RAMON CORPORAL, PETITIONER, VS. EMPLOYEES’ COMPENSATION COMMISSION AND GOVERNMENT SERVICE INSURANCE SYSTEM, RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Corporal versus Employees' Compensation Commission
The Case
This is a petition for certiorari filed by Ramon Corporal against the Employees' Compensation Commission and the Government Service Insurance System, questioning the Commission's decision denying his claim for death benefits under Presidential Decree Number 626, as amended. The case matters because it fixes the two and only two routes to compensability of sickness and death under the present employees' compensation regime, and it marks the end of the old presumption of compensability and the doctrine of aggravation that belonged to the repealed Workmen's Compensation Act. It is also a case about the limits of liberal construction: social legislation is read in favor of the worker, but not where the law is clear.
Procedural History
Ramon Corporal filed a claim for compensation benefit with the Government Service Insurance System. The System denied the claim, ruling that the cause of death was not an occupational disease under Presidential Decree Number 626 and that the position of teacher did not increase the risk of the ailment. He filed several motions for reconsideration, which failed after a re-evaluation by the Medical Evaluation and Underwriting Group of the System. He then appealed to the Employees' Compensation Commission, which directed the System to re-evaluate the claim and to elevate the whole record if denial was reiterated. The System reiterated its denial, and the Commission, in a decision rendered in September 1988, likewise denied the claim. From that decision, Ramon Corporal came to the Supreme Court by petition for certiorari.
Facts
Norma Peralta Corporal was a public school teacher. In late November 1977 she was confined at the Esteves Memorial Hospital for acute coronary insufficiency and premature ventricular contractions. In June 1983 she was assigned to the Banadero Elementary School in Daraga, Albay, and she had to walk three kilometers to and from the school because no transportation was available from the national highway. During her fourth pregnancy she suffered a complete abortion and was hospitalized for two days. After her maternity leave she reported back to work.
In March 1984 she conceived again. In September of that year she was transferred to the Kilicao Elementary School, where she had to walk more than one kilometer of rough road. On December 2, 1984, she gave birth to a baby boy with the help of a hilot, a traditional birth attendant. An hour later she was rushed to the Immaculate Conception Hospital due to profuse vaginal bleeding. She underwent a hysterectomy but died on the same day due to shock and severe hemorrhage resulting from a prolapsed uterus post partum. She was forty years old.
Her husband claimed death benefits. He contended that as early as January 1984, before her fifth pregnancy, he had noticed a spherical tissue like a tomato protruding from her vagina and rectum, which he attributed to her long walks over rutted, rocky, flooded and slippery roads to and from the school on the side of Mayon Volcano, and that she continued to discharge her duties despite her pregnancy and her condition.
Issues
- Whether or not the death of Norma Corporal is compensable under Presidential Decree Number 626, as amended, on the ground that her working conditions increased the risk of contracting her illness, although the illness is not among the occupational diseases listed by the Employees' Compensation Commission.
- Whether or not the denial of the claim violates the constitutional provision on social justice and the rule of liberal construction of labor and social welfare legislation.
Applicable Provisions
The decision applies Presidential Decree Number 626, as amended, which governs sickness and death compensation and requires the claimant to show either a listed occupational disease or an increased risk from working conditions. The Court states the governing rule in these words:
Under P.D. No. 626, as amended, for sickness and the resulting death of an employee to be compensable, the claimant must show either: (a) that it is a result of an occupational disease listed under Annex A of the Amended Rules on Employees' Compensation with the conditions set therein satisfied; or (b) that the risk of contracting the disease is increased by the working conditions.
This two-tier requirement is the test the Court applied to the claim, and the claim failed on the second tier.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the death is not compensable. The petitioner admitted that the ailment is not listed as compensable and anchored his claim solely on the increased risk theory, so he had to positively show that the risk of contracting the illness was increased by the working conditions, and he failed to discharge that burden. The Court ruled that the principle of aggravation and the presumption of compensability under the old Workmen's Compensation Act no longer apply. The long walks, whether six kilometers daily or a shorter distance of more than one kilometer, were not sufficient to establish that they caused the prolapse of the uterus, and the petitioner presented no medical findings on his claim of a protruding tomato-like tissue. Relying on medical authorities, the Court found that the prolapse resulted from childbirth injury to the pelvic floor, from multiparity, and from the laxity of structures with age, so that whether the prolapse came before or after the fifth pregnancy was immaterial.
On the second issue, the Court held that the denial does not offend social justice. While labor and social welfare legislation is as a rule liberally construed in favor of the applicant, the Court declared:
While as a rule labor and social welfare legislation should be liberally construed in favor of the applicant, there is also the rule that such liberal construction and interpretation of labor laws may not be applied where the pertinent provisions of the Labor Code and P.D. No. 626, as amended, are clear and leave no room for interpretation.
The Court commiserated with the petitioner and his children and recognized the importance of the services of public elementary school teachers despite their meager salaries, but it could only suggest, not mandate, that the respondents grant ex gratia some form of relief to members similarly situated.
Doctrine
Under Presidential Decree Number 626, as amended, compensability of sickness and resulting death requires the claimant to show either that the illness is an occupational disease listed in Annex A of the Amended Rules on Employees' Compensation with its conditions satisfied, or that the risk of contracting the disease is increased by the working conditions. The burden of proving increased risk rests on the claimant and must be met with positive evidence, including medical findings where the causal link is contested. The presumption of compensability and the principle of aggravation under the old Workmen's Compensation Act no longer apply. Liberal construction in favor of the worker yields where the pertinent provisions of the Labor Code and Presidential Decree Number 626 are clear and leave no room for interpretation.
Disposition
The petition was denied, and the denial by the Employees' Compensation Commission of the claim for death benefits was sustained.
Remember This
Memorize the two-tier test: a listed occupational disease with its conditions satisfied, or a risk increased by the working conditions, with the burden on the claimant and no presumption of compensability. Examiners use this case to test the shift from the old Workmen's Compensation Act to Presidential Decree Number 626, and to test the limits of liberal construction in social legislation.