportunity of applying to the Civil Governor for pardon and of presenting such proofs as they might have in support of an application for discharge under the amnesty proclamation.
On the third issue, the Court found that the aggravating circumstances numbered 15 and 20 of article 10 of the Penal Code were present, inasmuch as the defendants entered the house of the complainant in the nighttime for that purpose.
On the fourth issue, the Court held that the defense of alibi, though well supported by the testimony of witnesses, could have little weight when the identity of the defendants as the persons who committed the offense had been fully established by eyewitnesses. The testimony of the complainant and his wife was direct and positive, and they had known the defendants for years and lived in the same town.
Accordingly, the Court convicted Remigio Quimangan, Benigno Pascua, Bernardino Gampona, and Juan Baldivino of the crime of lesiones graves, punishable under article 416, section 3, of the Code, for the wounds inflicted upon the complainant by which he was ill and disabled from his usual occupation for a period of more than ninety days.
Doctrine
An accused may be convicted only of the offense charged in the complaint or information. A conviction for an offense not alleged in the complaint, such as discharging firearms at the person of another, is erroneous and must be reversed on appeal.
Amnesty under a proclamation of the President requires proof that the acts charged were the result of political dissensions or disturbances. The mere fact that the accused were members of the insurgent army, without more, does not entitle them to the benefit of the amnesty proclamation.
The aggravating circumstances of nighttime and of committing the act in the dwelling of the offended party are appreciated when the offenders enter the house of the complainant at night for the purpose of committing the crime.
The defense of alibi cannot prevail against the positive identification of the accused by eyewitnesses who have known them for years and who testify directly and positively as to their identity.
Disposition
The judgment of the court below was reversed as to the conviction for discharging firearms, and the four accused were convicted of lesiones graves and each sentenced to four years and two months of prision correccional in its maximum degree, with the corresponding accessory penalties, to pay the injured party 67 pesos and 50 cents, Mexican, jointly and severally, with subsidiary imprisonment in case of insolvency, and to one-fourth part of the costs each; the motion for amnesty was denied.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing is that no accused may be convicted of an offense not charged in the complaint, and that alibi yields to positive identification by credible eyewitnesses. Examiners like to use this case to test the rule on conviction for an offense not alleged in the information and the requisites for amnesty under a presidential proclamation.