🎧 Case Brief Lecture

SPS. THELMA R. MASINSIN AND MIGUEL MASINSIN, SPS. GILBERTO AND ADELINA ROLDAN, PETITIONERS, VS. THE HON. ED VINCENT ALBANO, PRESIDING JUDGE OF THE METROPOLITAN TRIAL COURT OF MA…

G.R. No. 86421. May 31, 1994 May 31, 1994

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Masinsin versus Albano

The Case

This is a petition filed with the Supreme Court by the spouses Thelma and Miguel Masinsin, together with the spouses Gilberto and Adelina Roldan, against Judge Ed Vincent Albano, the presiding judge of the Metropolitan Trial Court of Manila, and against the private respondent Vicente Cañeda. The petitioners ask the Court to stop the Metropolitan Trial Court from enforcing a final judgment of ejectment. The case matters because it shows how the Supreme Court treats litigants and lawyers who file one petition after another to delay the execution of a decision that has long become final, and it reminds us of the binding force of the lawyer's oath.

Procedural History

The private respondent filed an ejectment suit before the Metropolitan Trial Court of Manila, Branch Ten. After trial, the trial court rendered judgment against the petitioners. No appeal was taken, and the judgment became final and executory. The petitioners then filed a petition for certiorari before the Regional Trial Court of Manila, Branch Thirty-Two, seeking to annul the ejectment decision and to set aside the order of execution. That petition was dismissed, and again no appeal was taken.

The petitioners next filed a complaint for annulment of judgment, lease contract and damages before the Regional Trial Court of Manila, Branch Forty-One. That complaint was dismissed on the ground of res judicata. The petitioners appealed to the Court of Appeals, which affirmed the dismissal. Their recourse to the Supreme Court was denied, and an entry of judgment was made. The records were remanded to the Metropolitan Trial Court for execution, and when the petitioners refused to remove their house, an order of demolition was issued.

Before the demolition could be completed, the Regional Trial Court of Manila, Branch Nineteen, issued a restraining order upon a petition filed by the petitioners, but that court later dismissed the petition. The petitioners then filed another petition for certiorari, preliminary injunction and declaratory relief before the Regional Trial Court of Manila, Branch Twenty-Five, which also issued a restraining order. That petition was ultimately dismissed. It is from these events that the petitioners came to the Supreme Court by petition for certiorari, prohibition, relief from judgment and declaratory relief.

Facts

The private respondent Vicente Cañeda sued the petitioners for ejectment before the Metropolitan Trial Court of Manila. On the first of July, 1985, the trial court rendered judgment ordering the petitioners and all persons claiming right under them to vacate the premises, to remove their house or apartment, and to surrender possession of the land to the private respondent. The judgment also ordered them to pay one hundred pesos a month from January 1987 as reasonable compensation for the use and occupation of the premises until the land is actually vacated, plus the costs of suit.

No appeal was taken from that judgment, so it became final and executory. Instead of complying, the petitioners filed a series of petitions and complaints before different branches of the Regional Trial Court and the Court of Appeals, all seeking to nullify the same ejectment decision. Each was dismissed. When the records were returned to the Metropolitan Trial Court for execution, the petitioners refused to remove their house, and an order of demolition was issued.

In this petition, the petitioners contend that the Metropolitan Trial Court lost jurisdiction to enforce its decision when the property was proclaimed an area for priority development by the National Housing Authority on the first of December, 1987, by authority of Presidential Decree Number 2016.

Issues

  • Whether or not the Metropolitan Trial Court of Manila lost jurisdiction to enforce its final judgment of ejectment when the property was proclaimed an area for priority development.
  • Whether or not the petitioners and their counsel should be sanctioned for filing repeated petitions to delay the execution of a final judgment.

Applicable Provisions

The decision quotes the lawyer's oath, which every lawyer takes upon admission to the Bar:

I will do no falsehood nor consent to its commission; I will not wittingly or willingly promote or sue any groundless, false or unlawful suit nor give aid nor consent to the same; I will not delay any man's cause for money or malice and will conduct myself as a lawyer according to the best of my knowledge and discretion with all good fidelity as well to the courts as to my clients and I impose upon myself this obligation voluntary, without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion.

This oath bears on the case because the Court found that the petitioners, through their counsel, repeatedly filed groundless suits to delay the execution of a final judgment, in violation of the pledge not to promote groundless suits and not to delay any man's cause.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the petition is totally without merit. The Court referred to its earlier resolution in a related case, where it had already ruled on the effect of the urban land reform laws and the proclamation of the area as an area for priority development. In that earlier resolution, the National Housing Authority reported that the lot in question was not for acquisition by the Authority, and that the site was under the administration of the Presidential Commission on Urban Poor for acquisition and upgrading. The Court therefore found that the proclamation did not deprive the Metropolitan Trial Court of its jurisdiction to enforce a judgment that had long become final and executory.

On the second issue, the Court observed that the petitioners, with the assistance of counsel, tried four times to nullify the same decision before different branches of the court, trifling with judicial processes. The Court stressed that the lawyer's oath is not a mere fictile of words, drift and hollow, but a sacred trust that must be upheld and kept inviolable. It reminded counsel that any act which tends to obstruct, pervert, impede and degrade the administration of justice is contumacious, calling for disciplinary action and the application of the contempt power.

Doctrine

A judgment that has become final and executory can no longer be annulled or set aside through repeated petitions filed before different branches of the courts. The proclamation of a property as an area for priority development does not, by itself, deprive the court that rendered a final judgment of ejectment of its jurisdiction to enforce that judgment.

The filing of multiple petitions and complaints to obtain favorable action, or to delay the execution of a final judgment, is a trifling with judicial processes that the courts will not countenance. A lawyer who wittingly or willingly promotes or files a groundless suit, or who delays any man's cause, violates the lawyer's oath and may be censured and warned by the Supreme Court.

Disposition

The petition was dismissed, the petitioners' counsel of record was strongly censured and warned that a similar infraction in the future would be dealt with most severely, and double costs were imposed against the petitioners.

Remember This

The single line worth memorizing is that the lawyer's oath is a sacred trust, not a mere fictile of words, and that repeated petitions to delay a final judgment are a trifling with judicial processes. Examiners like to use this case in legal ethics and remedial law, on the duties of a lawyer not to file groundless suits and not to delay any man's cause, and on the finality of judgments.